Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › General Discussion › Off topic › Your Favorite single Review
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Your Favorite single Review

post #1 of 66
Thread Starter 
Just for fun, name you favorite review. It can be any single review. A review that made you laugh, one that put you on a mission, one that turned your stomach. Any review will do, just make sure it's your favorite. I will start!

Amouage Gold Men

Egads! Honeyed cat pee. It must be arduous to extract and distil the urine of all those diabetic cats, which would explain the astronomical price. This is alleged to contain hundreds of ingredients, but to my nose it's civet, buckets of musty powder and aldehydes...and a little more powder. Civet + powder + aldehydic white flowers = The Cat Peed in Grandma's Closet. Bombastic and unbalanced for a full eight hours. Shocking as the flagship of the line that contains the marvelous Dia and Jubilation XXV. Oddly enough, the women's version is quite good on my wife. Go figure.

I chuckle every time I read it. Thanks Vibert, your review made me buy a sample just to smell this concoction of diabetic pee in grandmas closet.
post #2 of 66
Any review by Naed Nitram (although, I admit, far more than one single review) could easily qualify for this title
post #3 of 66
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ken_Russell View Post

Any review by Naed Nitram (although, I admit, far more than one single review) could easily qualify for this title

post one!
post #4 of 66
A lot of SirSlarty's reviews crack me up.

My favorite, is for Kenzo Jungle L'Elephant:

"Whoa, slow down there cinnamon. Don't get too close to those cloves... ah damn see? Now you two... argh stay away from that licorice... argh! Now you three smell really bad. Guess we need to wash you up in some vanilla. This is very unbearable to me. Don't get this if you dislike cloves."

Perversely, it made me buy a bottle!
post #5 of 66
Vibert's review of Mazzolari Lui. Describes the scent perfectly and is entertaining to read.
post #6 of 66
This one of Pierre Cardin PM by colormechris:

It's a Friday night in 1980. Your best friend calls you and asks you if you want to go to the roller rink and hang out. Cool, you say. What time will you and your Mom pick me up? (Hey, it's a five mile walk...) As you look into your closet trying to decide what to wear, you start thinking of that girl who hangs out a the roller rink and is always checking you out. Maybe she'll be there tonight. You take extra care in picking out your clothes: a skin tight pair of Jordache jeans, a plaid Daniel Hechter sports shirt and your prized gold serpentine chain. As you're putting it on, your eyes fall on the little bottle of Pierre Cardin cologne that you swiped from Woolworth's at the mall. You pick it up and unscrew the chrome top and sniff of it. The aroma is heady. It's kind of lemony and kind of spicy and rich. Nothing like that stuff your Dad has under his bathroom cabinet. That smells like the barber shop. This smells classy, even though it's sort of cheap and you could've paid for it; but after you smelled it in the store something excited you and stealing it only added to the excitement.
You hear the car horn and run downstairs and throw on your red bomber jacket and get in the car. Your friends mother tells you how nice you smell. You blush. Your friend says something about hockey practice. When his Mom drops you off she tells you to keep warm because it's late October and it really is starting to get cold. You go into the rink and it's the usual. Round and round in circles to songs like "I'm Turning Japanese" and "Heart of Glass".
That girl you were thinking about isn't there. There are other girls, equally as interested...but your heart was set on her. Finally, after the hundredth circuit, your friend gets bored and whispers to ask if you want to go behind the building and smoke a joint. Why not?
When you get out there, it's almost too cold to smoke, but you can clearly smell your cologne, almost as strong as when you put it on and somehow even better smelling in the cold air. Your best friend lights the joint and suggests that he shot-gun it to you. You nod. He inhales and you both move in until your faces are almost touching... The next thing you know his lips are on yours. You're full on making out. Your best friend is telling you how awesome you smell and it's like the world has turned upside down in three seconds. Is it your Pierre Cardin? Maybe not...but so much for that girl.
14 October 2007
post #7 of 66
Thread Starter 
@Tony that one is awesome. Thank you for sharing, now where is my Pierre Cardin?
post #8 of 66
My fav is a review is one of Unforgivable by basenoter joela87

"I dont understand all da negativity. Stop hatin on it. Its not 2 be slept on. If you dont want to attract the ladies stay away from it cuz they love it. (@ least on my skin!) had 2 cop da 4.2 "
post #9 of 66
This one by Mario J

******************

It's Halloween and the busty, sexy kindergarten teacher has shown up to class dressed like The Tooth Fairy.

She sniffs something in the air.

Terrified, she recognizes the smell, it's Joop!

Jason Voorhees and Freddy Kreuger enter and make short work of her in front of the horrified children.

Screams and slashes!!!!

OK, cut and print.

The director turns to the screenwriter.

" Sorry dude, but Joop! should have a question mark at the end, not an exclamation point. You're fired! "

The cast breaks for lunch----and even the child actors avoid anything that smells even remotely sweet.

The End.
post #10 of 66
Penhaligon's Blenheim Bouquet by Naed_Nitram.

The Baron de Charlus once told me: 'I recall the time when I was a houseguest at Chartwell, the country estate of Sir Winston Churchill (or "Vesuvius" as we used to call him on account of his volcanic eruptions). He gave us each a bottle of Blenheim Bouquet.
"Tell me, de Charlus," said Sir Winston in that celebrated slurred growl of his, "as a connoissheur of schent, what is your opinion of Blenheim Bouquet? Shum shay it is one of the finest schents in creation - and I concur!" "Then we are of one mind, my dear Vesuvius," I responded. "An opening of clean pure citrus with a truly divine development of warm woods. It has hardly been bettered before or since." Sir Winston looked surprised. "Sho," he said, "you do not intend, then, to asshail me with one of your shelebrated inshults?" "Merely to remark, my dear Vesuvius, given your capacity to engage in some of the fiercest and foulest eruptions known to man, that it is most gracious of you to counteract these assaults on your fellow creatures by bathing yourself in the fragrant ambience of Blenheim Bouquet. It leaves us all wondering whether we are surrounded by citrus or shitrus."
At this, much to my admiration, the famous statesman and bon viveur growled, scowled, guffawed, and threw a steak and kidney pudding at my head.'
post #11 of 66
Quote:
Originally Posted by wooznib View Post

...
Egads! Honeyed cat pee....

