So lately it seems like there's been an Amouage explosion on the boards. They seem to be getting more talk than even Creeds lately. So I decided to order a few samples of Dia, Reflection, Epic, Jubilation, and Lyric. So I'd like to know, in your opinion, if they are worth the hype. No matter how good they smell, I already know they're DEFINETELY NOT worth the price! lol But are they any good, and why?
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Amouage samples on the way. Worth the hype?
Recent Reviews
-
I've tried this many times, I never understood why it stands out or sells so much. That bitter orange is repulsive and disgusting. This smells almost as bad as Guerlains Vetiver.
-
I don't like to factor in cost when reviewing a fragrance but for the ridiculously cheap price, this stuff is great! Smells similar to Armani Code but better. Might buy another bottle
-
TVlampboy declared Or des Indes as the elegant richer sister of Bal a Versailles,( but not the older) This is repeated by other enthusiasts on on other blogs. It is spot on. Bal is Zsa Zsa and Or...
-
Let me first say that Eau de Kananga is a brilliant but not mind-blowing scent. Eau de Kananga, at least the Rigaud version, is not a feminine fragrance and in reality a unisex if not exclusively...
-
SMN Garofano is a realistic and beautifully orchestrated carnation perfume. It is strong, spicy, and heady with floral overtones. Garofano is spicy, but not as spicy as Caron's Coup de Fouet. It...
Amouage samples on the way. Worth the hype?
post #2 of 48
7/28/10 at 8:23pm
- Redneck Perfumisto
- offline
- Gender:

- Trader Feedback: +38
- Loving C(h)oco Noir!
-
- 10,235 Posts. Joined 2/2008
- Location: Spiritually, Kansas
- Select All Posts By This User
post #3 of 48
7/28/10 at 8:45pm
- Sugandaraja
- offline
- Gender:

- 6,513 Posts. Joined 8/2007
- Location: Vancouver, BC
- Select All Posts By This User
post #4 of 48
7/28/10 at 9:12pm
- ohhmygod
- offline
- Gender:

- 1,497 Posts. Joined 5/2006
- Location: Adelaide
- Select All Posts By This User
post #5 of 48
7/28/10 at 9:58pm
Tested almost all EdP's and (only one among attars-) Homage. Their customer service sucks, they make you feel unimportant. That being said, I judge fragrances not customer service fools.
The short version: the EdP's are very good... compare them with what was left of the big French houses... mostly shadows of their glorious selves, no matter how much Luca Turin would be gushing in hyperbolic five stars reviews... there's no comparison in terms of concentration, seriousness of purpose... however, I enjoy these (Amouage EdP's) more like something to be enjoyed as an experience, not to be had as a full-volume product. Experimental in a good way.
Homage: it took me a while to appreciate it properly, but now I (think I) do and I just ordered a full attar bottle... and I'm not rich... it's that good... it's one of those few things you don't care whether others approve of, you just need it for yourself. Again, it's that good. As good as the best of Creed. The only one so far among what I tried.
Hillaire's Basenotes review of Homage sums up its best qualities splendidly.
The short version: the EdP's are very good... compare them with what was left of the big French houses... mostly shadows of their glorious selves, no matter how much Luca Turin would be gushing in hyperbolic five stars reviews... there's no comparison in terms of concentration, seriousness of purpose... however, I enjoy these (Amouage EdP's) more like something to be enjoyed as an experience, not to be had as a full-volume product. Experimental in a good way.
Homage: it took me a while to appreciate it properly, but now I (think I) do and I just ordered a full attar bottle... and I'm not rich... it's that good... it's one of those few things you don't care whether others approve of, you just need it for yourself. Again, it's that good. As good as the best of Creed. The only one so far among what I tried.
Hillaire's Basenotes review of Homage sums up its best qualities splendidly.
post #6 of 48
7/29/10 at 1:16am
- Oslo-Fjord
- offline
- Gender:

