Originally Posted by PalmBeach
Pretty simple. What is one persons Filet Mignon is another persons McDonalds Hamburger.
I own and like IB, and think it is a very nice fragrance, but to be honest, could easily live without it.
Same with u, I could live without it.
But I can never go without mitsoku or Shalimar.- - - Updated - - -
Originally Posted by hedonist222
Bo'3naim, I had the exact response whn I tried it.
A huge HUH on my face.
Quality ingredients and masterful blend , but so it's too conservative and restrained.
I know from your taste that you expect more from a perfume.
I find Sartorial very similar to it and better. It's possesses the 'oomph' you're looking for.
Lastly, it was hyped. Between IB and Sarotial, sartorial was more deserving of a hype if one were to be enforced.
That said, I'll definitely be getting a bottle of IB. I enjoy the genre amd will fit IB into the rotation.
I guess it is time for me to try Sartorial, especially the price is very good for a quality house
Although most penhalligons are weak, but i really enjoy them- - - Updated - - -
Originally Posted by FISS80
Interesting. I thought Rose 31, LDDM, and honestly LDDM were all okay. I ended up giving away LDDM, swapping Rose 31, and now trying to swap GIT, but I would NEVER swap IB unless it was for a flacon of Jardin d' Amalfi or 100ml of M.
Well, this is a perfect example that people vary in taste.
But for Jardin d'Amalfi: this is really amazing stuff
For the last 3 years or so, it is my best discovery
Although it is flagged as Femme, but well suited for man