Originally Posted by HammerFist
Contrary to the consensus here, I smell a LOT of rose in it. Rose + (Dirt, orange peel and gunflint). If it weren't for the dirt and gunflint, this would easily have been a female fragrance or unisex at best.
But I DO smell a lot of rose in it. If I remember it right, the rose note in this one was called as "Bay Rose" or something like that.
Overall, it's an excellent fragrance.
I think you are also referring to the Baie Rose, which JaimeB pointed out that it means Pink Peppercorns.
No rose to me either. It sounds like your girlfriend doesn't like something
in it, but doesn't either know what it is, or isn't able to identify what she's smelling. It's like when people who aren't really into fragrance think everything is "musky," regardless of any actual musk presence.
She probably just doesn't like a certain note in it and can't quite put her finger on it.