I say get L'Homme. They are completely different. L'Homme was & still is one of my favorite scents. It is a safe scent, maybe a go to scent when you just don't know what to wear. It can be worn spring, summer, fall, winter. La Nuit is completely different, sweet & spicey yet safe also. La Nuit can be worn fall, winter & spring...maybe even summer. I love La Nuit but, no collection is complete without the original L'Homme.