I have tried the Pipe Tobacco accord, I wasn't really thrilled with it. I LOVE the smell of pipe tobacco, and the CBIHP Pipe Tobacco accord didn't smell at all like tobacco to me. That said I would love to try both of the Cumming fragrances and In the Library. Burning Leaves also sounds very good.
I actually love the founder's work on the Demeter colognes. Does the I Hate Perfumes line have at least slightly better staying power, are they of much higher quality than Demeter, and I see they come in water-based perfume form... but any other form too?
When I tried the accord I didn't get a lot of mileage out if it. Seems like I got about three or four hours out of the fragrance IIRC. A quick read of their FAQs on their website shows that they make water based and some oil based fragrances, but no alcohol based ones.