- 5,921 Posts. Joined 8/2008
- Location: Oslo
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
Agreed. It`s my favourite perfume-house. All of the male EDP are very high quality. The edp`s from Amouage gives me all I expect from a niche brand of this calibre. All of them smell good, but that doesn`t mean that I can use all of them. Gold is just to much for me to tolerate. To many sprays of this will make you sick.. There is no longevity problems with Amouage.
IMO, I will rank them like this:
1. Jubilation xxv. -This is the best fragrance I have smell so far. Ever! My favourite.
2. Epic. -Heavy stuff! masculine, powerful and strong. Not for kids! A masterpiece.
3. Dia. -Luxurious and refined for elegant day wear. IMO, also for evening wear.
4. Ciel. -Very unique complex fresh floral scent for men. Perfect for spring/summer.
5. Silver. -Classical, very elegant, "workhorse" scent. Fresh, crisp, woody and spicy. Smells great on eny occations.
6. Lyric. -Great floral rose based scent with strong sillage and longevity. Quite unique as a male-perfume.
7. Reflection. -In the Joop homme/Fleur du Male/Givenchy Pi-family. Smells nice, but can be to much if oversprayed.
8. Gold. -Luxurious, dense, and elegant. Expencive smell. To feminine for my taste..
post #7 of 48
7/29/10 at 5:23am
Homage would be still worth it if it was twice the price IMO . I dont get the longevity that other people seem to , about 6 hours but what a 6 hours - Im almost tempted to say that its the #1 in my wardrobe and I love all my smells . Same with Tribute . Have tried Epic Lyric and Reflection and think they are all excellent
post #8 of 48
7/29/10 at 5:44am
post #9 of 48
7/29/10 at 5:50am
- Oslo-Fjord
- offline
- Gender:

- 5,921 Posts. Joined 8/2008
- Location: Oslo
- Select All Posts By This User
Okay you guys, so the samples finally arrived today. I just applied another niche fragrance to my left wrist (Ambre Precieux) and Jubilation to my right wrist. Precieus doesn't impress on first impression. But this Jubilation...nice!!! I mean, I was over here just laughing to myself in delight at how nice it was. Now it's been on my wrist for about 5-8 minutes, and to be honest, I am a little less enthused. It kinda reminds me of Jo Malone's Pomegranete, which I was also impressed with upon initial application, but after a few more, it was just like ehh...
But I'll update you guys on the rest of the Amouages as I try them. I'm also anxious to try this Tauer Orange Star and the other niche fragrances in my sample pack.
But I'll update you guys on the rest of the Amouages as I try them. I'm also anxious to try this Tauer Orange Star and the other niche fragrances in my sample pack.
Ok...one more update. So I tried Epic and Reflection last night. I like Epic. It's okay, but I need more time to get better acquainted with it. But Reflection? Realllly good stuff. Surely this is the one that gets the Joop comparisons, because it definetely reminds me of a cleaner Joop. It's like Joop and GIT's lovechild. It's a little milder than Joop, and smoother and cleaner. Really nice. It definetely smells polished/upscale. I think it would make for a great formal fragrance. I'd definetely buy it if I had the money. A decant may be necessary. Lyric and Dia are next! But so far, Reflection is my top Amouage.
post #12 of 48
7/30/10 at 7:06am
- 30 Roses
- offline
- Gender:

- Trader Feedback: +185
- Lifelong Sniffaholic
-
- 10,379 Posts. Joined 10/2007
- Location: Connecticut
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
This eBay seller is located in Kuwait. I have found her reliable. Here is her page of Amouage currently on eBay:
http://shop.ebay.com/universal-perfu...911.m270.l1313
post #13 of 48
7/30/10 at 7:12am
I don't judge a house by one or two fragrances but this is a recent experience...
When I had with Reflection on, I was swamped with memories of...
-- my grandmother's cheap urinal cakes
-- cheap Halloween candy
-- the detergent aisle of a dollar store
-- a hint of body odor from some Indian taxi driver guy
-- some retched hippie thing from the 1970's (patchouli?)
This nightmare was long due to the oil-to-alcohol ratio.
When I had with Reflection on, I was swamped with memories of...
-- my grandmother's cheap urinal cakes
-- cheap Halloween candy
-- the detergent aisle of a dollar store
-- a hint of body odor from some Indian taxi driver guy
-- some retched hippie thing from the 1970's (patchouli?)
This nightmare was long due to the oil-to-alcohol ratio.
post #14 of 48
7/30/10 at 7:30am
- Suppressor
- offline
- Gender:

- 1,584 Posts. Joined 12/2006
- Select All Posts By This User
post #15 of 48
7/30/10 at 8:53am
- Oslo-Fjord
- offline
- Gender:

- 5,921 Posts. Joined 8/2008
- Location: Oslo
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
Originally Posted by Larwiz 
Ok...one more update. So I tried Epic and Reflection last night. I like Epic. It's okay, but I need more time to get better acquainted with it. But Reflection? Realllly good stuff. Surely this is the one that gets the Joop comparisons, because it definetely reminds me of a cleaner Joop. It's like Joop and GIT's lovechild. It's a little milder than Joop, and smoother and cleaner. Really nice. It definetely smells polished/upscale. I think it would make for a great formal fragrance. I'd definetely buy it if I had the money. A decant may be necessary. Lyric and Dia are next! But so far, Reflection is my top Amouage.

