Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › I have a fig problem...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

I have a fig problem...

post #1 of 18
Thread Starter 
So I just purchased L'artisan Premier Figuier, which I love, but I'm afraid I've created sort of a redundancy in my wardrobe...I have enough fig based scents. Basically I wanted to put this out there in case anyone searched for it in the future (like I did previously but came up short.) I have in my current collection Philosykos, Premier Figuier, and Premier Figuier Extreme. I also have Un Jardin En Mediterranee, which I'll just mention quickly is not my favorite, but also shares a fig note. It is a good scent, but I wouldn't group it in with these 3 in terms of smelling somewhat similar.

Premier Figuier - The greenest smelling of the bunch. Giacobetti's first go at fig, and it somewhat shows. It lacks the smoothness of Philosykos, it begins sharp, almost like you snapped a fig branch and smelled the insides. The somewhat roughness of it is perhaps the most pleasing part of it. As it advances to the drydown it becomes more calm, the coconut and slight milkiness come out, but nowhere near extreme. Perhaps the shortest longevity of the 3, but still lasts decently.

Premier Figuier Extreme - If you're thinking this is the previous but stronger, you'd be slightly mislead and disappointed. It more tones down the fig for the milky coconut and sweetness aspects. And it does get sweet. After it dries down it loses a lot of the crisp fig opening and turns very sugary. Imagine spilling sweetened condensed milk on your arm and that's a good idea of what I get. It does last the longest of the bunch. Possibly my least favorite of the bunch just because it can get cloying to me.

Philosykos - If you're going to pick one of these, this is my choice. The way this is put together shows how Giacobetti has grown. It has been said before this is her revisiting her previous work on Premier Figuier, and releasing it as she felt it should be. I could see that. The milk and coconut notes are absent, except for the slight coconut vibe given from figs in the first place. I've seen it stated before that this is the scent of this whole fig tree, I can see that. Mix the fruit with the bark and leaves and you get a very authentic fig smell. Like you are resting under the actual tree, relaxing in the summer heat.

If I were to pick one it would be Philosykos, if you want to try another, well that depends on what you want...do you like sweetness? Do you want a much sweeter fig, go for Extreme. Do you want to see where Philosykos came from? Maybe have another fig scent to contrast with Philosykos, having a slightly rougher and sharp vibe? Try out Premier Figuier.

Just my thoughts on one of my favorite notes...feel free to add
post #2 of 18
Have all three in my collection and like them all. Nice assessment of all three.
post #3 of 18
I'm afraid that I am at odds with you in your appraisal of Premier Figuier Extreme by L'Artisan Parfumeur.
I very much enjoy the sweep of this composition from the initial barren, fig tree in the opening, through the budding fig in the heart, and ultimately, the consummate, ripened fig in the base.
With fig as the subject matter, one should indeed expect sweetness to be a major component.
I own and enjoy this pleasurable composition.

Premier Figuier Extreme by L'Artisan Parfumeur - Upon application, one is pleasantly treated to the sweetish greenness of fig leaves coupled with the coconutty floral of gorse flowers. This fascinating duet percolates a bit before segueing to the waiting middle. Here, in the aborning heart, a wondrous blend of galbanum, with its sour green and somewhat stemmy facets, ivy, with its pert and slightly savory character, almond milk, with its gloppy and nutty features, as well as sandalwood, with its creamy and spicy trait, gives rise to an illusion of budding figs, abounding with milky sap. Transitioning to the enhancing base, the swollen delectability of tree-ripened figs comes to fruition. A redolent, dried fruit accord, with elements of plums, apricots and peaches, commingles with the strong, camphor smell of stone pine. A hint of creamy, coconut milk flutters about to seal the illusion. A delightsome drydown ensues. This wonderful, all-season scent has good longevity, and, after an hour of radiating projection, settles to a skin scent. A truly awesome composition, it leans to the masculine side.
post #4 of 18
Thread Starter 
If it sounded like I didn't like it, I meant only when compared to the other 2. If looking for a fig scent it should still be considered. Just to me the sweetness it develops is a bit too much for me. But if the goal for your idea of a fig based scent is sweet, then by all means it's a good one, and as your said it is a very ripe (almost over ripe, to were the sweetness really comes out) fig.

As for your description, you had me up until leaning masculine, which I think if anything is mostly neutral to slightly feminine. But I guess that's why opinions exist
post #5 of 18
another fig frag , very nice ; Ninfeo Mio - Annick Goutal , a fresh & green fig
post #6 of 18
I don't detect redundancy. They're all different enough and actually unique if you're a true fig connoisseur.
post #7 of 18
My preferred figs are Jardins de Kérylos and Heeley's fig.
Not keen on overly sweet figs.
post #8 of 18
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by hedonist222 View Post

I don't detect redundancy. They're all different enough and actually unique if you're a true fig connoisseur.

It was more just a personal redundancy.

Quote:
Originally Posted by gandhajala View Post

My preferred figs are Jardins de Kérylos and Heeley's fig.
Not keen on overly sweet figs.

In the future I will probably be replacing Extreme with Heeley's fig, haven't tried it yet but I have yet to be disappointed with a Heeley. Could anyone describe it?
post #9 of 18
Heeley's fig was conceived more with the idea of a fig tree than ripe, fig-fruit in mind.
Opens with a sharp green note that always suggests sap to me.
Nice.
post #10 of 18
I prefer the sandalwood of Premier Figuier over the cedar of Philosykos and there is a cool note in Philosykos that doesn't work for me. I can see where you feel that all 3 create a redundancy, though.
post #11 of 18
I think they have a cream for that.
post #12 of 18
Anyone tried the aftelier fig ? It intrigues me ....
post #13 of 18
Un Jardin En Mediterranee.
post #14 of 18
Quote:
Originally Posted by gandhajala View Post

My preferred figs are Jardins de Kérylos and Heeley's fig.

Same here...
post #15 of 18
Quote:
Originally Posted by Makassar View Post

another fig frag , very nice ; Ninfeo Mio - Annick Goutal , a fresh & green fig

That is also my favourite fig fragrance. I find the ones you mention too green. NM, on the other hand, has this wonderful citrus that transports you directly to a garden in AndalucÃ*a. Satisfying and long-lasting as well.
post #16 of 18
two of the best fig frags aren't even mentioned in this fig thread. too bad.
post #17 of 18
Quote:
Originally Posted by PuddleMonkey View Post

two of the best fig frags aren't even mentioned in this fig thread. too bad.

PM, stop lurking, now! Glad to see you around...
post #18 of 18
I don't think you have a fig problem at all. Rather you have a fig leaf problem - I'm pretty sure that's the main note in each of your scents.

I did test them all at some time or other. I wasn't as impressed with Philosykos as many others here are, I liked the L'Artisan ones better.

That said, I really like longevity in fig leaf scents, which is why I still greatly prefer Good Life and Salvatore Ferragamo PH.
Regards,
Renato
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: MFD Archive
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › MFD Archive › I have a fig problem...