I dont have Play Intense so I cant give any precise comment on that but VI is a good option only if you like gourmands...it is mocha mixed with chocolate notes...I'd tried play intense sometime back and as far as i remember I found it close to VI....Rochas man is too sweet for me.!!
A lot of spears might break over this, but then it hits me - it won't. Very irresistible for men is a personal favourite of mine, play and play intense however, being good, have much better marketing. I would pick Very Irresistible for men, albeit I have to admit that Play Intense does have its charm.