Ok...one more update. So I tried Epic and Reflection last night. I like Epic. It's okay, but I need more time to get better acquainted with it. But Reflection? Realllly good stuff. Surely this is the one that gets the Joop comparisons, because it definetely reminds me of a cleaner Joop. It's like Joop and GIT's lovechild. It's a little milder than Joop, and smoother and cleaner. Really nice. It definetely smells polished/upscale. I think it would make for a great formal fragrance. I'd definetely buy it if I had the money. A decant may be necessary. Lyric and Dia are next! But so far, Reflection is my top Amouage.
Most people need some time to "get" Epic, but when you first do, it`s almost hypnotic! By the way, it smells different when spraying from a bottle compared to a sample-vial. This is a "spray-in-air-walk-through" scent.
post #16 of 48
7/30/10 at 10:10am
- Scentologist
- offline
- Gender:

- 4,627 Posts. Joined 4/2007
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
Well said and I agree.
post #17 of 48
7/30/10 at 10:31am
post #19 of 48
7/30/10 at 1:02pm
- SculptureOfSoul
- offline
- Gender:

- 8,874 Posts. Joined 7/2005
- Select All Posts By This User
Reflection is one of the finest fragrances out there, imo. It has so many dualities it is crazy - it is modern and yet classic, sweet and yet full bodied, refined and yet playful, light and dark, compositionally heavy in some ways and yet so transparent in others. The key with Reflection is not to overdo it - 1 or, at most, 2 sprays is plenty. Glad you are enjoying what has essentially become my signature fragrance (by virtue of the fact that I tend to wear it 2 or 3 times a week because I crave it so.)
Hey Sculpture. Maybe you can send me a free decant? :-) Or maybe we can work somethin out. I may pm you. But umm...I also got a sample of Let Me Play the Lion, which I see is in your top 12. Man, that sucka smells like a slightly sweeter and more pleasant Yatagan. I was like OH NO!!! Now that was just my first impression. But my initial impression usually doesn't fleet, so I dunno. But yeah man...Reflection is all that. And the staying power is defientely there. I applied it at about 7:45 this morning, and I can still smell it loud and clear at almost 5 pm. That's 10 hours. Really good stuff. I'd love a decant of this stuff!
post #21 of 48
7/30/10 at 3:23pm
I just sampled some Amouage at the only chain store that sells them here, a little pricier than elsewhere. Sadly I only got them sprayed on strips since I kept getting assaulted by sales assistant not understanding that "I'm only here to smell amouage".
Anyhow, this is by no means my a significant first impression since the test wasn't on my skin. But Reflection and Gold are amazing (2 of the three I smelled). It's hard to describe the scents, they're not very "ground breaking" but they smell so pure and the notes flow perfectly. Though considering none of the scents "WOW"ed me on it's own, they're still not worth the price to me. I rather get an 5 excellent scents done moderately over a single good scent which is done perfectly. But I'm yet to test J XXV and Dia, maybe they'll make acquiring an amouage bottle worth it.
They lasted a good while on the scent strips, much better than any other complex scent I've had sprayed on paper, but you know what they say about fragrances that smell good on paper...God if only the sales assistant wasn't showing me the next perfume before I even sniff the one I just got. I mean...do these people even know scents need time to unfold?
Anyhow, this is by no means my a significant first impression since the test wasn't on my skin. But Reflection and Gold are amazing (2 of the three I smelled). It's hard to describe the scents, they're not very "ground breaking" but they smell so pure and the notes flow perfectly. Though considering none of the scents "WOW"ed me on it's own, they're still not worth the price to me. I rather get an 5 excellent scents done moderately over a single good scent which is done perfectly. But I'm yet to test J XXV and Dia, maybe they'll make acquiring an amouage bottle worth it.
They lasted a good while on the scent strips, much better than any other complex scent I've had sprayed on paper, but you know what they say about fragrances that smell good on paper...God if only the sales assistant wasn't showing me the next perfume before I even sniff the one I just got. I mean...do these people even know scents need time to unfold?
I hear you evoke. Those sales people can be pushy as hell! Right now I have Dia and Lyric on my left and right hand, respectively. Lyric must be the one that people are saying has rose in it, because Lyric is awfully floral right now, and I don't know that I like it. It doesn't smell very sophisticated. It smells like a typical floral scent from any generic perfume house. This is an easy PASS. Dia on the other hand is a nice sweet n spicy fragrance. It's kinda dry...kinda reminds me of Encre Noir. I'd wear it, but wouldn't buy it.
Hmm...on second and third sniff, Lyric isn't bad. It starts off waaay too floraly, but after about 5 minutes, it becomes a bit more wearable. Still though, Epic and especially Reflection are the only two of the five that I sampled that I would really consider purchasing.
Hmm...on second and third sniff, Lyric isn't bad. It starts off waaay too floraly, but after about 5 minutes, it becomes a bit more wearable. Still though, Epic and especially Reflection are the only two of the five that I sampled that I would really consider purchasing.
post #23 of 48
7/30/10 at 7:45pm
- A. Homme
- offline
- Gender:

