Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Fragrance house elimination game!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Fragrance house elimination game!

post #1 of 50
Thread Starter 
You may have played one of these before. You simply copy and paste the list, then add one point to your favourite and take one point away from your least favourite. Feel free to add any that I have forgotten.

Creed (10)
Tom Ford (11) +
YSL (10)
Davidoff (10)
Giorgio Armani (10)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (10)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (10)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (9) -
John Vavatos (10)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (10)
CK (10)

I've clearly missed out a load of big ones so feel free to add your faves.
post #2 of 50
Creed (10)
Tom Ford (11) +
YSL (9) -1
Davidoff (10)
Giorgio Armani (10)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (10)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (10)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (9) -
John Vavatos (10)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (10)
CK (10)
Penhaligon's (11) +1

Read more: http://www.basenotes.net/threads/251...#ixzz0mzIUgAdH
post #3 of 50
Creed (10)
Tom Ford (11)
YSL (9)
Davidoff (9) -
Giorgio Armani (10)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (10)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (10)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (9)
John Vavatos (10)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (10)
CK (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11) +
post #4 of 50
Creed (9) -
Tom Ford (11)
YSL (9)
Davidoff (9)
Giorgio Armani (10)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (10)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (10)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (9)
John Vavatos (10)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (11) +
CK (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
post #5 of 50
Creed (9)
Tom Ford (11)
YSL (10) +
Davidoff (9)
Giorgio Armani (10)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (10)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (10)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (8) -
John Vavatos (10)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (11)
CK (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)

Read more: http://www.basenotes.net/threads/251...#ixzz0mzP62Ynf
post #6 of 50
Xerjoff (1)
Creed (9)
Tom Ford (11)
YSL (10) +
Davidoff (9)
Giorgio Armani (10)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (10)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (10)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (7) -
John Vavatos (10)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (11)
CK (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)

Read more: http://www.basenotes.net/threads/251...#ixzz0mzVIgaXQ
post #7 of 50
Craig, your vote on YSL should have brought it up to 11, or.. were you voting for Xerjoff instead?

Xerjoff (10)
Creed (9)
Tom Ford (11)
YSL (11)
Davidoff (9)
Giorgio Armani (10)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (10)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (10)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (7)
John Vavatos (10)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (11)
CK (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Amouage (11) +
By Kilian (9) -
post #8 of 50
Xerjoff (10)
Creed (10) +
Tom Ford (11)
YSL (11)
Davidoff (9)
Giorgio Armani (10)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (10)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (10)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (7)
John Vavatos (10)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (11)
CK (9) -
Penhaligon's (11)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Amouage (11)
By Kilian (9)
post #9 of 50
I voted for Xerjoff. It wasn't listed so I added it as 1 and then subtracted 1 away from the company I dislike the most (Sean John). Sorry if I did it wrong which I now see I did.
post #10 of 50
I think the idea is that you copy the last person's list, thereby avoiding confusion.
post #11 of 50
Xerjoff (10)
Creed (11)
Tom Ford (11)
YSL (11)
Davidoff (9)
Giorgio Armani (10)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (10)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (10)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (6)-
John Vavatos (10)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (11)
CK (9)
Penhaligon's (11)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Amouage (11)
By Kilian (9)
post #12 of 50
Xerjoff (10)
Creed (10)-
Tom Ford (11)
YSL (11)
Davidoff (9)
Giorgio Armani (10)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (10)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (10)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (6)-
John Vavatos (11)+
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (11)
CK (9)
Penhaligon's (11)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Amouage (11)
By Kilian (9)
Thierry Mugler (10)
post #13 of 50
Xerjoff (10)
Creed (11)+
Tom Ford (11)
YSL (11)
Davidoff (9)
Giorgio Armani (8)-
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (10)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (10)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (6)-
John Vavatos (11)+
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (11)
CK (9)
Penhaligon's (11)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Amouage (11)
By Kilian (9)
Thierry Mugler (10)
post #14 of 50
I agree HDS, then to the ones you put a + by, you add 1 to the number, and vice versa for the minus. So to fix this up so it actually has a point and end results.. I'm gonna save everyone the trouble by doing the math.

Although the house choices are subjective, it's the OP's post.. and I think we should respect it. I think OP should re-do this thread though with actual fragrances and not houses, because it's hard to dislike an entire house, but it's also hard to give it praise if you've only tried a couple from them.

