The scent is not quite right. I'd like it a lot more if it was just true pine but something else gets in the way. It's a bit hot too (alcohol burn). I add witch hazel and pine EO to "fix" it. If you like the bay rum scent, Aubrey's take on it are better than what they think the North Woods smell like.
This particular natural deodorant that I tried actually smells like the new Dana English Leather to me. It's a good product but unfortunately does not hold up like antipersperants which clog your pores. I can't speak for the after shave.