- 1,433 Posts. Joined 6/2010
- Location: Texas
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
Received a sample of this one (my first Amouage) yesterday, and am trying it for the first time tonight. I have to agree--very nice and very much reminds me of something a mature woman would wear.
post #24 of 48
7/30/10 at 7:55pm
- Suppressor
- offline
- Gender:

- 1,584 Posts. Joined 12/2006
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
Interesting.
I personally see a mature woman wear C&S No.88, a more dark dirty rose.
Lyric Man is a very fresh fragrance which I think would suit a younger woman better imo.
I am kind of wondering how Lyric Woman smells...
I mean if the male version is already this feminine, the female must be uber-feminine!
post #25 of 48
7/30/10 at 8:11pm
- A. Homme
- offline
- Gender:

- 1,433 Posts. Joined 6/2010
- Location: Texas
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
Originally Posted by JBL 
Interesting.
I personally see a mature woman wear C&S No.88, a more dark dirty rose.
Lyric Man is a very fresh fragrance which I think would suit a younger woman better imo.
I am kind of wondering how Lyric Woman smells...
I mean if the male version is already this feminine, the female must be uber-feminine!

Interesting.
I personally see a mature woman wear C&S No.88, a more dark dirty rose.
Lyric Man is a very fresh fragrance which I think would suit a younger woman better imo.
I am kind of wondering how Lyric Woman smells...
I mean if the male version is already this feminine, the female must be uber-feminine!
Perhaps I should have said "well-heeled woman." It has class. Although to my nose it lacks any kind of a sweet or musky base, which I find fitting for younger women. This has a lot of blossom, and "jumps out" at you more than others so maybe that's throwing me off. Whatever it is, it makes me think of 35-45 y/o women with equal parts taste and disposable income.
Maybe I'll feel differently sometime tomorrow afternoon when this stuff begins to calm down. It is definitely some potent stuff.
Funny you should mention C&S No 88, too, because I have a sample of it on my other wrist. It's......something.

post #26 of 48
7/30/10 at 8:36pm
- CanwllCorfe
- offline
- Gender:

- 2,339 Posts. Joined 6/2009
- Location: Pennsylvania
- Select All Posts By This User
post #27 of 48
7/30/10 at 10:29pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by JBL 
Interesting.
I personally see a mature woman wear C&S No.88, a more dark dirty rose.
Lyric Man is a very fresh fragrance which I think would suit a younger woman better imo.
I am kind of wondering how Lyric Woman smells...
I mean if the male version is already this feminine, the female must be uber-feminine!

Interesting.
I personally see a mature woman wear C&S No.88, a more dark dirty rose.
Lyric Man is a very fresh fragrance which I think would suit a younger woman better imo.
I am kind of wondering how Lyric Woman smells...
I mean if the male version is already this feminine, the female must be uber-feminine!
The Lyric Woman is rather more 'masculine'; I figured they played a bit with the concept. Woman is rosier, but less generically floral and has a very strong sandalwood drydown.
I figure the sharp 'ginger attack' at the front of man was the comapny's rationale for it's being chosen for the 'masculine' market. I wear both, and possibly prefer Man.
As for man, it requires time to drydown, and I thin one needs to know its sillage to know its full personality. I fond it really delightful.
post #28 of 48
7/31/10 at 8:58am
- Oslo-Fjord
- offline
- Gender:

- 5,921 Posts. Joined 8/2008
- Location: Oslo
- Select All Posts By This User
post #30 of 48
7/31/10 at 1:00pm
- JonB
- offline
- Gender:

- 1,837 Posts. Joined 8/2008
- Location: Midwest
- Select All Posts By This User
post #32 of 48
7/31/10 at 1:38pm
- Suppressor
- offline
- Gender:

- 1,584 Posts. Joined 12/2006
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
Damn, that was creepy huh?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Hillaire 
The Lyric Woman is rather more 'masculine'; I figured they played a bit with the concept. Woman is rosier, but less generically floral and has a very strong sandalwood drydown.
I figure the sharp 'ginger attack' at the front of man was the comapny's rationale for it's being chosen for the 'masculine' market. I wear both, and possibly prefer Man.
As for man, it requires time to drydown, and I thin one needs to know its sillage to know its full personality. I fond it really delightful.

The Lyric Woman is rather more 'masculine'; I figured they played a bit with the concept. Woman is rosier, but less generically floral and has a very strong sandalwood drydown.
I figure the sharp 'ginger attack' at the front of man was the comapny's rationale for it's being chosen for the 'masculine' market. I wear both, and possibly prefer Man.
As for man, it requires time to drydown, and I thin one needs to know its sillage to know its full personality. I fond it really delightful.
Thank you Hillaire for clearing that up.
So the Man version is for woman and the Woman version is for man...
Only with Amouage!

