Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Searching for a patchouli scent with an ambery/vanilla dry down.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Searching for a patchouli scent with an ambery/vanilla dry down.

post #1 of 44
Thread Starter 
Hey guys and gals,

I'm highly interested in patchouli scents as of late and am seeking someting along these lines : A patchouli based scent, with an ambery/vanilla like accord in the drydown.

Any ideas ?

I came up with this interest because of how much I like Molinard Patchouli. Nice scent and has a wonderful dry down. Not a one note scent, like some have mentioned. I know we all experience scents in our way, but this Molinard Patchouli has more notes going on in the dry down. The patchouli dies down alot too and it finnish off with a VERY subtle ( I would say it becomes a "skin scent") aroma of amber/vanilla ( and perhaps other notes). The amber and vanilla may even be another note/accord, perhaps. Essentially, the Molinard Patchouli is too subtle of a scent for me to enjoy as a SotD.

Anyways, I would like to hear any rec's for what I am seeking.

Thanks in advance
post #2 of 44
Montale Patchouli Leaves
post #3 of 44
You need to try Patchouli Nobile by Nobile 1942. I got a sample of this from Luckyscent lately, and it's a super smooth patchouli that still smells distinctly like patchouli, and has an ambery finish.
post #4 of 44
Coromandel seems to be what you're looking for. I even mistook my friend's sillage for Shalimar!
post #5 of 44
Patchouli Leaves and Mazzolari Patchouly both fit the description, but both are also pricey and difficult to source, except online.
post #6 of 44
Second Coromandel.
post #7 of 44
Mazzolari Patchouly or Reminiscence Eau de Patchouli. The labdanum in Reminiscence is prominent.
post #8 of 44
Just stay with the Molinard House, Ambre Molinard

Top notes: Bergamot, Lemon, Orange, Lavender
Heart: Benzoin, Incense, Geranium
Basenores: Patchouli. Musk, Vanilla
It is a strong patchouli scent and a sweet ambery (Ambre in the name, but not Amber in the notes) Vanilla drydown.
It is listed as a feminine scent, but it is clearly unisex.

Sample it first, it is not a fragrance that will please everybody.
post #9 of 44
You might also check out Real Patchouly from Bois 1920. I find it's nearly a scent twin to Patchouli Leaves, but may be easier to source.
post #10 of 44
Oops! Forgot about Coromandel - also a great suggestion.
post #11 of 44
Quote:
Originally Posted by Snafoo View Post

You might also check out Real Patchouly from Bois 1920. I find it's nearly a scent twin to Patchouli Leaves, but may be easier to source.

Is this the one that's extremely similar to Heritage? Anyhow, Heritage packs a lot of patchouli with a Guerlinade drydown; so you might look into that one too.
post #12 of 44
Try Tom Ford Private Blend Noir de Noir. It has patchouli, chocolate truffle, and vanilla in it. It has to be one of my favorites of his.
post #13 of 44
No reason not to try Prada's original perfume, which has a drydown very similar to Coromandel.
post #14 of 44
Perhaps Mixte Pour Homme by J.A.
post #15 of 44
Quote:
Originally Posted by Snafoo View Post

You might also check out Real Patchouly from Bois 1920. I find it's nearly a scent twin to Patchouli Leaves, but may be easier to source.

+2...i smell amber and vanilla and patchouli.
post #16 of 44
Thread Starter 
Thank you for the wonderful reponse gentlemen !

Yes, Coromandel from Chanel, I'll get a sample of that for sure. I know alot of you like it and I am sure there is a reason for it. Will sample it for sure !

I have a sample of Mazzolari Patchouly, but have not cracked it open. One thing is, like Off-Scenter mentioned, it is hard to get ahold of (in full bottle form). And it is not cheap. But I would go large decant anyways, as I want to few options for patchouli and money is not unlimited. I will sample Mazzolari Patchouly this comming week.

Montale Patchouli Leaves is hard to find in bottle form as well ( once again, as mentioned). But reading the reviews tells me I will like it. It may not be great, but I can't see why I wouldn't like it. I can get ahold of a large decant, perhaps.