This phrase nailed my purchase of Amouage Gold. Even my wife quotes this anytime i wear it
post #12 of 66
I won a competition last year, and the prize was any fragrance in the Le Jardin Retrouve range.Having no previous experience of this house, I had to rely on the available reviews to make my decision. The only review at that time was provided by Naed Nitram for Eau de Vetyver, and It was on the basis of this slightly abstract critique that I made my choice. The review really does capture the essence of this excellent fragrance,and is an entertaining read to boot.

The Review

'The Baron de Charlus once delivered a lecture to the Society of Perfumes in Paris on the subject of Vetyver-Vanille by Le Jardin Retrouve. 'Messieurs and mesdames,' he began, 'indulge me while I engage in another of my impressionistic rambles. Alphonse and Eugenie, you know, the children at the picnic, how they are full of delight on this beautiful summer's day! Creaking hay carts, waving branches, easy majesty of summer. Bitter vetiver, sweet vanilla. Hand in hand they go. Mama and Papa are sipping champagne. The children are hiding in the tall grass of the meadow. Sunlight, shadows and confectionary. Bitter vetiver, sweet vanilla. Little do they know that they will carry this scent with them, this secret poem of childhood, half remembered, through their whole lives - like some deep forgotten yearning.'
post #13 of 66
Those wacky guys at the notorious overstockperfume have taken to writing their own copy. Could provide hours of fun reading:

"Launched by the design house of Alfred Dunhill, Dunhill Classic men Eau De Cologne Spray Old One 3.4 Oz offers masculine scent. An ideal spray for office wear, it is a mixture of various flowers such as Cinnamon, Sandalwood, Basil, Sage and Clove. Dunhill Classic men by Alfred Dunhill Eau De Cologne Spray Old One, it can be used by career oriented and fashionable men due to its breathtaking and marvelous aroma. Due to having lustful and fresh scent, it is the first choice of legendary and popular men. So, take this fresh aroma and turn every one’s nose with full of jealous."


My nose is already full of jealous.
post #14 of 66
Thread Starter 
@ inselaffe Wonderful review, thank you for sharing.
@ Forlorn that's great. I need to be legendary, so I am off to purchase.
post #15 of 66
Every single piece of writing by Hillaire.
I hope to see a collection of her reviews in print some day.

My other favourite reviewer is Shamu. Just perfect.

Regards,
Pawel
post #16 of 66
[QUOTE=RoteRosen;1770732]Every single piece of writing by Hillaire.
I hope to see a collection of her reviews in print some day.

I totally agree... and would like to encourage Hillaire to publish a collection of her reviews in book-form.
Turin/Sanchez would get cold feet...
post #17 of 66
Thread Starter 
@ Roterosen and Jale' as much as I agree, can you pick 1? your favorite
post #18 of 66
I agree that Hillaire's reviews, particularly her reviews of men's scents, are great. I've considered her review of Krizia Uomo to be like a benchmark review of that scent.
post #19 of 66
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by shamu1 View Post

I agree that Hillaire's reviews, particularly her reviews of men's scents, are great. I've considered her review of Krizia Uomo to be like a benchmark review of that scent.

Hillaire's Review of Krizia Uomo
I wonder:

Whatever happened to the sensible notion of pine-smells? Although everything comes and goes in the fickle world of perfume fashion, the healing properties of coniferous freshness strike me as obvious, necessary, and ancient -- almost indispensable in their role in bodily ablutions. When did caramels and bourbons become more desirable than pine?

Krizia Uomo relieves us from modern nonsense; it imparts the salubrious magic of pines and conifers in a most delectable, fit-for-a-king, powerhouse of a scent.
When I think of elaborate, Roman bath rituals, when complex, herbal remedies and mixtures of fragrant oils were customized for royalty by revered, mystical, court perfumers... I imagine the emperors were given something quite like Krizia Uomo. I suspect it would have -- all at once -- cured the common cold, doubled as a rheumatism salve, balanced the humours, and sent courtesans into inexorable, writhing, fits of lust.

And it smells fantastic! I like it for myself even... in very, very tiny doses. I feel like it puts me in focus, and mobilizes my viscous catarrh .
Aa rewarding, if daunting journey for the adventurous smell-traveler.
02 November 2009
post #20 of 66
Thread Starter 
@ Hillaire's Review - I will blind buy this lol
post #21 of 66
Quote:
Originally Posted by wooznib View Post

@ Hillaire's Review - I will blind buy this lol

Hillaire nailed it with Krizia Uomo! I've actually referred other BN'ers to her review of this scent.

I'll warn you, though - KU is quite a bold fragrance (in my review, I said it slams into your sinuses like a plane crash). That being said, I bought it blind, based on Hillaire's review!
post #22 of 66
My favorite review of all time in foetidus' review of Aoud Damascus. He wrote:

Truly the most beautiful presentation of the rose that I have encountered. Usually I find rose fragrances to be too abundant and opulent to be tolerated in a fragrance, but the Damascus rose note in Aoud Damascus is rendered with incredible genius. The deep sumptuous rose accord is kept from getting too lascivious by being touched with a perfect green; the etherealness of incense is kept at an elegant minimum, the airy depth of aoud is held in abeyance (after its opening blast) to provide an impeccable background. And yet with all this control, these powerful notes are kept whole and pure. This fragrance is a model of the ingenious artistry in transforming the potency of nature to a human reach—presenting that power with sensitivity, delicacy, and awe-inspiring creativity. Opulence and luxuriousness transformed into rich elegance and refinement.

When people tell me that I am a total loser for liking Aoud Damascus, I simply point them to this review by foetidus.
post #23 of 66
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by scentsitivity View Post

My favorite review of all time in foetidus' review of Aoud Damascus. He wrote:

Truly the most beautiful presentation of the rose that I have encountered. Usually I find rose fragrances to be too abundant and opulent to be tolerated in a fragrance, but the Damascus rose note in Aoud Damascus is rendered with incredible genius. The deep sumptuous rose accord is kept from getting too lascivious by being touched with a perfect green; the etherealness of incense is kept at an elegant minimum, the airy depth of aoud is held in abeyance (after its opening blast) to provide an impeccable background. And yet with all this control, these powerful notes are kept whole and pure. This fragrance is a model of the ingenious artistry in transforming the potency of nature to a human reach—presenting that power with sensitivity, delicacy, and awe-inspiring creativity. Opulence and luxuriousness transformed into rich elegance and refinement.