I don't even know the difference anymore between men & man and women and woman!
Forgive me, English is not my native language.
post #33 of 48
7/31/10 at 8:51pm
Except for Homage, which recently became one of my favorite five scents ever, I go back and forth on Amouages... I don't try to be excessively wobbly, these are good professional scents and so on and so forth but... good as they are, they sometimes give me a headache (Lyric Man). Today I wore for the fourth time Jubilation XXY (with a little Creed Windsor on the other wrist)... the difference was staggering... Jubilation smelled good at times and literally anoying at other times - Windsor remained a reigning masterpiece... even if I now detect a slight artificial base-note in Windsor as well.
I've also tried out some Xerjoff... when it comes to EdP rather than attars (which of course Xerjoff does not produce), Xerjoff wins hands down in my opinion. They actually smell good from top to bottom (tried Kobe and Uden so far and liked them both quite a bit - it's not all about the composition, the quality of the ingredients makes a biiig difference).
I've also tried out some Xerjoff... when it comes to EdP rather than attars (which of course Xerjoff does not produce), Xerjoff wins hands down in my opinion. They actually smell good from top to bottom (tried Kobe and Uden so far and liked them both quite a bit - it's not all about the composition, the quality of the ingredients makes a biiig difference).
post #34 of 48
7/31/10 at 9:44pm
- Surfacing
- offline
- Gender:

- 3,950 Posts. Joined 4/2008
- Location: Canada
- Select All Posts By This User
Larwiz, it is good to see you back posting on the boards. I hope you find the niche samples compelling.
The only Amouage I have worn in Lyric Man. Very good stuff, although I need to wear it more to get a better grasp of the fragrance. Unlike others, I find Lyric Man to be quite masculine. A fresh rose, but masculine. Anyone who thinks that this smells feminine really needs to try more rose scents marked as "feminine" in the Basenotes directory. That'll teach ya.
The only Amouage I have worn in Lyric Man. Very good stuff, although I need to wear it more to get a better grasp of the fragrance. Unlike others, I find Lyric Man to be quite masculine. A fresh rose, but masculine. Anyone who thinks that this smells feminine really needs to try more rose scents marked as "feminine" in the Basenotes directory. That'll teach ya.
post #35 of 48
8/1/10 at 12:30am
- SculptureOfSoul
- offline
- Gender:

- 8,874 Posts. Joined 7/2005
- Select All Posts By This User
I too find that Lyric Man is, if not masculine, definitely not overtly feminine. My girlfriend finds it quite masculine on my skin, and absolutely LOVES it (she also loves things like L'Anarchiste, Serge Noire and M7, so she definitely likes heavier, masculine scents). I found it especially interesting that my girlfriend's mother, when smelling Lyric Man from under the cap, said it smelled like a scent for a masculine, outdoors kind of man.
On me, the ginger, angelica, and later nutmeg, saffron and cedar balance the feminine aspect of the rose and vanilla quite nicely. I don't find the particular rose accord to be that feminine though - it's not heavy, thick, syrupy or particularly fruity here - but instead lighter, dewy, green and ethereal.
I honestly find Reflection Man to be more feminine overall than Lyric Man (of course, I love them both, and any feminine qualities in either I find to be tempered enough by the masculine qualities that I feel it creates an interesting dualistic mix, rather than something that is unbalanced into the ostentatiously feminine realm.)
On me, the ginger, angelica, and later nutmeg, saffron and cedar balance the feminine aspect of the rose and vanilla quite nicely. I don't find the particular rose accord to be that feminine though - it's not heavy, thick, syrupy or particularly fruity here - but instead lighter, dewy, green and ethereal.
I honestly find Reflection Man to be more feminine overall than Lyric Man (of course, I love them both, and any feminine qualities in either I find to be tempered enough by the masculine qualities that I feel it creates an interesting dualistic mix, rather than something that is unbalanced into the ostentatiously feminine realm.)
post #36 of 48
8/1/10 at 5:49am
- Oslo-Fjord
- offline
- Gender:

- 5,921 Posts. Joined 8/2008
- Location: Oslo
- Select All Posts By This User
The only male scents from Amouage that gives a feminine aura (imo), is Gold and Reflection.. Unfortunately Reflection gives me a terrible headache, and makes me almost sick! It`s a odd, "screwed", remarkable smell, with monster-sillage and longevity.. I have tried and tried, several times now to learn to like it, but I must realize that the battle is lost! OVER AND OUT!
Quote:
Originally Posted by Surfacing 
Larwiz, it is good to see you back posting on the boards. I hope you find the niche samples compelling.
The only Amouage I have worn in Lyric Man. Very good stuff, although I need to wear it more to get a better grasp of the fragrance. Unlike others, I find Lyric Man to be quite masculine. A fresh rose, but masculine. Anyone who thinks that this smells feminine really needs to try more rose scents marked as "feminine" in the Basenotes directory. That'll teach ya.

