Ah, Josh, I see you are a man of obvious good taste and intelligence.
Since we skipped OP, here are my picks for silverpunk.
D&G Pour Homme
Lolita Lempicka Au Masculin (even though it's on your swap list!)
Worst, in my opinion, is 212 Men -- not that it's bad, but I just can't work up any enthusiasm for it at all. It doesn't have that kick that puts it over the line for me.
And, since I am apparently on a roll, here's for Josh:
Azzaro Pour Homme
Montale Black Aoud
Rive Gauche PH
You have a solid wardrobe! Forced to pick a weak link, I would pick Mugler cologne, because it just doesn't hold up to the rest of your inventory.