Creed (10)
Tom Ford (13) +
YSL (11)
Davidoff (9)
Giorgio Armani (9)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (10)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (10)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (4)
John Vavatos (11)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (11)
CK (8) -
post #15 of 50
Creed (10)
Tom Ford (13)
YSL (11)
Davidoff (9)
Giorgio Armani (8) -
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (10)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (11) +
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (4)
John Vavatos (11)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (11)
CK (8)
post #16 of 50
Creed (10)
Tom Ford (13)
YSL (11)
Davidoff (8) -1
Giorgio Armani (8)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (10)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (4)
John Vavatos (11)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (12) +1
CK (8)
post #17 of 50
I've honestly never even tried a Sean John. Just what's so hateable?
post #18 of 50
Creed (10)
Tom Ford (13)
YSL (11)
Davidoff (7) -1
Giorgio Armani (8)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (10)
Gucci (11) +1
Givenchy (10)
Dior (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (4)
John Vavatos (11)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (12) +1
CK (8)

Read more: http://www.basenotes.net/threads/251...#ixzz0n0d1JMU8
post #19 of 50
Guerlain (11) +1
Creed (10)
Tom Ford (13)
YSL (11)
Davidoff (7)
Giorgio Armani (8)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (9) -1
Gucci (11)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (4)
John Vavatos (11)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (10)
Azzaro (10)
CDG (12) +1
CK (8)
post #20 of 50
OK, what happened to Penhaligon's. It was added by HDS1963 and later eliminated by the Cologneist.And Guerlain dropped off the list in a few responses.
post #21 of 50
Guerlain (11)
Creed (11) +1
Tom Ford (13)
YSL (11)
Davidoff (7)
Giorgio Armani (8)
Acqua di Parma (10)
Chanel (10)
Lancome (9) -1
Gucci (11)
Givenchy (10)
Dior (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Sean John (4)
John Vavatos (11)
Hugo Boss (10)
Paco Rabane (11) +1
Azzaro (10)
CDG (13) +1
CK (8)
post #22 of 50
*** mixed up *** sorry!
post #23 of 50
You plussed three, trapper?! That's cheating?!
post #24 of 50
Quote:
Originally Posted by The_Cologneist View Post

Although the house choices are subjective, it's the OP's post.. and I think we should respect it.

The OP actually suggested we add to the list. By simply deleting the houses we have added, the list is now skewed. Our negatives remain while our positives are wiped out.
I don't think we should change rules mid-game. It's kinda confusing...
post #25 of 50
Well Xerjoff I added has vanished, so much for that
post #26 of 50
Here's an updated one, which I believe has the correct counts. trapper's post was hard to figure out, but I think it was +1 Paco Rabanne, -1 Lancome.
Here's what I have:

Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (11)
Armani (8)
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (9)
Chanel (10)
CDG (12)
CK (8)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (7)
Dior (11)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (10)
John Vavatos (11)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabane (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (6)
Tom Ford (12)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (10)
post #27 of 50
Thank you, Matty ... then I'll join;

Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (11)
Armani (8)
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (9)
Chanel (10)
CDG (12)
CK (8)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (6) -
Dior (12) +
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (10)
John Vavatos (11)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabane (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (6)
Tom Ford (12)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (10)
post #28 of 50
Dolce & Gabbana; Arden; Gaultier; Mugler; Lagerfeld;
Anna Sui; Hermès; Boucheron; Clinique; Joop?!

To name but a few..!
post #29 of 50
Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (11)
Armani (8)
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (9)
Chanel (10)
CDG (12)
CK (8)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (6)
Dior (12)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (9) -
John Vavatos (11)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabane (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (6)
Tom Ford (13) +1
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (11)
post #30 of 50
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Matthew View Post

Here's an updated one, which I believe has the correct counts. trapper's post was hard to figure out, but I think it was +1 Paco Rabanne, -1 Lancome.
Here's what I have:

Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (11)
Armani (8)
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (9)
Chanel (10)
CDG (12)
CK (8)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (7)
Dior (11)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (10)
John Vavatos (11)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabane (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (6)
Tom Ford (12)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (10)

Thanks for that
post #31 of 50
Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (11)
Armani (8)
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (10) +1
Chanel (10)
CDG (12)
CK (7) -1
Creed (11)
Davidoff (6)
Dior (12)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (9)
John Varvatos (11)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabanne (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (6)
Tom Ford (13)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (11) \t\t\t\t\t\t

post #32 of 50
Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (11)
Armani (7) -
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (10)
Chanel (10)
CDG (12)
CK (7)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (6)
Dior (13) +
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (9)
John Varvatos (11)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabanne (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (6)
Tom Ford (13)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (11)
post #33 of 50
Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (11)
Armani (7)
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (10)
Chanel (10)
CDG (13) +1
CK (7)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (6)
Dior (13)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (8) -1
John Varvatos (11)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabanne (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (6)
Tom Ford (13)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (11)

