Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Female Fragrance Discussion › March Blind Sniff: Those Moody Blues
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

March Blind Sniff: Those Moody Blues

post #1 of 477
Thread Starter 
Here goes: since we had a Red Blind Sniff in January, I thought it would be a good idea to sniff the Blues for a sense of balance. While settling on the name we -- darkdreams and I -- thought about Shades of Blue (already taken as a personal name, Hi Shades!), One Way Ticket to the Blues (Neil Sedaka way, no less), Out of the Blue, etc. and finally thought about Those Moody Blues.

If only you knew how many times I have heard "I can't stand anything coming in blue boxes/bottles or light blue in color or with the name having to do with the color Blue" while speaking about fragrances! While I can understand these people's blues -- TM Angel, Cacharel LouLou, D&G Light Blue and Coty Adidas of all stripes are certainly NOT for everybody -- we can all pitch in and come up with an alternative list of very nice fragrances while you think of the color blue -- sunny March skies and sea waves, stormy nights and quiet twilights, huge corporation logos and melancholy, precious gems and modest forget-me-nots, everything from the Blue Bird to the Blue Beard. These fragrances would express a wide range of olfactory emotions, belong to different fragrance categories and -- more importantly -- bear the imprint of your own persona. Out of a long long list of Blue Fragrances, we have selected three, and they can be full blooded representation of the genre, like in "blue blood". Please sniff Those Moody three and post your impressions.

Our sniffers are: Aiona, hilaryjane (UK) and Thalia.
Twolf is hosting and darkdreams is co-hosting.


Everybody can participate by posting your questions/thoughts here or using the PM function.

The goal is to figure out the identity of the scents that our Sniffers have received, right now they are labeled as A, B and C. It is also to find new fragrance likes and make us Basenoters learn more about each other.

Thank you!
post #2 of 477
ahhh! This sounds right up my alley! Really? There are people who don't like blue bottles, boxes, or juice? I can't imagine.

Yes, there is a whole rainbow of shades of blue ... and just as many moods, feelings, and temperaments for each and every shade.

Good luck, everyone!

(PS I'm going to sticky the thread to make it easier to find.)
post #3 of 477
Good morning, sniffers and everyone else! Are you ready to start today?
post #4 of 477
I'm ready! I get home from work around 6 p.m. Pacific Time, so 9 Eastern. I find the theme very intriguing, because blue is one of my favorite colors, and yet blue-tinted perfumes look like Windex to me ...
post #5 of 477
Thread Starter 
LOL @ Windex comparison, Thalia! They do, don't they?

Hilaryjane reported on the main thread she would be available Saturday and/or Sunday, but you can go ahead and sniff your sample A to your heart's content. I will be here -- it is 8 pm my time tonight, I suppose.
post #6 of 477
Should I wait, or go ahead with A tonight? I can do either.
post #7 of 477
Thread Starter 
I would say Go ahead. I will be here at 8pm my time, hopefully Aiona can join you.
post #8 of 477
OK, I'll jump on at six and start smelling!
post #9 of 477
Here is an image to set the mood for sample A.



the photo belongs to http://www.flickr.com/photos/magic_fly/
post #10 of 477
Looking forward to it! Beautiful image!
post #11 of 477
Quote:
Originally Posted by darkdreams View Post

Good morning, sniffers and everyone else! Are you ready to start today?

Ack! I am ready! It is 15 minutes to 8 PM. I believe Twolf and I are in the same time zone?

Shall I start with A?
post #12 of 477
I stupidly sampled Feuille de Tabac today, and am now desperately looking for unscented soap! Funny how you can never find unscented soap when you need it!

Oh well, I'll just have to spray a little bit unconventionally. Say when!
post #13 of 477
I just rubbed down with unscented deodorant and soap, and I'm ready to spray!
post #14 of 477
Aiona, shall we go for it?
post #15 of 477
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thalia View Post

Aiona, shall we go for it?

It *is* 8 PM my time. I guess so.
post #16 of 477
Thread Starter 
Ready, set, go!
post #17 of 477
Thread Starter 
Seems like we are slower -- like usual -- today! Would not one know it? hahaha
post #18 of 477
OK -- it goes on sweet. And citric -- not bergamot, I think.
post #19 of 477
It's opening fresh, not warm.
post #20 of 477
Lemon?
post #21 of 477
Oh geez, there's something a little urinous in there.
post #22 of 477
Okay, now I'm worried. Thalia, I have not smelled this before. I have no idea what it is!