When people tell me that I am a total loser for liking Aoud Damascus, I simply point them to this review by foetidus.

Thank you for sharing this one scentsitivity. I am really wanting to try Aoud Damascus now.
post #24 of 66
From the always funny and usually spot-on TVLAMPBOY:

Zino Davidoff by Davidoff
Lush and dark and (surprisingly) both casual and formal at the same time. But n one here has, thus far, picked up on what I smell in Davidoff -- a wild, almost sweaty sexual abandon that others always attribute to Musc Ravageur. This is an almost feral scent I'm talking about, rather like a civet, or very like the uber-masculine ferality many (rightfully) see in Muscs Koublai Khan.

Whatever it is that I'm smelling (and I like it!), it renders this scent (at least for me) unwearable except in the most, eh, compromising of situations. NOT a frag to wear when Sister Mary Annunciata comes by to pick up charity donations for St. Vincent de Paul, if you know what I mean, and far too randy for even a Neighborhood Association meeting. No, this is definitely a rich, decadent, "down and dirty" sweaty sex scent, or at least a damn good cruising smell. (In my book, anyway.)
02 November 2006
post #25 of 66
Good thread Wooznib

I'll pick one from a favorite reviewer of mine, The Gabba Goul :

Sexy, sweet, almost magical...this scent is a mysterious hike through a forest at "the blue hour" just as day melts away into night...the smell is mysterious, night birds chirping, mythelogical creatures scampering through the forest...deffinately a storybook, sexy and youthful, this cool, fresh, woodsy scent will transport you to a different world whenever you spray it on...


The review here is for Lalique le Faune. Reading those words, I sure would want that fragrance. I really appreciate how The_Gabba_Goul wrote with descriptions of images and feelings in some of his reviews. Too bad he is long gone. Would love to read more of this type.
post #26 of 66
Thread Starter 
Great pick Surfacing.
Keep em coming guys!
Maybe some of the reviewers have favorites as well.
Turn me on to something new.
post #27 of 66
Quote:
Originally Posted by wooznib View Post

Hillaire's Review of Krizia Uomo
I wonder:

Whatever happened to the sensible notion of pine-smells? Although everything comes and goes in the fickle world of perfume fashion, the healing properties of coniferous freshness strike me as obvious, necessary, and ancient -- almost indispensable in their role in bodily ablutions. When did caramels and bourbons become more desirable than pine?

Krizia Uomo relieves us from modern nonsense; it imparts the salubrious magic of pines and conifers in a most delectable, fit-for-a-king, powerhouse of a scent.
When I think of elaborate, Roman bath rituals, when complex, herbal remedies and mixtures of fragrant oils were customized for royalty by revered, mystical, court perfumers... I imagine the emperors were given something quite like Krizia Uomo. I suspect it would have -- all at once -- cured the common cold, doubled as a rheumatism salve, balanced the humours, and sent courtesans into inexorable, writhing, fits of lust.

And it smells fantastic! I like it for myself even... in very, very tiny doses. I feel like it puts me in focus, and mobilizes my viscous catarrh .
Aa rewarding, if daunting journey for the adventurous smell-traveler.
02 November 2009

I would just like to say that I've heard it called many things, but "viscous catarrh" certainly is a first.
post #28 of 66
I just read this very cool thread with flattering-to-me parts (blushing), and I'd like to thank the sweet folks here so much for this surprising encouragement and kindness!
I am sooo tickled!
post #29 of 66
Jailia by Vibert

The imagery alone made me want to try this one - I was hearing Jobim & Astrud Gilberto as I read the review, and the irony is that Vibert admits this is not even to his particular taste . . .

L'Heure Bleue by hirch_duckfinder

You don't really need to talk about notes and accords with LHB and the end line was the clincher for me . . . to be read while listening to Debussy
post #30 of 66
Philosykos by Diptyque (Mario Justiniani)

I wish I could say that to me, it doesn't smell like figs, it smells like. . .dry grass and tomato leaves.

But

a. SniffQ already said that.

b. The potted plant smell ( whether it's dry gass or tomato) is present in virtually all the offerings by Diptyque.

c. We mut be wrong, since:

1. Olivia Giacobetti is a genius.

and

2. The majority of reviewers wax happily about the pronounced fig smell !

They're only differ-- or confess to being unsure--- as to whether it's creamy, simple, woodsy, dry, wet, complex; reminiscent of coconuts ( or almonds or peaches or bananas or...?) astringent, musky, has cedar, does not have cedar . projects great sillage, rides close to the skin; is more interesting than Marc Jacobs ( well, what the hell isn't?) but perhaps not more so than Jo Malone or Premier Figuier.

Sacre Bleu!

I beileve I have been niched.
post #31 of 66
I like this one by only_me, which hasn't loaded up yet...

Yves Saint Laurent: Jazz Prestige

Among those, for whom the pursuit of the now-obsolete olfactory treasures has become a source of constant fascination -- nay, dare I venture? -- obsession, the discovery of a still-boxed, fresh, full bottle of Jazz Prestige would be comparable to a car-boot-fare scenario, in which Steve Buscemi's 'Seymour' discovers a mint copy of an early John Coltrane album released on the original 'Prestige' record label.

Indeed, in Terry Zwigoff's remarkable, Ghost World (2001), we would see 'Seymour', the vintage-loving music collector, first admire the album's sleeve and 50s artwork; witness his thorough inspection of the disc for any scratches, etc., feeling the weight of 'old' vinyl as it slipped carefully from its inner, paper sleeve into his vigilant-yet-delicate grip and, finally, get to see him playing it on his old 'Hi-Fi' equipment. Escaping into 'the sound of the day', marveling at the 'sheets of sound' from Coltrane's tenor as captured by analogue -NOT digital - recording techniques. Buscemi's trademark over-crowded teeth breaking into an inexorable, easy grin to the infectious “swing” of the music.

Such is the quality of Jazz Prestige, a sadly discontinued bottle of pure “hard-bop” perfume, and a master class in olfactive intricate harmonies and delft key changes, that twists and turns just like Coltrane's solos, as the 'nose' in question threw everything but the proverbial “kitchen sink” into this creation and managed somehow to 'pull it off'. With engaging outcomes!

So, I cannot help imaging a film, an ‘alternate-universe’ Ghost World, in which the 'Seymour' character is like me and into perfumes. Buscemi's Seymour, with his fascination with all things lost, and disthymic, laconic tone would provide the perfect commentary on vintage scents!

