Hello Everyone, I'm Jay from Chicago, Illinois and I'm new to basenotes and the fragrance community. I'm 27, and recently really got into the whole fragrance collection. i use to be a 1 fragrance only guy, I used Acqua Di Gio by Armani for about 2 to 3 years before i finally got tired of the same ol scent and decided to sample different colognes. i now have a vast collection, well vast compared to the 1 cologne i use to keep before anyway, but i am looking to add to my collection. so I'm on here to ask the people who know their colognes what they recommend i buy. I'm looking for colognes that smell really good, are long lasting (which is a problem with a lot of my current colognes) and something not everybody is wearing. Up until now i have stuck to designer colognes, which are used by many. looking for something more unique. here is a list of my current colognes to give yous an idea of what i like: ck shock, play intense by givinchy, paco rabanne 1 million, bleu de chanel, burberry brit summer edition, guilty by gucci, la coste red, white, blue, and green. and love the mugler colognes, have angel men, pure shot, pure malt, pure havane, still have to get my hands on pure coffee. have heard good things about the colognes by tom ford, hermes, dior, creed. which colognes do you recommend from these guys or what other type of cologne is out there that you would recommend?? thank you in advance to anybody who shares their opinion and sorry about the novel i wrote. on a side note, I'm horrible with the scents, i don't know what vetiver, musk, patchuli, tonka bean smell like. but my favorite scent right now would be angel men by thierry mugler, i like the way that smells, and like the fact that it lasts. so maybe something similar to amen, also really like the burberry, gucci smells good just fades really fast. oh and i also have l'homme by ysl. that smells really good too.
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Just Starting Out › New to basenotes and the Fragrance Community!
Recent Reviews
-
Skimming through the reviews of Habit Rouge it's apparent that this scent comes/came in many incarnations, wastly different. I've tried a current EdT. .. There's nothing masculine about this...
-
I dislike the original AdG, always have because of the bitterness and strange orange synthetic note. The Essenza after one wear won me over, smooth opening, soft woodiness once it settles down....
-
Disturbingly bad. This opens up obscure, smoky, spicy and what seems like an attempt of a jasmine flower note. I have smelt jasmine notes from higher end perfumery and this is utterly...
-
This is the first Montale fragrance that I've liked enough to merit purchasing a full bottle. I would like to wax poetic about this frag, but Darvant and others have pretty much captured it's...
-
Here's how Tommy Bahama describes this fragrance: "With a bracing and refreshing blend of island-inspired scents, our Set Sail St. Barts cologne spray treats you to the essence of the Caribbean....
New to basenotes and the Fragrance Community!
post #2 of 18
6/7/12 at 2:06am
- hedonist222
- offline
- Gender:

- 12,959 Posts. Joined 9/2010
- Location: Abu Dhabi! UAE
- Select All Posts By This User
Hello and welcome.
Since you are unfamiliar with brands like Hermes, Dior, Tom Ford and so on that you mentioned. I urge you to try them at your pace by stopping by the boutiques or attaining samples.
This way you'll identify what you like and what you don't like and more important what needs further exploring.
Best to you!
Since you are unfamiliar with brands like Hermes, Dior, Tom Ford and so on that you mentioned. I urge you to try them at your pace by stopping by the boutiques or attaining samples.
This way you'll identify what you like and what you don't like and more important what needs further exploring.
Best to you!
post #3 of 18
6/7/12 at 3:07am
- Bigsly
- offline
- Gender:

- 8,545 Posts. Joined 2/2008
- Select All Posts By This User
post #4 of 18
6/7/12 at 3:58am
- hednic
- offline
- Gender:

- 45,627 Posts. Joined 10/2007
- Location: United States
- Select All Posts By This User
post #5 of 18
6/7/12 at 4:07am
- 30 Roses
- offline
- Gender:

- Trader Feedback: +185
- Lifelong Sniffaholic
-
- 10,474 Posts. Joined 10/2007
- Location: Connecticut
- Select All Posts By This User
Welcome to BN!
Best way to find something you like is to do a lot of sniffing!
There is a thread dedicated to perfume shopping in Chicago-- this may give you some ideas about where to try perfumes:
http://www.basenotes.net/threads/191365-Chicago
..and a Chicago area group:
http://www.basenotes.net/group.php?groupid=60
Best way to find something you like is to do a lot of sniffing!
There is a thread dedicated to perfume shopping in Chicago-- this may give you some ideas about where to try perfumes:
http://www.basenotes.net/threads/191365-Chicago
..and a Chicago area group:
http://www.basenotes.net/group.php?groupid=60
post #6 of 18
6/7/12 at 4:17am
- Ursula
- offline
- Gender:

- 589 Posts. Joined 2/2010
- Location: Flushing,NY/USA
- Select All Posts By This User
Hi, Jay08, welcome. This is the perfect place to get a thorough perfume education. Hang around and dig through the various threads. There is no hard and fast answer to all your questions in your introduction. (You may wish to make paragraphs between thoughts ... it reads easier, just saying.)
Be patient with the sometimes sluggish software reactions. It is worth the effort. Have fun.
Be patient with the sometimes sluggish software reactions. It is worth the effort. Have fun.
post #7 of 18
6/7/12 at 4:19am
- forfreddie
- offline
- Gender:

- 1,725 Posts. Joined 8/2011
- Location: Birmingham
- Select All Posts By This User
Well patchouli is one of the main players in the drydown of A*Men, also the sweetness means youre probably fond of gourmandes.
I'm not a fan of the Hermes line at all so I can't help there.
For Tom Fords try Black Orchid and Tobacco Vanille
Try some designer gourmands such as:
Dior Homme Intense and L'Instant Pour Homme Extreme by Guerlain. I'm not a real fan of this side of fragrances but they are universally liked within the community and they would be a great place to start.
I'm not a fan of the Hermes line at all so I can't help there.
For Tom Fords try Black Orchid and Tobacco Vanille
Try some designer gourmands such as:
Dior Homme Intense and L'Instant Pour Homme Extreme by Guerlain. I'm not a real fan of this side of fragrances but they are universally liked within the community and they would be a great place to start.
post #8 of 18
6/7/12 at 5:15am
- drseid
- online
- Gender:

- Trader Feedback: +12
- Good Sound Scents
-
- 4,660 Posts. Joined 12/1969
- Location: Northern VA/DC
- Select All Posts By This User
post #9 of 18
6/7/12 at 7:55am
- Mimi Gardenia
- offline
- Gender:

- Trader Feedback: +132
- Basenotes Institution
-
- 15,020 Posts. Joined 8/2008
- Location: At Home
- Select All Posts By This User
post #10 of 18
6/7/12 at 8:35am
- cacio
- offline
- Gender:

- 6,602 Posts. Joined 11/2010
- Location: Washington, DC
- Select All Posts By This User
Welcome!
As others were saying, you should just go on a few sniffing trips and try different things. Luckily, Chicago has a few good stores, as indicated in the previous posts. The best is probably Barney's on oak street, which has brands like Serge Lutens, Malle, Artisan Parfumeur, and others. But the big dept stores have stuff too, from Macys to Neiman Marcus and Saks, and then there's the Chanel boutique on Michigan for the Chanel exclusives.
You appear to like gourmand. Immortelle is a sweet-burnt sugar material that's very long lasting. A great example would be Sables by Annick Goutal (I forgot which of the big dept stores carry it, but certainly one of Nordstrom/Saks/Neiman does). Even more gourmand, Lutens Jeux de peau (at Barney's). Dior has an Eau Noire based on this material too, but it is sold only in Dior boutiques and I don't think there's one in Chicago.
Lutens has others hovering in gourmand/patch territory, like Borneo (patchouli chocolate) or Arabie (bitters).
For a completely different genre, I recommend that you also stop by the Chanel boutique and try Sycomore, a vetiver with a touch of woods, very fresh, natural smelling and long lasting. Another in the line you might be interested in is Coromandel, which contains patchouli.
cacio
As others were saying, you should just go on a few sniffing trips and try different things. Luckily, Chicago has a few good stores, as indicated in the previous posts. The best is probably Barney's on oak street, which has brands like Serge Lutens, Malle, Artisan Parfumeur, and others. But the big dept stores have stuff too, from Macys to Neiman Marcus and Saks, and then there's the Chanel boutique on Michigan for the Chanel exclusives.
You appear to like gourmand. Immortelle is a sweet-burnt sugar material that's very long lasting. A great example would be Sables by Annick Goutal (I forgot which of the big dept stores carry it, but certainly one of Nordstrom/Saks/Neiman does). Even more gourmand, Lutens Jeux de peau (at Barney's). Dior has an Eau Noire based on this material too, but it is sold only in Dior boutiques and I don't think there's one in Chicago.
Lutens has others hovering in gourmand/patch territory, like Borneo (patchouli chocolate) or Arabie (bitters).
For a completely different genre, I recommend that you also stop by the Chanel boutique and try Sycomore, a vetiver with a touch of woods, very fresh, natural smelling and long lasting. Another in the line you might be interested in is Coromandel, which contains patchouli.
cacio
post #11 of 18
6/7/12 at 9:53am
- mesaboogie
- offline
- Gender:

- 2,885 Posts. Joined 8/2011
- Location: Los Anchorage, AK
- Select All Posts By This User
post #12 of 18
6/7/12 at 10:33am
- knit at nite
- offline
- Gender:

- 4,572 Posts. Joined 9/2009
- Location: CA, Central Coast
- Select All Posts By This User
post #13 of 18
6/7/12 at 11:46am
- Kagey
- offline
- Gender:

- 1,463 Posts. Joined 1/2011
- Location: England
- Select All Posts By This User
Welcome! You've come to the right place 
I agree with those who say to smell lots of things and learn more about what you like. And avoid buying until you do!
If you like A*Men, I'm thinking you might like Serge Lutens's Borneo 1834, and also Coromandel from the Chanel Exclusives line. Since you seem to like heavier, sweeter things, other Serge Lutens scents might also appeal. I also thought of Parfumerie Generale and thought you might like Bois Naufrage, Un Crime Exotique, Coze, or L'Ombre Fauve.

I agree with those who say to smell lots of things and learn more about what you like. And avoid buying until you do!
If you like A*Men, I'm thinking you might like Serge Lutens's Borneo 1834, and also Coromandel from the Chanel Exclusives line. Since you seem to like heavier, sweeter things, other Serge Lutens scents might also appeal. I also thought of Parfumerie Generale and thought you might like Bois Naufrage, Un Crime Exotique, Coze, or L'Ombre Fauve.
- Jay08
- offline
- Gender:

- 9 Posts. Joined 6/2012
- Location: Chicago
- Select All Posts By This User
hello everyone and thanks for the replies, sorry if my original thread was a little difficult to keep up with, wrote it at like 2 in the morning on my cell phone.
i guess i have a lot or work or should i say sniffing to do, i thought maybe i would get lucky and there would be that 1 cologne that the majority of the people here would agree on that is awesome but i guess i'm not that lucky. lol. should have realized everybody's tastes are different and what may be awesome to me might not make someone else's top 100. lol.
upon thinking about ti a little i agree with the people saying i may like gourmands, I've herd good things about tom Ford's tobacco vanille. and if patchouli is the main smell in A*men then i am certainly gonna look into fragrances that have that.
again just want to thank everyone that commented on my post, your help and your recommendations are much appreciated. i will try and sample every cologne recommended here and go from there.
i guess i have a lot or work or should i say sniffing to do, i thought maybe i would get lucky and there would be that 1 cologne that the majority of the people here would agree on that is awesome but i guess i'm not that lucky. lol. should have realized everybody's tastes are different and what may be awesome to me might not make someone else's top 100. lol.
upon thinking about ti a little i agree with the people saying i may like gourmands, I've herd good things about tom Ford's tobacco vanille. and if patchouli is the main smell in A*men then i am certainly gonna look into fragrances that have that.
again just want to thank everyone that commented on my post, your help and your recommendations are much appreciated. i will try and sample every cologne recommended here and go from there.
- Jay08
- offline
- Gender:

- 9 Posts. Joined 6/2012
- Location: Chicago
- Select All Posts By This User
hello everyone and thanks for the replies, sorry if my original thread was a little difficult to keep up with, wrote it at like 2 in the morning on my cell phone.
i guess i have a lot or work or should i say sniffing to do, i thought maybe i would get lucky and there would be that 1 cologne that the majority of the people here would agree on that is awesome but i guess i'm not that lucky. lol. should have realized everybody's tastes are different and what may be awesome to me might not make someone else's top 100. lol.
upon thinking about ti a little i agree with the people saying i may like gourmands, I've herd good things about tom Ford's tobacco vanille. and if patchouli is the main smell in A*men then i am certainly gonna look into fragrances that have that.
again just want to thank everyone that commented on my post, your help and your recommendations are much appreciated. i will try and sample every cologne recommended here and go from there.
i guess i have a lot or work or should i say sniffing to do, i thought maybe i would get lucky and there would be that 1 cologne that the majority of the people here would agree on that is awesome but i guess i'm not that lucky. lol. should have realized everybody's tastes are different and what may be awesome to me might not make someone else's top 100. lol.
upon thinking about ti a little i agree with the people saying i may like gourmands, I've herd good things about tom Ford's tobacco vanille. and if patchouli is the main smell in A*men then i am certainly gonna look into fragrances that have that.
again just want to thank everyone that commented on my post, your help and your recommendations are much appreciated. i will try and sample every cologne recommended here and go from there.
post #16 of 18
6/8/12 at 5:23pm
- dollars&scents
- offline
- Gender:

- 6,676 Posts. Joined 9/2011
- Location: South Florida
- Select All Posts By This User
Try:
A*Men Le Gout du Parfum/Taste of Fragrance (Pure Chili) - Here is a flanker to the original A*Men, wherein an enhancer, in this case chili or red pepper concentrate, is added to the mix to exalt the original's notes, to wit, the versatility of the patchouli and the richness of the coffee. I might add that it is done superbly.
Initially, one is treated to a somewhat mellow, yet familiar, cherry-vanillic, medicinal scent from the interplay of bittersweet bergamot, refreshing spearmint, fresh lavender, the nutty woodiness of coriander and magical, creamy tonka bean. A warm and smooth spiciness from the chili/red pepper showers the melange with its facets. Transitioning to the heart, aromatic patchouli releases its sweetish cocoa character, commingling with the tart fruitiness of pink pepper, as well as the creamy and sweet woodiness of Virginia cedar. Resultantly, a lovely, bittersweet chocolate plays with the spiciness of the chili/red pepper. A faint undercurrent of coffee brews and carries the melange to the base. Here, the rich, roasted coffee comes into its own and combines with the mystical, sweetly woody vanilla, capturing an extraordinary, cafe mocha aura, while a faint soapiness of musk flitters about. An alluring drydown ensues. This unique and masculine scent have average projection, 2-hour scent cloud, then becoming a skin scent, and average, 7-8 hours, longevity. A truly distinctive composition that can be enjoyed all year round.
&
Spicebomb by Viktor & Rolf - Upon application, one is treated to a somewhat refreshing, fruity and citric blend from the commingling of an orangey and peppery bergamot, the tangy bittersweetness of grapefruit and the mildly spicy fruitiness of pink pepper. And, an intriguing elemi showers the blend with its resinous and balsamic spiciness. Resultantly, an all-too-familiar, sweet, spicy, bubble-gum smell wafts to the waiting middle. Here, in the heart, the Bazooka-like opening is immersed in an enveloping stew of sweetly warm and earthy cinnamon, a pepperish paprika and a healthy dose of hay-like floral from saffron. A sweet, pipe tobacco undercurrent carries this inviting melange to the base. Here, the luxurious, cherry-almond, pipe tobacco comes into it own and interplays with the rich, green and smoky earthiness of vetiver. A faint background of a vanillic musk and leather present. A suave drydown ensues. This versatile and high-quality scent has good projection, with a 3-hour, scent cloud, and good longevity, 7-8- hours. However, this composition appears to have purloined its varied, scent paths from other, existing scents. And, although I give the fragrance a "Thumbs Up," it is given unenthusiastically because of the flagrant lack of originality.
&

