MR smells like baby powder for too long. I've tried to like it having seen so many raving reviews but the lavender/talcum powder smell was just too much. Then there's the clove which can put some off.
New Haarlem is good-- smells like maple syrup pancakes and coffee-- but I just couldn't figure out when/why I'd wear this. Then you look at the price tag (if it were a designer, I might buy it). It's just pleasant, nothing more for me and I didn't find it very wearable.