For the benefit of the lost-yet-inquisitive 'Enid' (Thora Birch), after judiciously spraying 'Prestige onto both their wrists…

"You see...right off it’s citrusy and bright: “aromatic. green.”, and kinda deeply floral, oddly, with that heavy, ylang-ylang head note...and don't be fooled by the box, this is a unisex fragrance despite the 90s, bull***t, marketing-label crap. Yeah...here we go....this baby becomes an 'Oriental', smell all the pepper and spices?...but here....check this out now...yeah, you get the 'apples', but wait for the chypre notes...you dig the 'leather', right? That's genius; leather chypres were really cool in the 50s/60s because of a guy called 'Chant'...but here's the thing: this is no pure chypre either...tell me what you think in a couple of hours, when this dries down...you'll get a pure fougere...that's right, the coumarin-oakmoss- tonka bean vibe that made Paco Rabanne famous...only this is a thousand times better. Yeah, most numbskulls just know Paco and Drakkar, but to make an oriental-to-chypre-to-fougere that lasts...well, this is just… this is just pure class!

“No please, friend...take it: it's for you!"
post #32 of 66
Vibert's my favorite reviewer. He pulls no punches. One good example:

Pi by Givenchy

Pi may well represent the nadir of sickeningly sweet masculine gourmand orientals. Even if you despise A*Men, Lolita Lempicka au Masculin, Rochas Man, and their ilk, you have to credit them with a degree of intricacy – sometimes to excess – in their structures. Not so Pi. It’s just unrelentingly sweet artificial vanilla extract and talcum powder, in a combination that manages by some perverse miracle to be at once bland and grating. I suppose there must be art in that, but surely it’s an art too diabolical to pursue further.
post #33 of 66
Here's an oldie but goodie from Naed_Nitram of Anucci Man. It makes me wish I had a Derringer up my sleeve while playing five card stud:


Definitely a Parisian dandy's scent. Baudelaire could have written a poem about it. But it does not have the same obvious aura of sheer decadence and sensuality that a dandy's scent like Sybaris by Puig has. By comparison, Anucci is almost fastidious: sweet, flowery, rich, delicate, and pervaded by what someone called an unusual amaretto note. Very unique, but too sweet and strange for many men. A mood scent. Some women like to wear it. But, then again, according to reviews on certain sites (less dignified than the estimable Basenotes) Anucci sometimes functions as a babe magnet or damsel drooler or, even more poetically, as a cutecake crumbler. Possibly also worn by foppish gamblers in Dodge City in the 1870s (imported from Paris, of course).
04 December 2004

***************************

Cheers,

Mario
post #34 of 66
This is a great thread!

My favorite review, ever, is of Le Labo's Oud 27, written by Luca Turin:

Some years back I got a crisply-written email from a young woman in the US who explained that she was selling her soiled panties on the Internet to pay for her (college, judging by her vocabulary) education. She deplored the fact that she couldn't scale up the process and asked me whether I knew of any material that would help. I replied that I was myself, for non-commercial reasons, on the trail of such a thing and that I would keep in touch. Oud 27 makes me think I may be getting warm. Three minutes into it, after a wonderfully bitter, inky blast at the start, Oud 27 becomes properly pornographic: a wet-hair note and a couple of macrocyclic musks of the kind found near the rear end of deer take over, adding up to a sensational sweet-animalic note. The composition then behaves as if its been interrupted in midaction, hastily buttons up and acts natural thereafter, nonchalantly pretending to be a woody fragrance.

Great fun, brilliant perfumery and, for once, really raunchy.
post #35 of 66
I honestly think we have some of the very best reviewers of any consumer good, gracing our presence on Basenotes. I'm sure if Grant ever wanted to pursue it, with the permission of all those included, could create a BN "guide" full of user reviews, and it would far surpass that of the original Guide.
post #36 of 66
Quote:
Originally Posted by KMF View Post

Philosykos by Diptyque (Mario Justiniani)

I wish I could say that to me, it doesn't smell like figs, it smells like. . .dry grass and tomato leaves.

But

a. SniffQ already said that.

b. The potted plant smell ( whether it's dry gass or tomato) is present in virtually all the offerings by Diptyque.

c. We mut be wrong, since:

1. Olivia Giacobetti is a genius.

and

2. The majority of reviewers wax happily about the pronounced fig smell !

They're only differ-- or confess to being unsure--- as to whether it's creamy, simple, woodsy, dry, wet, complex; reminiscent of coconuts ( or almonds or peaches or bananas or...?) astringent, musky, has cedar, does not have cedar . projects great sillage, rides close to the skin; is more interesting than Marc Jacobs ( well, what the hell isn't?) but perhaps not more so than Jo Malone or Premier Figuier.

Sacre Bleu!

I beileve I have been niched.

I too, LOVE this review. Though, I completely disagree, I think Philosykos is ALL about figs, but that's why this hobby is so interesting! This is a great one.
post #37 of 66
Yes I know, only one but I'm an indecisive Libra
Moreover, while the admirable foetidus, Vibert and tvlampboy have been rightly mentioned,
I wanted to pay tribute to our other five most prolific reviewers.
It's a way of saying " thank you." Here goes:

SirSlarty (1815 reviews) on Tobacco Vanille by Tom Ford:

" It's like I smoked a cheap cigar right after smoking a pipe in a crushed velvet chair and then had the keen idea of spraying on some of Coty Raw Vanilla. I'm torn between a pleasing scent and a rip-your-heart-out high price. "

Trebor (1581 reviews) on Spezie by Lorenzo Villoresi

" I'm sorry but wearing Spezie makes me feel like I've been generously seasoned by a group of hungry cannibals.
As much as I like to smell irresistible, this is taking things a little too far... "

ubandimeme (907 reviews) on Luscious Pink by Mariah Carey

" Mariah Carey has now officially branded her name onto one of the pink cattle whos' herd is stampeding the current feminine fragrance market. Does anybody own a tranquilizer gun? "

Diamondflame (896 reviews) on Eau d'Hadrien by Annick Goutal

" In the words of my girlfriend, this smells like the car perfume in her mom's Nissan. While I don't entirely agree with her, I must admit there's more than an ounce of truth in that observation. Bland citrus blended to perfection. "

and odysseum ( 609 reviews) on Vétiver by Givenchy

"This has a sparkling-green vetiver opening that is quite delightful! Green citrus notes (lemon, aromatic bergamot) and green leaves and herbal notes contribute to this excellent beginning. It is refreshing and most enjoyable. The scent develops into a lovely warm, comforting cushion. There is a haunting yet invigorating dusky-tangy quality that is so appealing! Light sandalwood is here: soapy, woody, aromatic. IMO this far surpasses Guerlain Vetiver. Those who like it, like it a lot; and with reason. Re-released recently. "
********************
Once again, my thanks for the time and effort of all the reviewers!

