I've tried all the male Hermes scents, vintage and current. However, as I have not spent a great deal of time with a few I do not consider myself to be qualified to answer in the poll.
I own TdH and EdOV and enjoyed Rocabar and Bel Ami. I wore Equipage on my wrist today, courtesy of Nordstroms, and I like it much better than I had in the past but still consider it a bit dated for my tastes. Bel Ami is bright and spicy but I need to give it a full wearing to convince myself I can wear it comfortably. As for Rocabar, well, I don't remember much of Rocabar other than I liked it. Solid, solid house.