Nobile 1942 is a niche company I have little knowledge of, but will look up the above mentioned patchouli scent. Thanks !

Sanfoo, like you say, Bois 1920 is a company that I can source better than Montale Patchouli leaves. Thanks for that rec. I forgot about that niche line. I've only sampled one of their scents ( awhile back).

Quote:
Originally Posted by PerfumeCollector View Post

Just stay with the Molinard House, Ambre Molinard ....

Actually, because of a certain awesome female BNer, I was able to sample this recently. To be honest, I can't remember patchouli in this scent. I found it too quiet of a scent, actually. Very much a skin scent as well. ( Is this with all Molinards... ). I was kinda dissapointed, but I thought it was nice. For the price a full bottle goes for, I really wanted it to work. I will sample it again, as I had planned to.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr_Castro View Post

Try Tom Ford Private Blend Noir de Noir. It has patchouli, chocolate truffle, and vanilla in it. It has to be one of my favorites of his.

I read that this has rose in it Which is a really good thing. Certainly not a cheap scent. Cool name for a fragrance, however.

Quote:
Originally Posted by hednic View Post

Perhaps Mixte Pour Homme by J.A.

I never heard of this particular scent, hednic Hmmm.....I'll look it up. Hope it is not as ellusive as some other scents you have mentioned

EDIT : Forgot to mention Reminiscence Eau de Patchouli.. Actually, a Sephora in town has this....strangely. The term Eau kinda put me off, making me think it was not gonna last. I'll sample it again, but I'll have to be brave. The Reminiscence fragrances are in the womens section, and last time I went there to sniff a couple of fragrance, I got some awkward "looks" from SA's.
post #17 of 44
Quote:
Originally Posted by scent View Post

Is this the one that's extremely similar to Heritage? Anyhow, Heritage packs a lot of patchouli with a Guerlinade drydown; so you might look into that one too.

I can't say that I noticed much similarity between Real Patchouly and Heritage, the latter being more herbs and and spices than patch, although I agree it's present. Heritage is worth checking out in its own right - it's a great fragrance.
post #18 of 44
Surfacing.........I wear Mazzolari, Reminiscence Eau de Patchouli and Bois 1920 Real Patchouly. The most cost effective of the 3 is Reminiscence and it has the most ambery finish. I wear it no problem and find it as good as the other 2 mentioned.

The Bois is more woody, but has a similar finish to the Mazzolari.

*****There is nothing weak about the Eau de Patch either. I had reservations too at first, but as soon as I wore it, I found it to be VERY STRONG. ******
post #19 of 44
My two favorites are Nobile 1942 Patchouli and Chanel Coromandel, in that order. Nobile 1942 Patchouli would be my choice, more vibrant and yet very smooth.
post #20 of 44
Quote:
Originally Posted by Snafoo View Post

I can't say that I noticed much similarity between Real Patchouly and Heritage, the latter being more herbs and and spices than patch, although I agree it's present. Heritage is worth checking out in its own right - it's a great fragrance.

Ah I see...it's probably the Bois Extreme one then. I think I have a sample of Real Patchouly; I'll have to check it out now!
post #21 of 44
Two worth trying. The best!

Profumum Patchouly
Patchouli Nobile
post #22 of 44
You really need to crack open that sample of the Mazzolari, Surfacing. It is exactly what you're looking for, IMO. It's just so damn expensive!
post #23 of 44
Réminiscence Eau de Patchouli fits the bill.
post #24 of 44
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by AromiErotici View Post

Surfacing.........I wear Mazzolari, Reminiscence Eau de Patchouli and Bois 1920 Real Patchouly. The most cost effective of the 3 is Reminiscence and it has the most ambery finish. I wear it no problem and find it as good as the other 2 mentioned.

The Bois is more woody, but has a similar finish to the Mazzolari.