Cheers,

Mario
post #38 of 66
How thoughtful of you, Mario! Thank you.
Here's one of yours which cracked me up everytime I read it.

Quorum by Antonio Puig

Some fragrances are referred to as " Sex in a bottle." This is crotch in a bottle.

- Mario Justiniani, 19 June 2009


And the review that led me to one of my best blind buys:-

Musk to Musk by Montale

Beautifully soft accord of rose petals in combination with lovely tinge of oudh and woody notes. it's soft and sensual. you would never get tired of this one. get it while it's available. easily one of those montales which i wouldnt mind going for a 100ml. Think of it as Black oudh super light

- Jenson, 18 August 2009
post #39 of 66
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tonyprince View Post

This one of Pierre Cardin PM by colormechris:

It's a Friday night in 1980. Your best friend calls you and asks you if you want to go to the roller rink and hang out. Cool, you say. What time will you and your Mom pick me up? (Hey, it's a five mile walk...) As you look into your closet trying to decide what to wear, you start thinking of that girl who hangs out a the roller rink and is always checking you out. Maybe she'll be there tonight. You take extra care in picking out your clothes: a skin tight pair of Jordache jeans, a plaid Daniel Hechter sports shirt and your prized gold serpentine chain. As you're putting it on, your eyes fall on the little bottle of Pierre Cardin cologne that you swiped from Woolworth's at the mall. You pick it up and unscrew the chrome top and sniff of it. The aroma is heady. It's kind of lemony and kind of spicy and rich. Nothing like that stuff your Dad has under his bathroom cabinet. That smells like the barber shop. This smells classy, even though it's sort of cheap and you could've paid for it; but after you smelled it in the store something excited you and stealing it only added to the excitement.
You hear the car horn and run downstairs and throw on your red bomber jacket and get in the car. Your friends mother tells you how nice you smell. You blush. Your friend says something about hockey practice. When his Mom drops you off she tells you to keep warm because it's late October and it really is starting to get cold. You go into the rink and it's the usual. Round and round in circles to songs like "I'm Turning Japanese" and "Heart of Glass".
That girl you were thinking about isn't there. There are other girls, equally as interested...but your heart was set on her. Finally, after the hundredth circuit, your friend gets bored and whispers to ask if you want to go behind the building and smoke a joint. Why not?
When you get out there, it's almost too cold to smoke, but you can clearly smell your cologne, almost as strong as when you put it on and somehow even better smelling in the cold air. Your best friend lights the joint and suggests that he shot-gun it to you. You nod. He inhales and you both move in until your faces are almost touching... The next thing you know his lips are on yours. You're full on making out. Your best friend is telling you how awesome you smell and it's like the world has turned upside down in three seconds. Is it your Pierre Cardin? Maybe not...but so much for that girl.
14 October 2007


This is one of the best things I have ever read. For anything.
post #40 of 66
Mine is Vibert's "L'Eau D'Issey pour homme":

"If youve followed my Basenotes reviews knows youll know that Im no fan of aquatic scents, and hence not predisposed to enjoy LEau dIssey. Indeed, I find its brash, synthetic, calone drenched opening repugnant. To me it smells less like the ocean than like an industrial chemical. (Which I suppose is exactly what calone is.) I dont detect much change as the scent ages, except perhaps for a few bright flowers and a helping of artificial fruit flavoring. (Think green Lifesavers.) Two or three hours later Im left with a harsh woody (cypress?) base, but as Issey transforms it passes through a phase that I can best describe as rotting seaweed.

One thing I especially dislike about LEau dIssey is that its ozonic note is not even minimally blended. The result is crass and crude, as if LEau dIssey has its naked butt up against the school bus window, mooning any motorist unlucky enough to pass. Paradoxically, I have to give the scent some credit for its brashness its far less bland than the thousands of limp aquatic imitators that have come in its wake. As much as I dislike it, I must also acknowledge LEau dIsseys significance in the history of scent. It is a landmark composition that epitomizes the past decades dominant fragrance genre. So though I rate it very low, its not so much because I think it smells bad (which I do), but because there are so many more well-constructed, nuanced, and sophisticated clean aquatic scents to choose from."

Genius
post #41 of 66
Forgot single favorite in poetry

From pluran

When all the others let you down
Patou Pour Homme came to town
Its deep and complex
As good as some sex
Herbal, spicy, and woody
Oh man, its a goody
The evolutions profound
Tenacious and sound
The drydowns ourtrageous
Extended and contagious
It makes you feel good
The way that you should
Theres no doubt about it
Itll give you some wood
Its the bomb
Exotic, and full of aplomb
The best Ive worn
And Ive no need to mourn
For I own five bottles
And can spray with full throttle
post #42 of 66
My mistake. The Best Review in Poetry:

Vera Wang for Men by Vera Wang
This is the story of Vera Wang:
Starts with a whispering lemony tang,
Turns to a tobacco and woody affair
But there's nothing spectacular going on there.
It's pleasant enough, my nose surmises,
But hardly deserving of any first prizes.
I find it not so much understated
As overpriced and overrated.
More than a whimper, less than a bang,
And that is the story of Vera Wang.

