Tough choice, both are excellent and deserve to be in a wardrobe. In the end, I choose Tub Cri because it is more striking, angular, and perhaps more masculine. Carnal Flower, as others were saying, is however a more realistic rendition of the flower.
HdP Tubereuse 3 animale is also a good contender, but in a way it is the less tuberose-y of the group. It highlights the sweetish, decaying aspect of the flower, supported by the immortelle. So one needs to like immortelle. It is definitely the more masculine and because of the immortelle it lasts forever.
With $$$$, there's also JAR Eclair, of course.