*****There is nothing weak about the Eau de Patch either. I had reservations too at first, but as soon as I wore it, I found it to be VERY STRONG. ******

Thanks AE. I'll certain give Eau de Patchouli a sampling for sure. Thankfully, bottles aren't hard to come by ( although large decants are).
post #25 of 44
If you want a fine scent that won't break the bank, I highly suggest Avon Tomorrow. Lots of patchouli, cocoa, & amber. It was my SOTE last night & I forgot how much I loved it.
post #26 of 44
Givenchy Play has a fresh citrusy start to it, but the dry down gives you patchoulli and woodsy and also a little musky smell to it. $53 for 1.7 at Macy's.
post #27 of 44
Patchouli Noir by Il Profumo is my suggestion!
post #28 of 44
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by CologneJunkie View Post

If you want a fine scent that won't break the bank, I highly suggest Avon Tomorrow. Lots of patchouli, cocoa, & amber. It was my SOTE last night & I forgot how much I loved it.

Thanks CJ. This the mens version, I presume ? I'll check out the review. I do find cheap bottles to have a charm in a way, but just haven't really found too many of them. I know a family member who gets Avon stuff and always asks me if I need anything. That should be nice and convenient. I'll check some reviews now

Quote:
Originally Posted by JakeStiebs View Post

Givenchy Play has a fresh citrusy start to it, but the dry down gives you patchoulli and woodsy and also a little musky smell to it. $53 for 1.7 at Macy's.

I did find Play to be pleasant, although did not last long on skin ( 5 hours ?). I made a rash choice and bought the Play Intense. Not good because
a) It is not as nice and complex as Play
b) It smells like chocolate peanut butter cookies hot out of the oven to me. Something that makes it hard to wear outside of a snowy December night.

I didn't really notice that much patchouli in it, if any at all. But that was back in June. I will check Play again. Thanks !

Quote:
Originally Posted by Postumo View Post

Patchouli Noir by Il Profumo is my suggestion!

I like Il Profumo as a brand and have been eyeing this particular fragrance. Its easy to get it mixed up with Histoires de Parfums fragrance Noir Patchouli. You say it has an ambery/vanilla accord in the drydown ? Its on my radar, but I can't track down a sample at the moment so it may have to wait.
post #29 of 44
Unless I missed it, can't believe nobody said Mazzolari Lui (patchouli-amber). Or perhaps they know of your lack of manliness and just didn't bother to suggest it??
post #30 of 44
PG's L'Ombre Fauve is mainly amber and patchouli, both notes prominent through the life of the frag on skin.
post #31 of 44
Quote:
Originally Posted by Surfacing View Post

I did find Play to be pleasant, although did not last long on skin ( 5 hours ?). I made a rash choice and bought the Play Intense. Not good because
a) It is not as nice and complex as Play
b) It smells like chocolate peanut butter cookies hot out of the oven to me. Something that makes it hard to wear outside of a snowy December night.

I didn't really notice that much patchouli in it, if any at all. But that was back in June. I will check Play again. Thanks !

Yeah I agree, Play is much better than Play Intense.

Play intense was way to sweet and oriental like for me.

Play doesn't last too long so another application after about 4 hours does the trick. It isn't heavy in the patchouli but I smell some unless my nose is playing tricks on me.
post #32 of 44
If you do end up getting Givenchy Play, and because you already have Play Intense, I heard that if you layer Play Intense with Play it gives you quite a nice smell. Once again I just have heard this a few times but I never have tried it.
post #33 of 44
+1 for Mazzolari - Lui, it's a gem.
post #34 of 44
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Force of One View Post

Unless I missed it, can't believe nobody said Mazzolari Lui (patchouli-amber). Or perhaps they know of your lack of manliness and just didn't bother to suggest it??

Ooooh...ouch ouch ouch.....Fo1. I guess we are "even" now from my comment at you in another thread.

Seriously though, if someone said I have manliness, I sure would not take it as a compliment. I'm out of high school now, and even then, didn't care for any "manliness" ( whether I had it or not). I'm just who I am. When I think of manliness, I think of over emotional thugs with Tap-Out ( or Ed Hardy) shirts and a sideways cap getting into intimidation battles and fights.