By Naed_Nitram
post #43 of 66
Nearly anything by Naed_Nitram will do. Here's one blasting One Man Show by Jacques Bogart:
Quote:
One Man Show by Jacques Bogart


ARISTOCRAT SHOOTS FRAGRANCE AT LEARNED SOCIETY! Police were called last night to the Society of Perfumes in Paris following the shooting of the fragrance One Man Show by the eccentric aesthete Baron de Charlus. Eyewitnesses report that de Charlus was heard shouting: 'I refuse any longer to dignify this sinus-destroying syrup with words!' Producing a revolver, he tossed a bottle of One Man Show in the air and shot it to pieces. 'I have no regrets,' de Charlus was reported as saying later, 'I only wish I had shot it sooner!' One Man Show is believed to be in a critical condition but the House of Bogart are confident it will recover.
post #44 of 66
Another great one, Santino on Kouros:

"On a cold winter evening, you went to meet a newly met acquaintance to their house. You sit down in their living room, playing with your mug of coffee. You dont know these people so well. You are constantly watching your mannerism: thinking twice before speaking, watching your gestures and posture, your body slightly tense due to the air of discomfort. Suddenly, you have an urge to empty your bladder. Very politely, you ask your hosts to direct you towards their bathroom. They do so with utmost courteousness.
You enter the bathroom and frisk the walls in darkness searching for the light switch. The bathroom being dark yet, you cannot see anything but you can smell. A combination of smells hit your sinuses. Smell of clean toilet , smell of air freshener, smell of soaps and lotions laying on the edge of the bath tub and the natural musky smell coming off the undergarments belonging to the owner of the bathroom. It is a combination of these smells, but while you perform your restroom ritual, you take time to analyse each smell according the its source. You feel oddly comfortable with this foreign aroma. Slowly, the cords of your discomfort loosen up and you feel an abstract intimacy with these smells. You are feeling intrigued, amused and slightly embarrassed at the same time. Now that your restroom ritual has ended, you get up, wash your hands and look in the mirror to check your appearance. Satisfied, you wipe your hands with a tissue paper and leave the bathroom.
Now that you have been through the olfactory experience of one the private areas of your acquaintance's house, you take your seat with a broader smile. You grab the mug of your coffee. Now your new acquaintance has become your friend."
post #45 of 66
I'm attracted to simplicity. Allan's Review of Moustache in the basenotes directory:

"horse pee and grapefruit, together at last!"
post #46 of 66
Quote:
Originally Posted by lovingthealien View Post

I'm attracted to simplicity. Allan's Review of Moustache in the basenotes directory:

"horse pee and grapefruit, together at last!"

LMAO
post #47 of 66
Habit Rouge has attracted a lot of amusing negative reviews, eg:

'EDC:

Ghoulishly sweet and morbid. Smells like something an aging queen would spray in his nether regions before an evening at the adult bookstore.

Totally, irredeemably repulsive.'
post #48 of 66
Foetidus and off-scenter wrote reviews that left me in awe. I remember this this from when I first joined
post #49 of 66
Nilla Goon's short, scathing review of Jubilation 25 (now missing) where he states that it

"flawlessy recreates walking through the potpourri aisle at Bed, Bath and Beyond."
post #50 of 66
Nobody does Mugler like Hunter, Jack Hunter.
Jack's take on A*men

'The most vile and disgusting fragrance
ever to be created and only the devil
in the depths of hell would wear this.
It's toxic and vomit inducing.'
post #51 of 66
Quote:
Originally Posted by dmarino67 View Post

Nilla Goon's short, scathing review of Jubilation XXV (now missing)

I'm honored! And impressed at the accuracy of your recall.

I recently revisited this one, so the review's gone back into the year-long moderation queue. Unfortunately, with the update it's no longer so short:

Flawlessly recreates the experience of walking down the potpourri aisle at Bed, Bath, and Beyond. The perfect scent for a plump, fortyish American woman living in Ohio who "does a lot of crafts" and has Strawberry Shortcake figurines in her kitchen. If only she could afford it...

2012 update: I often find that revisiting a fragrance leaves me with a very different impression. But in this case, "BB&B potpourri" seems uncannily accurate. It's not that Jubilation XXV smells bad. In fact, it smells good, in a mass-market, functional-fragrance kind of way. I'm not sure what to think. Either my nose is off or BB&B potpourri is indeed a masterpiece of aromascience.

Jubilation XXV loses some of its "sweet berry" note in the drydown, and it's all the better for it. Still, Duchaufour has done better, and Amouage has done better. Save your money and check out some of Duchaufour's creations for L'Artisan Parfumeur or CdG's Incense series.

This is a great thread. I miss Vibert. :-(
post #52 of 66
I find the incipit of Secretion Magnifique by Off-Scenter to be absolutely brilliant...

"Mine smells better"
post #53 of 66
Great reading it again. I agree with the update.

Quote:
Originally Posted by NillaGoon View Post

I'm honored! And impressed at the accuracy of your recall.

I recently revisited this one, so the review's gone back into the year-long moderation queue. Unfortunately, with the update it's no longer so short:

Flawlessly recreates the experience of walking down the potpourri aisle at Bed, Bath, and Beyond. The perfect scent for a plump, fortyish American woman living in Ohio who "does a lot of crafts" and has Strawberry Shortcake figurines in her kitchen. If only she could afford it...

2012 update: I often find that revisiting a fragrance leaves me with a very different impression. But in this case, "BB&B potpourri" seems uncannily accurate. It's not that Jubilation XXV smells bad. In fact, it smells good, in a mass-market, functional-fragrance kind of way. I'm not sure what to think. Either my nose is off or BB&B potpourri is indeed a masterpiece of aromascience.

Jubilation XXV loses some of its "sweet berry" note in the drydown, and it's all the better for it. Still, Duchaufour has done better, and Amouage has done better. Save your money and check out some of Duchaufour's creations for L'Artisan Parfumeur or CdG's Incense series.

This is a great thread. I miss Vibert. :-(
post #54 of 66
For me, nothing quite reaches the heights of lisawhip's review of MDCI Promesse de l'Aube:

Quote:
Originally Posted by lisawhip

I call this Eau de Spiteful Grandmother. At the topnote, it tells an eight-year-old that she looks fat in her dance recital costume. Then the heartnote opens up, and you get a very strong complaint of having had to ride on an elevator with a (whisper) *black*. The basenote lets its horrid little dog bite you and tells you that it couldn't possibly have hurt. At the drydown, right before it fades, it gives all the jewelry to its friends's daughter because you never admired it even once.

I hate myself in this scent and would take great pleasure in not giving myself a seat on the bus.
post #55 of 66
There are a number of reviews I hold in high esteem, and I cannot choose among them. So many reviews of fragrances become literary miniatures of a sort, mingling poetry, philosophy and vivid prose. However, the following review has made me laugh whenever I've read it, and is probably my single favourite comical review.


