I can't really choose an order but my top 5 are probably
Drakkar Noir: I used to wear this in high school, but gave my bottle to a friend to find other stuff, but recently tried it again the other day, and WOW! It just smells so damn amazing on me, and probably better than it did when I was 15-17. I don't know why I ever quit wearing it.
Azzaro PH: Even though it seems weak(which is contrary to the reviews) I love the way it smells, and I can't see myself liking anything better than Azzaro PH.
Azzaro Chrome: Probably the absolute best aquatic fresh smelling frag, and it actually has some strength, and lasting ability.
Fahrenheit Doir: I actually liked Lucky#6 before I heard of Fahrenheit, and I loved it, but then I tried Fahrenheit, and it is much better than Lucky
Joop: It just smells unlike anything else I have smelled before almost like sweet-tarts or some other sweet but a little sour.
Honorable mention to Stetson, Stetson Black(best black smell I know of), Avatar, Cigar, and Grey Flannel(just tried it and love it).