There are some gems if you feel like digging. Each category has a pretty varied range of fragrances, maybe you could just go by themes you like. Most of their scents have a list of notes in the description, and the bpal forum has reviews for just about all the scents. They are oils so it's different from wearing an alcohol based perfume.
I have a few favorites, they have a nice touch with woods, spice, musks, patchouli, and more. Let's see.....I like Mad Hatter, Baron Samedi (it's their version of bay rum, with almond and lots of vetiver), Nyarlathotep, Djinn, Plunder, many more.....
I think my favorite section is the Salon, where they have perfumes inspired by paintings. I particularly like Cloister Graveyard In The Snow. I also found a few winners in the Carnaval Diabolique section which is supposed to be limited edition, but it has been around for about 5 years.
Speaking of limited editions.....yeah. They have limited seasonal scents almost all the time, and it does get a little ridiculous trying to keep up with all the updates and limited scents, and I can totally understand how people 'get the fever' for it all.
Unfortunately the search engine has been down for a while, so you can't really search by notes right now.