A*Men Le Gout du Parfum/Taste of Fragrance (Pure Chili) - Here is a flanker to the original A*Men, wherein an enhancer, in this case chili or red pepper concentrate, is added to the mix to exalt the original's notes, to wit, the versatility of the patchouli and the richness of the coffee. I might add that it is done superbly.
Initially, one is treated to a somewhat mellow, yet familiar, cherry-vanillic, medicinal scent from the interplay of bittersweet bergamot, refreshing spearmint, fresh lavender, the nutty woodiness of coriander and magical, creamy tonka bean. A warm and smooth spiciness from the chili/red pepper showers the melange with its facets. Transitioning to the heart, aromatic patchouli releases its sweetish cocoa character, commingling with the tart fruitiness of pink pepper, as well as the creamy and sweet woodiness of Virginia cedar. Resultantly, a lovely, bittersweet chocolate plays with the spiciness of the chili/red pepper. A faint undercurrent of coffee brews and carries the melange to the base. Here, the rich, roasted coffee comes into its own and combines with the mystical, sweetly woody vanilla, capturing an extraordinary, cafe mocha aura, while a faint soapiness of musk flitters about. An alluring drydown ensues. This unique and masculine scent have average projection, 2-hour scent cloud, then becoming a skin scent, and average, 7-8 hours, longevity. A truly distinctive composition that can be enjoyed all year round.
&
Spicebomb by Viktor & Rolf - Upon application, one is treated to a somewhat refreshing, fruity and citric blend from the commingling of an orangey and peppery bergamot, the tangy bittersweetness of grapefruit and the mildly spicy fruitiness of pink pepper. And, an intriguing elemi showers the blend with its resinous and balsamic spiciness. Resultantly, an all-too-familiar, sweet, spicy, bubble-gum smell wafts to the waiting middle. Here, in the heart, the Bazooka-like opening is immersed in an enveloping stew of sweetly warm and earthy cinnamon, a pepperish paprika and a healthy dose of hay-like floral from saffron. A sweet, pipe tobacco undercurrent carries this inviting melange to the base. Here, the luxurious, cherry-almond, pipe tobacco comes into it own and interplays with the rich, green and smoky earthiness of vetiver. A faint background of a vanillic musk and leather present. A suave drydown ensues. This versatile and high-quality scent has good projection, with a 3-hour, scent cloud, and good longevity, 7-8- hours. However, this composition appears to have purloined its varied, scent paths from other, existing scents. And, although I give the fragrance a "Thumbs Up," it is given unenthusiastically because of the flagrant lack of originality.
&

post #17 of 18
6/9/12 at 12:33am
- Sovski
- offline
- 63 Posts. Joined 7/2011
- Location: Washington
- Select All Posts By This User
Make sure you SAMPLE stuff and give it a good wear before you decide on buying! Especially with the niche stuff...
Some of my favorites:
YSL La Nuit de L'homme - The night time/flanker version to L'Homme which you have. It's sweet and spicy.
Dior Homme Intense - Powdery Iris which drys down to vanilla/cocoa. Great scent.
Chanel Allure Homme Edition Blanche - Very natural creamy lemon... think lemon meringue pie
Creed Millesime Imperial - Great fresh fruity aquatic... think chopped up melons by the sea side drizzled with salt
Ed Hardy Love and Luck - Similar to Millesime Imperial minus the salty accord and replace melon with pear... also a LOT cheaper
Carolina Herrera 212 Men - Fresh cut green grass that dries down to a nice sweet musk.
Acqua di Parma Arancia di Capri - Great orange focused citrus... just doesn't seem to last very long
Acua di Parma Mandorlo di Sicilia - Almonds and vanilla... very sweet and soft scent
Just get out there and see what you like... blind buying can be very expensive
Some of my favorites:
YSL La Nuit de L'homme - The night time/flanker version to L'Homme which you have. It's sweet and spicy.
Dior Homme Intense - Powdery Iris which drys down to vanilla/cocoa. Great scent.
Chanel Allure Homme Edition Blanche - Very natural creamy lemon... think lemon meringue pie
Creed Millesime Imperial - Great fresh fruity aquatic... think chopped up melons by the sea side drizzled with salt
Ed Hardy Love and Luck - Similar to Millesime Imperial minus the salty accord and replace melon with pear... also a LOT cheaper

Carolina Herrera 212 Men - Fresh cut green grass that dries down to a nice sweet musk.
Acqua di Parma Arancia di Capri - Great orange focused citrus... just doesn't seem to last very long
Acua di Parma Mandorlo di Sicilia - Almonds and vanilla... very sweet and soft scent
Just get out there and see what you like... blind buying can be very expensive
post #18 of 18
6/10/12 at 5:51am
- heavenscent1
- offline
- Gender:

- 514 Posts. Joined 3/2012
- Location: Nebraska
- Select All Posts By This User
Welcome to Basenotes! I'm pretty new here, too, and everyone has been very helpful. You might try just buying samples from ebay, Luckyscent, and other sites for a while and sniff everything you can at the dept. store counters. If you know what basic notes you like that goes a long way towards a successful blind buy. Lots of good reviews of fragrances on this site, but it can be confusing when there is almost always some difference of opinion about a certain fragrance. I think it all boils down to skin chemistry. I like to toggle back and forth between ebay listings and the reviews on this site to see if it's worth a blind buy. Good luck!
Return Home
Back to Forum: Just Starting Out
- New to basenotes and the Fragrance Community!
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Just Starting Out › New to basenotes and the Fragrance Community!
Currently, there are 391 Active Users
(49 Members and 342 Guests)
Recent Discussions
- › Question-Answer Game Part 6 18 seconds ago
- › LOLITA LEMPICKA AU MASCULIN 3 minutes ago
- › montale direct ordering? 3 minutes ago
- › spicebomb vs burberry london 5 minutes ago
- › COTD—how are we caffeinating today? 7 minutes ago
- › MILANO CAFFE' GIVEWAY 7 minutes ago
- › SOTD: Wednesday, June 19th, 2013 7 minutes ago
- › Latest Movie/DVD you've seen ~ PART 2 8 minutes ago
- › What are you eating/drinking? 9 minutes ago
- › Album, EP or Song of the Day - June 2013 9 minutes ago
View: New Posts | All Discussions
Recent Reviews
- › Bentley For Men Intense by Bentley, 2013 by drseid
- › Habit Rouge by Guerlain, 1965 by Ronaldtimmermann
- › Acqua Di Giò Essenza by Giorgio Armani, 2012 by nyguy
- › Indian Night Jasmine by Body Shop, 2012 by IsaIsabella
- › Dark Aoud by Montale, 2011 by seeminglytransparent
- › Set Sail St. Barts For Men by Tommy Bahama, 2007 by marcuslaughter
- › Set Sail Martinique For Men by Tommy Bahama, 2010 by marcuslaughter
- › Bulgari Man Extreme by Bulgari, 2013 by marcuslaughter
- › Lime Sec by Pinaud by marcuslaughter
- › Lilac Vegetal by Pinaud, 1880 by marcuslaughter
View: More Reviews
New Fragrance Articles
- › Aoud by M.Micallef celebrates its Tenth... by Judith Brockless
- › Dueto Parfums release new fragrance, Citiver by Judith Brockless
- › Guerlain ‘Les Parisiennes’... by Judith Brockless
- › Iris Prima: ‘The Spirit of the Ballet. ... by Judith Brockless
- › Pell Wall Releases 1953 Pour Homme and Eau de... by Judith Brockless
- › Serge Lutens by Grant
- › An Interview with Christopher Sheldrake -... by Grant
- › Aedes de Venustas launch Iris Nazarena next... by Grant
- › UK FiFi Award winners 2013 by Grant
- › UK FiFi Awards tonight. by Grant
Home | Fragrance Product Guide | Forums | Fragrance Articles | My Profile
About Basenotes | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2013 Basenotes is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle
About Basenotes | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2013 Basenotes is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle






