I'll suggest one that doesn't seem to get much love among BN'er's. . .
Burberry Touch for Men. . .violet, pepper, light vanilla musk. Maybe a little mature for high school, but I can bet no one else will be wearing it. You can get a 3.4oz. bottle for around $40 on Amazon.
I bought my first bottle in Rome back in 2003. Every time I wear it now, I get Roman flashbacks!
On my third 100ml (3.4oz) bottle.
P.S. Another great frag: Moschino Uomo? Rosewood, cinnamon, musk. I've gotten lots of compliments on this one. Big bottle (4.2oz) for under $40 most everywhere.