I find it difficult to have a strong love or hate for a single house, since my tastes are quite diverse, very few houses create such a strong opinion from me.
post #34 of 50
Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (11)
Armani (7)
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (10)
Chanel (10)
CDG (14) +
CK (7)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (6)
Dior (13)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (7) -
John Varvatos (11)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabanne (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (6)
Tom Ford (13)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (11)
post #35 of 50
Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (11) +1
Armani (7)
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (10)
Chanel (10)
CDG (15)
CK (7)
Creed (11)-1
Davidoff (6)
Dior (13)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (6)
John Varvatos (11)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabanne (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (6)
Tom Ford (13)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (11)
post #36 of 50
Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (12)
Armani (8) [+1]
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (10)
Chanel (10)
CDG (15)
CK (7)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (6)
Dior (13)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (6)
John Varvatos (11)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabanne (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (6)
Tom Ford (13)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (10) [-1]
post #37 of 50
Quote:
Originally Posted by Matthew View Post

The OP actually suggested we add to the list. By simply deleting the houses we have added, the list is now skewed. Our negatives remain while our positives are wiped out.
I don't think we should change rules mid-game. It's kinda confusing...

Ya I apologize, I missed that :O Thank you
post #38 of 50
Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (12)
Armani (8)
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (10)
Chanel (11) +
CDG (15)
CK (7)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (6)
Dior (13)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (6)
John Varvatos (10) -
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabanne (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (6)
Tom Ford (13)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (10)
post #39 of 50
N/A
post #40 of 50
Ohhmygod -- You messed it up again!
Only one + per voter!!!
And Malle needs to be erased again, we do not
add to the list, right?!
post #41 of 50
oops )

Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (13) +1
Armani (8)
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (10)
Chanel (11)
CDG (15)
CK (7)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (6)
Dior (13)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (6)
John Varvatos (10)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabanne (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (6)
Tom Ford (13)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (10)
post #42 of 50
Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (14)
Armani (8)
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (10)
Chanel (11) +1
CDG (15)
CK (7)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (6)
Dior (13)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (6)
John Varvatos (10)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabanne (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (6)
Tom Ford (13)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (10)
post #43 of 50
LOOOL ... one + and one - ..!
post #44 of 50
Oh ,i am sorry,it's the first time i play this game!!!

Quote:
Originally Posted by sophi View Post

Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (14)
Armani (8)
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (10)
Chanel (11) +1
CDG (15)
CK (7)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (6)
Dior (13)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (6)
John Varvatos (10)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabanne (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (6) -1
Tom Ford (13)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (10)
post #45 of 50
AAAhahahaha, I give up!
Then you need to fix the numbers too, miss Sophi.
Add one to Chanel, and take one from Sean John!
post #46 of 50
Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (13)
Armani (8)
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (10)
Chanel (12)
CDG (15)
CK (7)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (6)
Dior (13)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (6)
John Varvatos (10)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabanne (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (5)
Tom Ford (13)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (10)

Thank you Mr.Duc
post #47 of 50
Amouage ftw !
post #48 of 50
Quote:
Originally Posted by ohhmygod View Post

Amouage ftw !

IS 13 the correct number for Amouage?
post #49 of 50
Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (13)
Armani (8) -1
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (10)
Chanel (12) +1
CDG (15)
CK (7)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (6)
Dior (13)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (6)
John Varvatos (10)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabanne (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (5)
Tom Ford (13)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (10)
post #50 of 50
Acqua di Parma (10)
Amouage (13)
Armani (8) -1
Azzaro (10)
By Kilian (10)
Chanel (12) +1
CDG (15)
CK (7)
Creed (11)
Davidoff (6)
Dior (13)
Givenchy (10)
Gucci (11)
Guerlain (11)
Hugo Boss (6)
John Varvatos (10)
Lancome (8)
Maitre Parfumeur et Gantier (11)
Paco Rabanne (11)
Paul Smith (10)
Penhaligon's (11)
Sean John (4)
Tom Ford (13)
Xerjoff (11)
YSL (11)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: MFD Archive
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Fragrance house elimination game!