Originally Posted by Grottola
Tommy Bahama Set Sail St. Barts.
Virgin Island Water is the clear winner out of both of those, but it isn't worth $150+.
Great frugal post.
Sean John Unforgivable Black is pretty decent for a designer release, and I think besides I Am King and the standard Unforgivable, all of Sean John's scents have been very good fruity designer scents, as bad as their origins are (biting Millesime Imperial).
But in all honesty, I would buy VIW at discount. As good as set sail st. barts top is, the drydown is lackluster.