Larwiz, it is good to see you back posting on the boards. I hope you find the niche samples compelling.
The only Amouage I have worn in Lyric Man. Very good stuff, although I need to wear it more to get a better grasp of the fragrance. Unlike others, I find Lyric Man to be quite masculine. A fresh rose, but masculine. Anyone who thinks that this smells feminine really needs to try more rose scents marked as "feminine" in the Basenotes directory. That'll teach ya.
Hey Surfacing! Good to be back, and good to see you posting as well. I do a whole lot of lurking these days, so don't think I'm not around just because Im not posting. I'm basenotes' own phantom. lol But Lyric to me...I don't know. It just doesn't scream POUR HOMME to me, you know what I mean. It's too soft...I just put it on seconds ago, and it smells rather soapy, like a floral soap that your mom has in the guest bathroom in the house. I dunno man.
What's interesting to me is that I see a lot of men on these boards talking about rose notes in fragrances, and frankly, it would surprise and sorta baffle me that men would find this note attractive and/or masculine. It smells like something an older woman would wear.
post #38 of 48
8/1/10 at 12:57pm
- castorpollux
- offline
- Gender:

- 4,676 Posts. Joined 12/2005
- Select All Posts By This User
[QUOTE=SculptureOfSoul;1895804]
I honestly find Reflection Man to be more feminine overall than Lyric ManQUOTE]
Ok...this right here literally had me laughing out loud. But I totally disagree, 1000%!!! Reflection has some sweetness to it, but it is so wonderfully balanced with other masculine notes that it could never be percieved as feminine. Reflecton is sweeter than Lyric, but that sweetness doesn't translate to feminine like the rose in Lyric does. But you know what-that's what makes fragrance perception interesting. Two people will get totally different notes and feels from the same fragrance.
I honestly find Reflection Man to be more feminine overall than Lyric ManQUOTE]
Ok...this right here literally had me laughing out loud. But I totally disagree, 1000%!!! Reflection has some sweetness to it, but it is so wonderfully balanced with other masculine notes that it could never be percieved as feminine. Reflecton is sweeter than Lyric, but that sweetness doesn't translate to feminine like the rose in Lyric does. But you know what-that's what makes fragrance perception interesting. Two people will get totally different notes and feels from the same fragrance.
You know what Oslo-I found myself sneezing a bit on Friday when I wore it, which is funny, because it smells a bit like Joop!, which is the ONLY FRAGRANCE that causes me to instanly sneeze upon first application. But I wore it yesterday, and enjoyed every bit of it. And I don't recall sneezing once. Come to think of it though-on Friday, there was a moment where my head was kinda bothering me, but I didn't attribute it to the fragrance I was wearing. It didn't last, either way, so...I'm pretty confident that I can wear Reflection with no problems. Really, I've never had problems with headaches with any of my fragrances, fortunately!
post #41 of 48
8/2/10 at 12:48am
- Oslo-Fjord
- offline
- Gender:

- 5,921 Posts. Joined 8/2008
- Location: Oslo
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
Originally Posted by Larwiz 
You know what Oslo-I found myself sneezing a bit on Friday when I wore it, which is funny, because it smells a bit like Joop!, which is the ONLY FRAGRANCE that causes me to instanly sneeze upon first application. But I wore it yesterday, and enjoyed every bit of it. And I don't recall sneezing once. Come to think of it though-on Friday, there was a moment where my head was kinda bothering me, but I didn't attribute it to the fragrance I was wearing. It didn't last, either way, so...I'm pretty confident that I can wear Reflection with no problems. Really, I've never had problems with headaches with any of my fragrances, fortunately!