I checked out the reviews for Mazzolari Lui and I remember some forum comments in the past. This doesn't have an ambery or vanilla dry down, so its not gonna work. Ya gotta read the opening thread post, bro. Thats what I am looking for in a patchouli scent. No doubt in my mind this Mazzolari Lui is a high quiality scent. I saw that your review is the last one submitted and clearly you like it. But just not what I am looking for.
post #35 of 44
Quote:
Originally Posted by Surfacing View Post

I checked out the reviews for Mazzolari Lui and I remember some forum comments in the past. This doesn't have an ambery or vanilla dry down, so its not gonna work.

Well, I can tell you from my own experience that it has both in the drydown.
post #36 of 44
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by mikeperez23 View Post

You really need to crack open that sample of the Mazzolari, Surfacing. It is exactly what you're looking for, IMO. It's just so damn expensive!

Alright, I opened up the vial this afternoon and place the juice on my arm. I gotta say, I was a bit surprised at how quickly I got the two accords/notes or amber and patchouli...together ! I did not expect that. I didn't read any reviews beforehand either.

Anyways, l wasn't too crazy about the first hour of Patchouy. I just found that when patchouli is really at the forefront, it did not go well with the amber. I feel that when patchouli subsides a bit more, then it is better ( or vice versa, because the amber was quite strong from the get-go). But after the first hour, this got better and better.....and then I realized : This is pretty much an amber scent. Its quite nice. I'm surprised it doesn't get recommended more ofter in amber threads ( I probably just missed it ). But 6 hours later, I get a well pronounced amber accord ( and its been as such for a few hours). Reminds me of Tom Fords Amber Absolute, MPG's Ambre Precieux and the Armani Prive Ambre ( can't remember the name). Its nice for sure ( as an amber scent). I can tell this is gonna last long on the skin with good radiance.

Kudos to those who recommended this. This is clearly a patchouli and amber scent. I wish the patchouli stuck around longer and the amber was a bit more tame. I will have to test this again, however. As first impressions are not always that best ( for me) when it comes to fragrances.

Quote:
Originally Posted by perfaddict View Post

PG's L'Ombre Fauve is mainly amber and patchouli, both notes prominent through the life of the frag on skin.

Thanks A couple of months ago, this was on my sampling radar, as I wanted to find the "perfect amber" fragrance. I was going to get a sample, but then shyed away because I read some reviews regarding a "fur" note. As in, an animal fur note. And with that, a couple of reviewers mentioned it was hard to wear because of that. But, I will still look into this one and consider it. Thanks again !

Quote:
Originally Posted by JakeStiebs View Post

If you do end up getting Givenchy Play, and because you already have Play Intense, I heard that if you layer Play Intense with Play it gives you quite a nice smell. Once again I just have heard this a few times but I never have tried it.

Thanks Jake. I did hear the same thing on Basenotes. That sounds like a good idea, layering or blending the scents. I found it interesting how that two scents were released pretty much at the same time. I wish I went with Play, and not Intense. Play would have been nice in summer. But I am always a sucker for longevity in a fragrances life. Live and learn. Let me know if you find any other rec's Jake.
post #37 of 44
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nasenmann View Post

Well, I can tell you from my own experience that it has both in the drydown.

Look, I realize in your haste to try and "put me back in my place", you probably got over excited and grasped at straws....the fact is, this probably DOES fit what you are looking for. Perhaps you let personal bias and a need to represent emo kids everywhere or whatever else get in the way of what was a solid recommendation made in good faith. If you've tried it and didn't like it, cool. But to (possibly) let a personal difference blind you from what could be a great find....well.