Quote:
Originally Posted by Naed_Nitram


Royal Scottish Lavender by Creed

The Baron de Charlus once told me: 'I recall the time when I was a houseguest at the Balmoral estate of Queen Victoria (or "Quack Quack" as we used to call her on account of the fact that she reminded us of a small stout duck). She gave us each a bottle of Creed's Royal Scottish Lavender.
"We are curious to know, de Charlus," demanded the Queen, "whether this fragrance, reputedly commissioned by ourself in memory of our dear Prince Albert, meets with your fastidious approval." "It is well known, my dear Quack Quack," I responded, "that sadly many Creed scents suffer from one of two faults: either from the infamous Creed arse note or from an incurable air of stuffiness. In the case of Royal Scottish Lavender, the infamous arse note is mercifully lacking, but not so the air of stuffiness. If I let my imagination wander, I conjure the following image: three of us are seated together in the royal train travelling through the Highlands: my own elegant self, your prim and portly personage dressed in widow's weeds, and the serious shade of your dear deceased consort Albert. The tenacious scent of Royal Scottish Lavender fills our compartment,strangely combining a sharp, natural air with an over-civilized medicinal and stuffy quality - in some ways reminiscent of herbal candy or those sticks of lavender rock one sometimes still finds in the jars of certain pharmacies. Poetic, quaint, fresh, prim, confectional, medicinal, old fashioned, somewhat delightful if somewhat staid."
The Queen blinked back a tear. "Much like my dear Albert, then," she commented, "and much unlike you, reeking of your decadent dandy's scents, your Musc Ravageur, your Habit Rouge, your Anucci Man and your Sybaris!"
I felt somewhat annoyed by these jibes at my exquisite taste and resolved to respond with the deadliest insults that a fragrance master can muster. "My dear Quack Quack," I replied icily, "I have it on the best authority that your precious Albert, when he was not stinking out the royal palaces with Cigar Aficionado or offending foreign dignitaries with the injudicious odour of Joop, would insist on boring the whole of English society to death with the bland tedium of Memoire d'Homme and Dior's Higher Energy! Enough said, I believe."'

30th March, 2005.
post #56 of 66
My SINGLE favorite review is one whose author I don't even know:

Quote:
"On me, it smells like I just had great sex while wearing nothing but a suede jacket with bags of ripe apricots as pillows. Its not refined on my skinits all about tousled hair, slightly smeared eyeliner, slip dresses but with Louboutin shoes as [usernameeditedout] mentioned. Its definitely not for everyday but its perfect when in a naughty mood. "

I really enjoyed this review because it generated a thread in which people correctly guessed which perfume the reviewer was talking about.
post #57 of 66
Naed_Nitram on Acqua di Parma Colonia

Quote:
I recall how once the Baron de Charlus, inspired by numerous glasses of wine, extolled to me in an inebriated ramble the several virtues of Acqua di Parma. 'Hmm, ha, yes,well, mon cher Nitram,' he began, 'flintlocks, filigree and fine old lace...that ancient air...hmm...an old chateau in the morning mist...ha...lemon and faded rose...exquisite!...my lady's wardrobe?...hum, perhaps...the old, the true aristocracy!...Monsieur le Duc....swathed in supreme citrus...carriages on cobbled streets...Acqua di Parma!...a gift for His Majesty!...all gone...faded glories...lost swan of youth...all...quite...gone...' At which point, having had one glass too many, the Baron surrendered to sleep.

30th November, 2004.
post #58 of 66
Bumping to add a little review (from a thread) of Alexander McQueen Kingdom,


Quote:
Originally Posted by boosh View Post

Smells like a sweaty and farty bus, with air freshener.
post #59 of 66
The most engaging piece of writing I've read in a while was MDMs story about Bal a Versailles:

