Originally Posted by Granola
No. They smell identical for the most part. People just have a preference for GIT coz its niche and its "slightly" different.
Wrong. As I said in the previous post, I think GIT is a 5-star fragrance because it's beautifully composed, smells buttery smooth, has seamless transitions, smells natural, and attractive. Yet, I don't care for personally. Cool Water, I rate as a 1-star fragrance, because it's noxiously chemical, smells haphazardly put together, and is a clear and blatant rip off of the vastly superior predecessor, GIT. And I don't like it either. Nothing to do with niche vs. designer, it has to do with one being good and the other being terrible.