Since you probably don't trust me as I'm just a boorish caveman, a) check that Nasenmann concurs b) the pyramid lists amber in the base (i.e. drydown) at least the one I saw did c) other reviews mention it (SirSlarty was one)

Just to show there is no hard feelings on my end, I will gladly accept a 10-20ml decant, sort of as an olive branch from you, if you do decide to check it out and buy it!
post #38 of 44
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Force of One View Post

Look, I realize in your haste to try and "put me back in my place", you probably got over excited and grasped at straws....the fact is, this probably DOES fit what you are looking for. Perhaps you let personal bias and a need to represent emo kids everywhere or whatever else get in the way of what was a solid recommendation made in good faith. If you've tried in an didn't like it, cool. But to (possibly) let a personal difference blind you from what could be a great find....well.

Since you probably don't trust me as I'm just a boorish caveman, a) check that Nasenmann concurs b) the pyramid lists amber in the base (i.e. drydown) at least the one I saw did c) other reviews mention it (SirSlarty was one)

Just to show there is no hard feelings on my end, I will gladly accept a 10-20ml decant, sort of as an olive branch from you, if you do decide to check it out and buy it!

No hard feelings at all, Fo1. I was just sorta joking/teasing and at the same time taking shots at jerks who roam around the city I live in.

I know you recommended it in good faith. But I didn't think too many review mentioned the amber/vanilla dry down. But yes, SirSlarty does make mention of it. Also Nasenmann didn't really help, as I never seem to agree with his thoughts on regarding fragrance ( no offence, Nasenmann )

Sampling is pricey with this particular company, so I gotta think about it. I may give it a shot.

Now if you don't mind, I'm gonna listen to my Stabbing Westward and Third Eye Blind cd's
post #39 of 44
Really??

For some reason I was picturing you listening to Fall Out Boy or My Chemical Romance! :P

All teasing aside, just to show I'm not a complete woman-beating Neanderthal jerk, I might be able to help you out. I'll send you a PM with the details.

Peace.
post #40 of 44
Quote:
Originally Posted by Surfacing View Post

( no offence, Nasenmann )

None taken but it's not just a matter of opinion - those notes are in Lui.
post #41 of 44
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Force of One View Post

Really??

For some reason I was picturing you listening to Fall Out Boy or My Chemical Romance! :P

All teasing aside, just to show I'm not a complete woman-beating Neanderthal jerk, I might be able to help you out. I'll send you a PM with the details.

Peace.

Hey, its all good. Yeah, we have differences. But I would never put you or someone in the category of "...woman-beating Neanderthal jerk... "unless I knew they were one. We're cool, Fo1.
post #42 of 44
Thread Starter 
Thanks everyone for the help in this thread, I very much appreciate it.

So far Mazzolari Patchouly, Avon Tomorrow and Noir de Noir are out. I don't like to wear fragrances with cocoa notes ( although love to smell them !). Patchouly is just to close to a few of the amber-centric scents I have sampled ( Ambre Russe, Amber Absolute...etc).

I have an idea of decants I will pick up and have narrowed my bottle choice down to 2. I'm on such a patchouli kick at the moment, so I want a few options. Of course if this is just a short term fad, I will kick myself

A couple of great things about patchouli, other than smell is

a) The vast amounts of options. I feel like no note has that many options. Certainly not rose....maybe amber ( I suppose)
b) The vast amounts of knowledge shown and given by BNers.
post #43 of 44

John Varvatos 10th Anniversary SE
-- patchouli, spices, and leather top and middle notes, then amber and woods base notes.
post #44 of 44
Quote:
Originally Posted by NewHaarlem View Post


John Varvatos 10th Anniversary SE
-- patchouli, spices, and leather top and middle notes, then amber and woods base notes.


Agreed. Do check this one out.

Also I love L'Artisan's Patchouli Patch-- even though vanilla and amber are not listed in the pyramid, I always got something like "Nilla Wafer cookies in the drydown. Patchouli Patch always made me think of the original Helmut Lang EDC/EDP with a stronger patchouli character. I don't know that it's exactly the type of scent you're looking for, but it's one of my favorite soft patchouli scents.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: MFD Archive
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › Searching for a patchouli scent with an ambery/vanilla dry down.