You know what Oslo-I found myself sneezing a bit on Friday when I wore it, which is funny, because it smells a bit like Joop!, which is the ONLY FRAGRANCE that causes me to instanly sneeze upon first application. But I wore it yesterday, and enjoyed every bit of it. And I don't recall sneezing once. Come to think of it though-on Friday, there was a moment where my head was kinda bothering me, but I didn't attribute it to the fragrance I was wearing. It didn't last, either way, so...I'm pretty confident that I can wear Reflection with no problems. Really, I've never had problems with headaches with any of my fragrances, fortunately!
I`m glad you like it. When I smelled it from the sample, I liked it. When I sprayed it from the bottle, is was just to much for me to tolerate...Futile money!
post #43 of 48
8/2/10 at 9:20am
So today I went to another store which carries amouage here, with no SA pressure, And wow...I was blown away.
Now I wasn't blown away by the scents themselves, like I was blown away with some average perfumes (YSL M7, Pure Malt). But rather blown away with the quality and complexity of the fragrances. Amouage seems to me like a fragrance that only the experiences nose can appreciate, and you can't get full grip of it right away due to the complexity. The most notable thing is how those perfumes open; they don't open with a top notes choking you, yet one spray lasts long enough and develops quite well. It's hard to explain what I mean, you won't notice how good the quality of Amouage is until you think of other perfumes you tried and how a random spray in the store doesn't really tell you much and is usually quite illusive.
Now as for the scents, these are the ones I tried and how I rank them:
1. Dia: my favorite, deep, somewhat sweet. Seems to work great as both a casual and a formal scent, yet it's not really an "inbetween" scent, you really get the best of both
2. Gold: This one smells expensive, and I can smell some Oud in there, I really like it but it's a little too formal for me.
3. Jubiliation xxv: This one is really unique, it has a very strong note that I haven't smelled in any other perfume. But it's really not for everyone, it sometimes smells to me like a herb we use here in the middle east for cooking, so I'm torn in this one.
4. Lyric for Women: Flowery and powdery, yet really unique and strong, I might get this one after Dia.
5. Reflection: This is a clam sort of powdery men scent, reminds me of Givenchy Pi. It's quite good, but there are many perfumes similar to it so you get a GIT vs Cool water delima here
6. Ciel: This seems like their casual scent, it's deep yet casual. It's the closest thing to a fresh scent they have.
7. Epic for men/women: nothing memorable in either, I like the women's one better though. EDIT: Epic actually developed into something very pleasant, I have to do more testing
Overall, they're all great. Few really impressed me with being unique, but that's not what makes Amouage stand out to me. It's really the quality that sets Amouage apart, And not everybody would appreciate that. But again, they're unique enough for the average nose to appreciate, but they're only worth the price for an experienced nose to appreciate.
P.S. I asking the SA if they sell samples, and he said no but he had a Lyric for men and Ubar for women sprayer samples, and gave them to me for free! I'm so happy and can't wait to actually try them for a day wear. Don't be shy to ask a nice sales assistant for samples! this was my first time and I got two samples of the most expensive perfumes in their store.
Now I wasn't blown away by the scents themselves, like I was blown away with some average perfumes (YSL M7, Pure Malt). But rather blown away with the quality and complexity of the fragrances. Amouage seems to me like a fragrance that only the experiences nose can appreciate, and you can't get full grip of it right away due to the complexity. The most notable thing is how those perfumes open; they don't open with a top notes choking you, yet one spray lasts long enough and develops quite well. It's hard to explain what I mean, you won't notice how good the quality of Amouage is until you think of other perfumes you tried and how a random spray in the store doesn't really tell you much and is usually quite illusive.
Now as for the scents, these are the ones I tried and how I rank them:
1. Dia: my favorite, deep, somewhat sweet. Seems to work great as both a casual and a formal scent, yet it's not really an "inbetween" scent, you really get the best of both
2. Gold: This one smells expensive, and I can smell some Oud in there, I really like it but it's a little too formal for me.
3. Jubiliation xxv: This one is really unique, it has a very strong note that I haven't smelled in any other perfume. But it's really not for everyone, it sometimes smells to me like a herb we use here in the middle east for cooking, so I'm torn in this one.
4. Lyric for Women: Flowery and powdery, yet really unique and strong, I might get this one after Dia.
5. Reflection: This is a clam sort of powdery men scent, reminds me of Givenchy Pi. It's quite good, but there are many perfumes similar to it so you get a GIT vs Cool water delima here
6. Ciel: This seems like their casual scent, it's deep yet casual. It's the closest thing to a fresh scent they have.
7. Epic for men/women: nothing memorable in either, I like the women's one better though. EDIT: Epic actually developed into something very pleasant, I have to do more testing
Overall, they're all great. Few really impressed me with being unique, but that's not what makes Amouage stand out to me. It's really the quality that sets Amouage apart, And not everybody would appreciate that. But again, they're unique enough for the average nose to appreciate, but they're only worth the price for an experienced nose to appreciate.
P.S. I asking the SA if they sell samples, and he said no but he had a Lyric for men and Ubar for women sprayer samples, and gave them to me for free! I'm so happy and can't wait to actually try them for a day wear. Don't be shy to ask a nice sales assistant for samples! this was my first time and I got two samples of the most expensive perfumes in their store.
post #44 of 48
8/2/10 at 9:44am
- Sugandaraja
- offline
- Gender:

