Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Fragrance Industry and General Fragrance Discussion › What is the most OVERRATED fragrance?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

What is the most OVERRATED fragrance? - Page 3

post #121 of 205
10/2/12 at 4:40pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by dollars&scents View Post

La Nuit De L'Homme by Yves Saint Laurent is too saccharine and teeters on the feminine side.
And, to make matters worst, it is a humdrum composition, at best.


Funny thing about La Nuit De L'Homme is if you look at its reviews on Fragrantica, it is probably the highest rated fragrance with such an enormous amount of reviews (over 1500 people have rated it). So it's tremendously successful. Personally, I never cared for it, and I'm wondering if I should revisit it given all the great ratings.
Reply
Reply

Features on Basenotes

Basenotes Reader Awards 2013 - Finalists Announced.
Greatest Hits: Annick Menardo
Petals Falling From The Sky - A Report From The Cote d'Azur's Bataille De Fleurs
post #122 of 205
10/2/12 at 4:45pm
Tea for Two, not really my thing
Reply
Reply
post #123 of 205
10/2/12 at 4:46pm
Tuscan Leather
Reply
Reply
post #124 of 205
10/2/12 at 5:06pm
I agree with YSL La Nuit De L'Homme. I bought a bottle based on the hype and hated it. It just smells so synthetic to me. Never buying a fragrance based on hype ever again.
Reply
Reply
post #125 of 205
10/2/12 at 5:27pm
+1 on The Dream. Nothing unique about it; opening is terrible, dry down is only decent.
Reply
Reply
post #126 of 205
10/2/12 at 5:29pm
Creed Millesime Imperial - I'm afraid I just really don't get it...at all
Reply
Reply
post #127 of 205
10/2/12 at 5:58pm
GIT. But then again, so is Cool Water.
Reply
Reply
post #128 of 205
10/2/12 at 6:01pm
By far and away Knize ten.
Reply
Reply
post #129 of 205
10/2/12 at 6:16pm
Puredistance M. Ok it is good. But not THAT good.
Reply
Reply
post #130 of 205
10/2/12 at 6:25pm
-The Dreamer (current version) +1
- Egoiste +1
Reply
Reply
post #131 of 205
10/2/12 at 6:26pm
Diamondflame, you are absolutely right. I just happened to get a sniff at Puredistance M today, in NYC. It is good, but nothing that I would go out of my way to purchase and let alone, pay an enormous amount for. It is truly overrated big time.
Reply
Reply
post #132 of 205
10/2/12 at 6:45pm
one million. aqua di gio. bought these sorta before my "basenote days". but to the person that said pure malt, i just bought it haha. and i love the dreamer. another mans trash...
Reply
Reply
post #133 of 205
10/2/12 at 6:52pm
Pour Monsieur and Antaeus are both grossly overrated on here. They smell dated and just plain bad to me.
Reply
Reply
post #134 of 205
10/2/12 at 6:53pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by justiceanthony View Post

I sometimes wonder why AdG is sooo highly regarded.....to me it's a fragrance that basically does nothing for me.


Wow. There's nothing overrated about AdG. It isn't the sort of bold and exciting scent that will thrill the experienced noses of basenotes, but it is among the highest regarded scents for men among women in the real world. I will gladly tip my hat to any perfumer who can accomplish that.

- - - Updated - - -

Quote:
Originally Posted by Buysblind View Post

Funny thing about La Nuit De L'Homme is if you look at its reviews on Fragrantica, it is probably the highest rated fragrance with such an enormous amount of reviews (over 1500 people have rated it). So it's tremendously successful. Personally, I never cared for it, and I'm wondering if I should revisit it given all the great ratings.

I've been having that thought too.

I can't really add anything that I think is overrated, because really, that'd just be me saying I don't like it. I don't like Egoiste, but that doesn't mean it's overrated. It just means I don't enjoy it.
Reply
Reply
post #135 of 205
10/2/12 at 7:33pm


Reply
Reply
post #136 of 205
10/2/12 at 7:50pm
Imperial Millesime
Dior Leather Oud
TF Tuscan Leather
Knize Ten
Frederic Malle Musc Ravageur
Reply
Reply
post #137 of 205
10/2/12 at 9:45pm
Terre d'Hermes and Egoiste.
Reply
Reply
post #138 of 205
10/2/12 at 9:48pm
Le male.. I just don't see how I can get past the heavy mint, insane projection and synthetic vanilla.
Reply
Reply
post #139 of 205
10/2/12 at 9:49pm
The "usual suspects" of Aventus, DHI and Egoiste that have all already been mentioned... I'll add YSL L'Homme and L'Eau d'Issey pour Homme
Reply
Reply
post #140 of 205
10/2/12 at 9:50pm
Reply
Reply
post #141 of 205
10/3/12 at 12:36am
Knize Ten.
Reply
Reply
post #142 of 205
10/3/12 at 1:20am
Dior Leather Oud
Reply
Reply
post #143 of 205
10/3/12 at 1:28am
  • Zgb
  • offline
  • Gender:
Quote:
Originally Posted by crvn View Post

DHI and Aventus.

There I said it. /thread

Agree. I'm also adding La Nuit de l'homme and Jazz/Live Jazz, Creed GIT
Reply
Reply
post #144 of 205
10/3/12 at 1:31am
Aventus
Reply
Reply
post #145 of 205
10/3/12 at 1:43am
DHI. One spray of that will ruin your day. Ghastly frag, truly ghastly.
Reply
Reply
post #146 of 205
10/3/12 at 1:44am
Aventus, was so glad to obtain 10ml decant. Now I am just puzzled. Yet I love BdP.
Reply
Reply
post #147 of 205
10/3/12 at 2:05am
Knize Ten, Yatagan and Musc Ravageur
Reply
Reply
post #148 of 205
10/3/12 at 3:35am
I agree with your thoughts on Aqua di Gio, and would add Bois du Portugal, Millesime Imperial and Mugler's Cologne.

Addidas Victory League has more presence than any of them.
Regards,
Renato
Reply
Reply
post #149 of 205
10/3/12 at 3:49am
+5 or whatever on Knize 10. I'll add DHI, Rive Gauche and Guerlain Vetiver
Reply
Reply
post #150 of 205
10/3/12 at 4:23am

Creed Aventus
Reply
Reply
post #151 of 205
10/3/12 at 4:28am
Creed- Aventus by faaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr.
Reply
Reply
post #152 of 205
10/3/12 at 6:37am
Aventus (should I say AVONtus)
Cool Water
AdG
Le Male
Any Bond No 9
Opium for men
And the king of overrated: A*men
Reply
Reply
post #153 of 205
10/3/12 at 7:08am
Puredistance M
All By Kilian
DHI
Black Aoud
Musc Ravageur
Millesime Imperiale
All Le Labo
All Bond No 9




To be honest, a lot of expensive niche fragrances. It's simple human psychology. People save up and splash a huge sum on an expensive bottle and then try to hype it as much as possible to garner more interest to justify the amount they spent (hoping also that more and more people want to get that fragrance but can't owing to availability and/or price).
Reply
Reply
post #154 of 205
10/3/12 at 7:09am
Quote:
Originally Posted by Renato View Post

I agree with your thoughts on Aqua di Gio

at least someone understands what I mean, sorry AdG lovers
Reply
Reply
post #155 of 205
10/3/12 at 8:14am
Fahrenheit by Dior. Can we say 'gasoline'????
Reply
Reply
post #156 of 205
10/3/12 at 12:48pm
ACQUA DI GIO and
TERRE D' HERMES
Reply
Reply
post #157 of 205
10/3/12 at 1:04pm
Know: ADG.
Own: none really, I never bought a scent just because it was overrated.
Reply
Reply
post #158 of 205
10/3/12 at 1:27pm
1 aventus
2 aqua di gio
3 a*man
Reply
Reply
post #159 of 205
10/3/12 at 2:12pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by cannotavoidtrite View Post

Terre d'Hermes and Egoiste.


THIS!!! and add La Nuit De L'Homme and the original version.
Reply
Reply
post #160 of 205
10/3/12 at 2:54pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ken_Russell View Post

Know: ADG.
Own: none really, I never bought a scent just because it was overrated.

Reply
Reply
post #161 of 205
10/3/12 at 11:13pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by silentrich View Post

All of my Avon fragrances.

lol
Reply
Reply
post #162 of 205
10/3/12 at 11:36pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by L'Homme Blanc Individuel View Post

Wow. There's nothing overrated about AdG. It isn't the sort of bold and exciting scent that will thrill the experienced noses of basenotes, but it is among the highest regarded scents for men among women in the real world. I will gladly tip my hat to any perfumer who can accomplish that.

Very well said. ADG is severely looked down upon on this board, but is adored in the real world.
Reply
Reply
post #163 of 205
10/4/12 at 12:12am
Acqua Di Gio
Cool Water
D & G pH
Reply
Reply
post #164 of 205
10/4/12 at 12:30am
  • jss
  • offline
  • Gender:
Frederic Malle - Musc Ravageur
Any of Bond No 9
Creed - Aventus
YSL - L'Homme/La Nuit de l'Homme
Reply
Reply
post #165 of 205
10/4/12 at 1:14am
Know:
Aventus..the wood note is nice but it's light and pineapple juice? Don't get it.
Pure anything by Mugler and A*men
Spicebomb
ADG(outside BN) too many guys where this and I don't know why.
D&G anything..again probably outside BN..don't get the whole line.
Fahrenheit..pepper spray?
Reply
Reply
post #166 of 205
10/4/12 at 2:44am
Quote:
Originally Posted by heperd View Post

This is just another list of "stuff you dont like that a lot of other people like"

At least, like I've said before,....your opinion counts!
Reply
Reply
post #167 of 205
10/4/12 at 3:10am
Quote:
Originally Posted by justiceanthony View Post

at least someone understands what I mean, sorry AdG lovers

Yes, I find ADG kind of watery - like someone splashed water on me.

I'm far more fond of Halston Unbound - it's like someone splashed flavoured water on me.
Regards,
Renato
Reply
Reply
post #168 of 205
10/4/12 at 4:15am
Acqua di Parma Colonia. Yes, the rose is rather nice, but...ugh, that musk in the base! It is not a classic composition so much as the silhouette of one.
Reply
Reply
post #169 of 205
10/4/12 at 4:31am
Black Afgano
La Nuit
Musc Ravageur

Sorry but I still love Aventus.
Reply
Reply
post #170 of 205
10/5/12 at 2:21pm
Quote:
Originally Posted by L'Homme Blanc Individuel View Post

Wow. There's nothing overrated about AdG. It isn't the sort of bold and exciting scent that will thrill the experienced noses of basenotes, but it is among the highest regarded scents for men among women in the real world. I will gladly tip my hat to any perfumer who can accomplish that.


My main problem with it is that it is boring compared to others of a similar idea. The fact that it sells so much, gets so much praise, ect while I don't particularly care for it is the definition of overrated.
Reply
Reply
post #171 of 205
10/5/12 at 3:34pm
Dior Homme Sport and Chanel's Allure Homme Sport.
Reply
Reply
post #172 of 205
10/5/12 at 4:52pm
Aventus +1
Reply
Reply
post #173 of 205
10/5/12 at 9:35pm
Originally Posted by forfreddie
Ambre Sultan and Ambre Precieux - whilst they're not the most talked about - they are two of the most overrated amber's. I don't enjoy either.
I can completely agree.

I could live in that skanky amber cacoon that ambre sultan envelopes me in. I think serge lutens and sheldrake are amazing. Best perfume line that I have encountered in my short niche history. Like everyone else.....aventus, but I also don't think l artisan is all that. I've sampled nearly their whole line and haven't been interested in anything.....maybe patchouli patch. Everything duchefour make he puts cinnamon in or at least that's what it smells like to me. I just don't get the l'artisan hype.
Reply
Reply
post #174 of 205
10/6/12 at 1:40am
Eau des Beaux
Le Male
Most Bonds
Most Creeds
Pure Havane
Musc Ravageur


But I love Egoiste!
Reply
Reply
post #175 of 205
11/28/12 at 12:56am
Frank No.2
Reply
Reply
post #176 of 205
11/28/12 at 1:40am
Bang by Marc Jacobs. Remains a favourite despite my general shift towards niche fragrances.
Reply
Reply
post #177 of 205
11/28/12 at 1:44am
  • rum
  • offline
  • Gender:
For me, Acqua di Parma's Essenza Colonia doesn't get the hype it deserves.
Reply
Reply
post #178 of 205
11/28/12 at 2:03am
Quote:
Originally Posted by rum View Post

For me, Acqua di Parma's Essenza Colonia doesn't get the hype it deserves.

I agree. Definitely the one in the main AdP line that seems to get little love, but I place it right up there with the best the line has.
Reply
Reply
post #179 of 205
11/28/12 at 3:44am
Guerlain Bois D'Armenie

where are the loves for this????
Reply
Reply
post #180 of 205
11/28/12 at 3:56am
  • rum
  • offline
  • Gender:
Quote:
Originally Posted by drseid View Post

I agree. Definitely the one in the main AdP line that seems to get little love, but I place it right up there with the best the line has.

...and a compliment getter I might add too! Some family members rave about when I'm going to wear this one again!!
Reply
Reply
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home

Features on Basenotes

Basenotes Reader Awards 2013 - Finalists Announced.
Greatest Hits: Annick Menardo
Petals Falling From The Sky - A Report From The Cote d'Azur's Bataille De Fleurs
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Fragrance Industry and General Fragrance Discussion › What is the most OVERRATED fragrance?