A is a beautiful yellow color. It is clearly not viscous. I have about a 1 ml sample in a miniature atomizer. It rolls back and forth easily. So it's not an oil.

I sniffed the nozzle, and it smells a bit oily. Vaguely familiar. But when I spray it on my skin, I agree with Thalia, the opening is a sharp alcohol smell, and very fruity sharp! But it's not a familiar fruit. Maybe vaguely like rambutan. But not really.

Definitely not bergamot.

And it smells. . . oily? I don't know what that note is. I've smelled it in other perfumes before.

Can we Google for notes?
post #23 of 477
After the opening, it isn't sweet at all -- it's kind of woody. Like maybe cedar? Cedar or some other wood and lemon Pledge and that weird tangy pee-ish note
post #24 of 477
Thread Starter 
You can Google or use whatever source you would like.

Bergamot -- Yes!
post #25 of 477
Yeah, it opened with a REALLY STRONG alcohol note, but I thought that was just because I had sprayed a lot and sniffed right away.
post #26 of 477
Ladies, do you get any vibe from the fragrance? Do you think, is it designer, niche or mass market fragrance? Does it have a celeb vibe?

Aiona, I will pick this tip from you next time I'm sniffing -- to roll the liquid up and down the vial.
post #27 of 477
I don't recognize this at all, either, Aiona, but I didn't expect to -- I'm not that experienced!

If I had to guess, I would guess this is a masculine. Or else a '90s unisex.
post #28 of 477
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thalia View Post

lemon Pledge and that weird tangy pee-ish note

Ah, yes. That oily smell does kind of remind me of a wood furniture cleaner, making me think of that oily sheen one has, after one has wiped with it. Something sharp. Maybe that's what you are smelling as a pee note.

It has some pretty good sillage, too. I sprayed it in one room, and left that room. Husband walked into that room and goes, "My God! Does the whole house smell like perfume!" He doesn't like anything I wear.

It's not an unpleasant perfume, but it's not something I typically wear. If I were to guess, I'd say it's marketed for women.
post #29 of 477
Yes, this is pretty strong! Hey, is there cumin in this? I'm starting to get a little bit of a curryish feeling ...
post #30 of 477
Thread Starter 
Does it smell expensive? How much would one pay for, say, 50ml of Fragrance A, if it were your taste?
post #31 of 477
Also, I'm pretty sure there's vanilla. My daughter sniffed my wrist and she picked it up right away! Like vanilla extract, not cupcakes.
post #32 of 477
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thalia View Post

If I had to guess, I would guess this is a masculine. Or else a '90s unisex.

I am cracking up! It really is a subjective thing, huh? Ah well.

And I was wrong about the bergamot, I see. Ah well, again. I am striking out a lot tonight!

As for what kind of scent this is. . . gee, let's see if I can get three strikes tonight! I don't sniff a lot of celebuscents, so I don't know that I can really classify them. I do think it has something in it that enhances its sillage. Could it be something synthetic? And if so, perhaps it's more likely to be a more mass market type fragrance?

Waiting for the umpire's call,
Aiona
post #33 of 477
Um, I'm terrible at guessing priciness! but it doesn't smell artificial or shampooey, so I'm guessing it's fairly expensive.
post #34 of 477
Hahahaha! Again, we're getting different impressions.
post #35 of 477
I guess I would expect a cheap citrussy vanilla to be really sweet ...
post #36 of 477
Thread Starter 
The notes picked up correctly so far are: bergamot, vanilla.

What do you think is the character of Fragrance A -- I know you have mentioned fresh and warm. COuld you please come up with more descriptives?
post #37 of 477
I agree with Thalia, there's gotta be vanilla in it, which is why it's tolerable to me. Vanilla or something of the like, like tonka bean.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Twolf View Post

Does it smell expensive? How much would one pay for, say, 50ml of Fragrance A, if it were your taste?

Well, based on my guess that it might harbor something synthetic that makes it project so awesomely, I would guess it's mass marketed, and hence, not as expensive as something with more subtle natural oils. So, based on that assumption, I would say it's, er. . . $90/50 ml?
post #38 of 477
Thread Starter 
It costs more than $30 for 50ml.
post #39 of 477
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thalia View Post

Hahahaha! Again, we're getting different impressions.

Indeed! My goodness! I hope we're not confusing readers with our different impressions!