Quote:
Ah! Father! This intrigue of nonsense! In myself I believed to see an omnipotent, all-knowing Alpha-Male, impervious and invincible to any and all confusions of the heart; troubles of unrequited love, emotive manipulations: Always, I walked a straight line into the lives of any and all I desired, to then leave them breathless, enflamed, slaves to my every whim. Coolly, with deft calculations, shamelessly I would captivate them with my looks, ensnare them with wit, to then hold them hostage until the moment would come, always inevitable, when the intrigue would wane, their allure grew tiresome, or simply, without warning, I would unexpectedly crave isolation: So it happened, Father, that, with age, I did come to approach and finally to guiltlessly accept my peripatetic love life; self centered, preoccupied with my own pleasures, feigning interest, yet principally engaged only in the glorification of my own ego to the detriment of many: To find me, follow the trail of shattered, weeping hearts, for I have broken so very many. The long, winding trail that crosses the globe, over and over: The trail of corpses. At the end of it, my own now lays gasping for air: Flummoxed, disturbed, distraught and in shock: Halfway through my life it would appear that I have been served a bit of my own Machiavellian, wanton ways, and just this tiny wee dose has left me senseless in despair, finally enlightened as to the bleak gravity of my transgressions. So here I am. I have come to confess this most hideous of sins: A lifetime of demonic lusts that culminated and erupted in a tryst so shamelessly brazen, so vile, that I feel as though by it I have been branded in fire. Somehow, now that I have tasted the foul savour of my own, pitiless and self-serving lust, I can no longer live with myself, for I feel as though I have been transformed into a kind of devil: Possessed and invaded by a daemon. I met her. I met her in flesh and in the blood. In retrospect, I feel as though I have met my own self in the guise of a woman. Her reputation, quite legendary in certain circles, had preceded our meeting. I knew well and proper that with her, I would be playing with fire, but nothing, nothing at all, would stop me: From the moment of introduction, to my integral surprise, in me she would show no interest whatsoever: She was aloof. Unimpressed. When questioned, flippantly she claimed never to have heard of me, as if I were some nameless back room bookkeeper in a shoe shop, or a common civil servant. That assertion I am near convinced was a ruse, though presently I am sure of nothing, save for the searing pain in my heart, and an unusual taste of isolation, formerly sweet, reassuring, restful, full of relief; now bitter. The nonsense of it! My own cherished, beautiful solitude now turned to loneliness, common as gutter sludge. I have come to confess a lifetime of sins of the flesh, of gluttony and of shameless, guileless indulgences, never repented, never regretted.
It was at a Fancy Dress Ball when, finally, we met, when finally, as it appeared, I came face to face with my own withered, dying soul. All around was confusion and movement. The finest ladies in sparkling attire. Hoards of gentlemen fitted out in black masques. From afar, I saw her dancing, whirling about on the marble, seemingly passed about like a party favour: Taking gloved hands into hers, twirling and pirouetting, then gliding off to the arm of her next partner. Every time our eyes would meet she would turn her gaze: No masque had she, only a fan of ostrich plumes, and a black spray of aigrettes tucked cunningly into her coiffure, which she wore pin-tucked and curled high atop her head. Waltzing and whirling my way through the chaotic merriment, I purposely and repeatedly veered to approach her, in hopes that she would accept my outstretched hand, yet each time I would draw near, she would only spin round, to whip me across the face with the feathers of her headdress, black as tar, that contrasted sharply with her voluminous, multi-layered gown of sunflower yellow taffetas, chantilly laces and diaphanous organza. Each time I drew near I could smell an intoxicating perfume of warmth: Fields of dryed out, rotting roses, baking and sweltering in the heat, laced with a kind of heady incense that left me in a muddle heretofore unknown. Finally, with my white-gloved hand, I reached to grasp her, forcefully from behind, at which point, with the deft snap-twirl of a ballerina, her face was flush against mine, and our eyes locked. Keeping my gaze, with nonchalance she handed me her fan, with long spidery fingers captive in tulle mittens she reached up to remove my masque, without a word, without an apology, to then tie it around her own face, now batting her eyes through it. Lifting up her fan to offer it back I could feel a kind of rush emanate from it: The sweetest, most erotic scent of sweat that took up residence in my nostrils. Like a creeping, invading virus, I could feel it enter my blood, which pumped furiously as we danced off key, strangely isolated in our own separate universe. This dance, which saw me bewitched and under spell, led us, both equally drunken and stupid, to a long corridor that stretched so far into the distance that it seemed as if it went on into eternity, all paneled and gilded, with sparkling crystal chandeliers and sconces flanking yawning doors, all closed. First peering down into the depth of it, she looked up at me, her aigrette feathers quivering as she removed my black masque from her face, and tossed it on the floor as she took my hand, and, in a rustle of taffetas, led me away, so far that the music faded to silence, and we were alone: As it now appeared, there was no end to this hall: Just an eternal suite of scintillating crystal, glistening wood, and doors.still more doors. She threw herself seductively against one of these, and, her face now bare, looked up at me. The fire, it was not only in her eyes, but seemed to erupt from beneath her skirts, through her bustier, with licking flames that crept up between her bosom. With her right hand, she reached high up to take a firm, pinching hold of my ear. With her left, she opened the door, and both of us fell, tumbling into an opulent chamber of damask silk draperies, lyre shaped lounges and cabriole legged chairs, all gold and vibrant, canary yellow. Intoxicated on the vapours that enshrouded her, now so heavy as to fairly blind me with their dank, rosy musk, I began laughing, until I was summarily shut up by her mouth, and her tongue, which seemed to move into my head the way her scent flushed its way into my blood, turning it to liquid amber: I felt as if the whites of my eyes had grown yellow, and, were a pair of horns to burst forth through my skull, I would not have puzzled. Tearing at each other like wild beasts we rolled about the floor, until her massive sunflower ball gown became a kind of mattress, my black cloak a cover: I felt as if she had wiggled her way into my body, and from the inside was tickling it and tantalizing it in the most delicious ways. Our silent waltz on the floor became increasingly intense. Her mouth, her hands, her hair, every part of her body seemed to seer its way into mine. She was in control. Every time I tried to speak, or groan, my mouth would be filled with some part of her. Finally I resigned to close my eyes and let her take charge as she mounted me and rode my body like a horse: Slapping and whipping it, scratching and spitting, all the while filling me with her amber liquids that smelled and tasted like the heat and fires of seething passions of bestiality. Of these I drank willingly, never knowing from whence they came, or what they were, knowing only that I craved them, hungered for them: Each time I would reach to return her caress I would be whipped, spanked or pinned down. Each time I opened my mouth it would be fed with her body, and all the while I could hear her gasping, moaning, in turn cackling and laughing. When finally I tried to open my eyes they would be blinded: She spat in them. Licked them. Held her fingers spread open in my mouth, to fill it again with a rush of nectar, all sweet, yet dry and suffocating, burning my throat. Finally, as I began to feel the convulsions of my own innards threaten to erupt, I felt her fingers leave my mouth and encircle their way around my throat. It seemed as though she were strangling me: Tighter and tighter until I gasped for air as my body released its passion, and I fell into a swoon that first seemed made of blinding yellow light then dimmed to a murky black haze, and, ultimately, to oblivion. Shivering and naked I next found myself sprawled out beneath my silk-lined cloak with the light of dawn creeping through the soaring windows, all draped and swathed with bouillon fringe and gossamer laceand stillthis scent in my nostrilsthis taste in my mouth: All over my body an oily sweat of wilting roses and amber, yet in the room, I was alone. No trace of her. No evidence that she had even existed, though every item of garment I sought out as I redressed reeked of this perfume. My socks. My shirt. It was as if they had all been laundered in this liquid then pressed in its steam. Now, I carry it with me, everywhere I go: Nothing will get it off, so I bring it here, to this Holy Place, with head bowed, and misery in my heart. I bring it along with the audacity to beg forgiveness, though I know I deserve it not: For how many times have I myself brought such punishment unto others, desirous only of my own pleasures? And how many times have I left some poor soul naked and weeping, covered in my own stench, equally indelible? How many times have I remorselessly done unto others what she, this woman did unto me, I who was willing, who drank of her nectar as if it were the very wine of Heaven, and laid there, spattered in her eruptions, delighting in them, lapping them up like a crazed animal in heat? Is it not said that there is no sin so black that it cannot be forgiven? Even these? Even these that went on at that Ball At That Bal a Versailles?
post #60 of 66
Don't think this is a review but Lutens had an interview on Fragrantica not too long ago and people were to submit questions for him. This cracked me up as a user named 'Hulk' left this comment and no question for Serge:

"HULK love you M. Lutens, HULK know
you express Beauty of Universe in
your remarkable work. La Myrrhe make
HULK weep green tears of awe. Only
when HULK alone. HULK rather enjoy
and contemplate HULK vast hoard of
Lutens, yes even more than go and
SMASH!"

Lol.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Off topic
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › General Discussion › Off topic › Your Favorite single Review