Glad you're enjoying it, Larimar! I used to own this one, but all my Carons went on walkabout last year ( part of a sample package send-around ) and never came home. I've been enjoying the sample you sent.
I have come to appreciate this one more and more each time I try it. It's still not an all-the-time tuberose, but it's easily the most interesting I know and surprisingly, a compliment getter ( I've gotten two compliments on it here, rather unexpectedly given its ''difficult'' nature ).
I know what you mean about Carnal Flower. It's a glorious scent, and the top notes are perfection, but it isn't complex and the base winds up a little bland, though still beautiful. I love it but it's never quite all that I want it to be.
I still don't smell the peach note many smell in this. When I think peachy tuberose, I think Peche Cardinal, Beyond Love, PC Tuberose Gardenia, even a little bit in Fracas, but the Caron has a greener bent, almost a little sudsy. I know there was a Fracas Pour Homme that smelled nothing like Fracas, but if Piguet paired things like Amouage does, with noticeable links between their men's and women's, I could easily see Caron Tubereuse being something akin to Fracas Pour Homme if someone added a pinch of lavender or the like.
As it is, I hope either my Tubereuse returns from its journeys or that I get the opportunity to buy it again.