I do agree that it does *not* smell shampooey. I have never smelled a shampoo like this perfume.
post #40 of 477
Thread Starter 
I got good projection on this skin too. It also lasts, especially on the hair.
post #41 of 477
Harsh. Full -- it's not a sheer scent. There's something animalic about it.
post #42 of 477
Is there rose in this?
post #43 of 477
It's getting floral and, oddly, less woody to me -- usually things get MORE woody!
post #44 of 477
Quote:
Originally Posted by Twolf View Post

The notes picked up correctly so far are: bergamot, vanilla.

Yay! That rules out at least 2 fragrances in the world.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Twolf View Post

What do you think is the character of Fragrance A -- I know you have mentioned fresh and warm. COuld you please come up with more descriptives?

Hmm. . . well, it's "oily." Most other "oily" perfumes I've smelled tend to be nighttime perfumes. Something I'd wear for an evening out. But this has that sharp, fruity smell that makes it a little less cloying/oily.

I'm not sure how to describe it.
post #45 of 477
i think Aiona is right -- this is marketed as a feminine.
post #46 of 477
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thalia View Post

Is there rose in this?

Rose! Yes, Thalia! That's the floral smell!
post #47 of 477
Quote:
Originally Posted by Twolf View Post

It costs more than $30 for 50ml.

...but less than $40? or are you just saying "more than $30"?
post #48 of 477
Yeah, Rose. Definitely rose. It's been 30+ minutes post-spray on skin, and now that you've mentioned that 'rose,' Thalia, that's all I can smell now! Maybe a bit of vanilla, and that's what makes it tolerable.

I don't think there is any patchouli in it. Or if there is, it's not a lot.
post #49 of 477
It smells oily to me too - like citrus peel oil, not juice ...
post #50 of 477
Quote:
Originally Posted by Thalia View Post

Harsh. Full -- it's not a sheer scent. There's something animalic about it.

Maybe the oily thing I'm smelling. Maybe civet?
post #51 of 477
Thread Starter 
You, ladies, are doing an increadibly great job. I have just checked the BN directory -- out of 383 fragrances containing bergamot and vanilla, would you say it is in any way similar to:
TM Angel,
Lanvin Arpege,
Anna Pliska,
VW Boudoir?

Warum, it is more than $30 for 50ml.
post #52 of 477
Quote:
Originally Posted by Twolf View Post

What do you think is the character of Fragrance A -- I know you have mentioned fresh and warm. COuld you please come up with more descriptives?

I'm totally not good at classification. I can say with absolute certainty that it is not an acquatic.

But could it be a sort of chypre? Or oriental?

It's definitely not 'green.'
post #53 of 477
It could be a lot of things! not leather, I'm pretty sure, but could be civet or cumin for sweatiness ...
post #54 of 477
Thread Starter 
I get this citrus peel oil too, slightly fruity and sort of heavy.

"Civet" would be a blonde singing in the deep bass octave -- do you really get that?
post #55 of 477
Yeah, not green, not gourmand, or aquatic, or fruity-floral in the tutti-frutti sense. Chypre sounds good, or oriental. Or aromatic?
post #56 of 477
Let me clarify. I do not think this is an aquatic because I smell no melon (which I associate with aquatics).

It is not anything like Angel. Why? Because it does not bowl me over with patchouli of any sort.
I have not tried Arpege or Pliska.
I *have* tried Boudoir. Um, it does kind of remind me of Boudoir.
post #57 of 477
I'm not sure I recognize civet! Although there's a weird skankiness in Chanel No. 5 taht I have always assumed was civet.
post #58 of 477
Quote:
Originally Posted by Twolf View Post

I get this citrus peel oil too, slightly fruity and sort of heavy.

"Civet" would be a blond singing in the deep bass octave -- do you really get that?

Yeah, you're right. I don't get civet. And it's definitely not a leather scent.

I don't smell any rosemary or artemesia in it that I associate with aromatics like Yatagan.

Boudoir. . . made stinky by the viburnum, I believe. Sample A does have a bit of stinkiness to it.
Boudoir had a smell like fish sauce to me. Sample A doesn't smell like fish sauce. But. . . it has a similar quality.
post #59 of 477
I'm embarrassed to say that I haven't smelled any of the scents you list!

TM Angel,
Lanvin Arpege,
Anna Pliska,
VW Boudoir

Boudoir seems plausible because my understanding is that that one's a little dirty. Angel's a big chocolate patchouli sweet bomb, yes? This is barely sweet. Anne Pliska is an orangey warm oriental, right?
post #60 of 477
Is there amber in this?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Female Fragrance Discussion
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Female Fragrance Discussion › March Blind Sniff: Those Moody Blues