- 6,513 Posts. Joined 8/2007
- Location: Vancouver, BC
- Select All Posts By This User
post #45 of 48
8/2/10 at 11:01am
- Oslo-Fjord
- offline
- Gender:

- 5,921 Posts. Joined 8/2008
- Location: Oslo
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
-I love it! It`s my favourite spring/summer fragrance.
post #46 of 48
8/3/10 at 9:53pm
I totally agree that the most 'feminine' of the bunch are Gold Man and Reflection Man, both of which I also wear happily. My BF likes Gold man on me very much and even requests it!
And I love Lyric Man on him, which he wears quite often; moreover, I'd say he's categorically 'masculine', if not'ordinary'
I love about the Amouage house in general how 'crossovery' they all are! Despite their "Man' and 'Woman' labels. Epic Woman, Jubilation 25, and Lyric Woman (as well as Gold Woman) are great on men, and would not strike anyone as odd, I think. My BF bought Jubilation 25 just for himself, and pointed out accurately that it's very reminiscent of HdP's Marquis de Sade.
Also, aside from Gold Man, Reflection Man, and Lyric Man, I really like to wear Ciel Man and Silver Cologne.
And I love Lyric Man on him, which he wears quite often; moreover, I'd say he's categorically 'masculine', if not'ordinary'
I love about the Amouage house in general how 'crossovery' they all are! Despite their "Man' and 'Woman' labels. Epic Woman, Jubilation 25, and Lyric Woman (as well as Gold Woman) are great on men, and would not strike anyone as odd, I think. My BF bought Jubilation 25 just for himself, and pointed out accurately that it's very reminiscent of HdP's Marquis de Sade.
Also, aside from Gold Man, Reflection Man, and Lyric Man, I really like to wear Ciel Man and Silver Cologne.
post #47 of 48
8/18/10 at 6:33am
- dreamer81
- offline
- Gender:

- 2,282 Posts. Joined 11/2009
- Select All Posts By This User
Dreamer, you don't have to be in a suit and tie to appreciate a formal business-like fragrance. Furthermore, every now and then, I am sure you are dressed to impress, whether it is a suit and tie, or just a nice shirt and some nice slacks or dressy jeans. THose are the times when you are going to want to feel like a million bucks. And that's when it would benefit you to be wearing a fragrance that screams QUALITY!!! It's always good to have a posh fragrance at your disposal. So I'd say definetley sample them.
Return Home
Back to Forum: MFD Archive
- Amouage samples on the way. Worth the hype?
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Amouage samples on the way. Worth the hype?
Currently, there are 524 Active Users
(44 Members and 480 Guests)
Recent Discussions
- › Old School SotD's 1 minute ago
- › SOTD: Thursday, May 23rd, 2013 2 minutes ago
- › How do we search fragrance directory? 4 minutes ago
- › Midnight in Paris or 24 gold scent story 7 minutes ago
- › Forum Specific Board Subscription Not Working 7 minutes ago
- › I dun goofed 10 minutes ago
- › 'Squash' Fragrance for men (ala Japanese Air Freshner) 10 minutes ago
- › The future of Gucci Pour Homme II? 21 minutes ago
- › Effet Devastateur? 22 minutes ago
- › Boutique hotels 23 minutes ago
View: New Posts | All Discussions
Recent Reviews
- › Terre D'Hermès by Hermès, 2006 by nyguy
- › Avant Garde by Lanvin, 2011 by nyguy
- › Or Des Indes by Maître Parfumeur et Gantier, 1988 by Bal a Versailles
- › Eau De Kananga by Rigaud by bokaba
- › Garofano by Santa Maria Novella, 1828 by bokaba
- › Cravache by Robert Piguet, 1963 by rbaker
- › Javanese Patchouli by Ermenegildo Zegna, 2012 by Lovescully
- › Neroli Portofino by Tom Ford, 2007 by JourneymanDave
- › Danger Pour Homme by Roja Dove, 2011 by Filomele
- › So New York by Bond No. 9, 2003 by Francop
View: More Reviews
New Fragrance Wikis
- › UK FiFi Award winners 2013 by Grant
- › UK FiFi Awards tonight. by Grant
- › Groups Guidelines by Grant Osborne
- › Buy, Sell, Trade Rules by Grant Osborne
- › Following And Followers by Grant Osborne
- › Search And Advanced Search Tutorial by Grant Osborne
- › Tagging Tutorial by Grant Osborne
- › Add A New Item Tutorial by Grant Osborne
- › Image And Video Tutorial by Grant Osborne
- › Subscription Tutorial by Grant Osborne
Home | Fragrance Product Guide | Forums | Fragrance Wikis | My Profile
About Basenotes | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2013 Basenotes is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle
About Basenotes | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2013 Basenotes is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle





