Guerlain Spiritueuse Double Vanille is my go-to vanilla treat. It is so, so fine. I am about to spring for Tonka Imperiale. And even Creed Sublime Vanille is calling my name. Guess I'm on a vanilla binge, eh?
A vanilla centered fragrance that is actually good--that's a tough one. I'd recommend Caron pour un Homme though you must like lavender or perhaps something a little drier like Patou's discontinued Ma Liberte.
Just sampled Spiriteuse Double Vanille and there was nothing other than vanilla extract on my skin. This has been the best recreation of vanilla on my skin but nothing else! I gotta say I am disappointed.
D&G The One is a nice little vanilla based scent that's widely available and not too pricey. Tobacco Vanilla is a perfect fragrance, but I wouldn't necessarily classify it as a vanilla scent or recommend it for someone looking for vanilla -- it's more off on its own.
SDV - Guerlain
Un Bois Vanille - Serge Lutens
Tobacco Vanille - Tom Ford
Havana Vanille - L'Artisan
Vanille Absolutment - L'Artisan
Eau Duelle - Diptyque
Tonka Imperiale - Guerlain
Musc Ravageur (DRY DOWN) - Frederic Malle
Pi - Givenchy
AND OF COURSE Le Male - Jean Paul Gaultier (HATE IT)