So I made a tincture and then applied a dab to my skin to see what it smells like as it dries down. 2hrs later my skin is burning all over although I have no other signs of allergic reaction. I scrubbed the part where I applied it but have to now consider Benzoin out of the perfumers kit. Not willing to have that scary experience again. Apparently some people get blisters from it. Err...no thanks. Is the synthetic equivalent likely to also be a problem for me? Should I just consider this fragrance note a no-go?
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Fragrance DIY › Contact reaction to benzoin tincture
Recent Reviews
-
Last year I purchased "4711 - Melissa & Verbena" and was mind blown about the freshness and how long it would last. Last week I saw the whole range of 4711 on sale and immediately wanted to buy...
-
I enjoyed this fragrance because it is very unique and has amazing performance. Something I've never noticed in a fragrance that I do with this one is there are a couple of notes that "fight"...
-
This was a blind buy when I was looking for a wood scent, primarily for winter wear. I was taken a little buy surprised by the powerful blast of lemon at the outset. That transitions nicely to...
-
An older classic, that is very wearable compared to most fragrances before 1990 (if you can wear YSL Rive Gauche, you can wear this), but still seems a bit dated, and I'm not sure people under 30...
-
Sugar, cinnamon, syrup, coffee, vanilla and a little cream. That with a fresh burst of powdery lavendar, which adds to the fragrance without being distracting or dominating it. The opening is...
Contact reaction to benzoin tincture
post #2 of 10
11/7/12 at 1:03am
That is an unfortunate reaction because tincture of benzoin has been used for years to heal damaged skin. They used to soak bandages in it using the medical version.
What strength was your tincture?
What benzoin did you use and what did you tincture it in?
Have you been allergic to many perfumes before?
What strength was your tincture?
What benzoin did you use and what did you tincture it in?
Have you been allergic to many perfumes before?
Quote:
Originally Posted by mumsy 
That is an unfortunate reaction because tincture of benzoin has been used for years to heal damaged skin. They used to soak bandages in it using the medical version.
What strength was your tincture?
What benzoin did you use and what did you tincture it in?
Have you been allergic to many perfumes before?

That is an unfortunate reaction because tincture of benzoin has been used for years to heal damaged skin. They used to soak bandages in it using the medical version.
What strength was your tincture?
What benzoin did you use and what did you tincture it in?
Have you been allergic to many perfumes before?
Strength unknown dropped a small qnty of crystal unscientifically into
10mls of ethanol and tinctures till I could smell it although it wasn't strong. Maybe about
1 gm worth of crystal. Styrax benzoides labelled Siam benzoin.
I'm not an allergy prone person, never had a reaction to anything either
Commercial or EO before. But I am curiously allergic to Aloe Vera, it burns my skin.
But that's it as far as I know. So saying that I have not knowingly been exposed to actual
Benzoin before, never used friars balsam or similar. The part if my skin where I applied it
Didn't burn or colour. I put it on my wrist. But I got an intense burning sensation around my mouth and eyes. I wished my face. Thoroughly in clean water and soap but the burning sensation didn't cease for over an hour
After that. This was the only new substance I had touched that day. I read up the net about reactions to this and it appears burning and itching are often not limited to place of application. I'd test it again if it wasn't such an unpleasant experience and a tad scary. It's one for the incense burner I think.
post #4 of 10
11/7/12 at 2:10am
- David Ruskin
- offline
- Gender:

- 1,051 Posts. Joined 5/2009
- Location: North London
- Select All Posts By This User
post #5 of 10
11/7/12 at 2:58am
Illogical that it didn't burn where it was put for an allergic reaction. I would suggest it was a contaminated sample as benzoin isn't renowned for it's allergic properties. It is used in so many perfumes that if you hadn't been suffering allergies before, then it would seem unlikely it was the culprit.
You say you were dropping crystals? in an unscientific manner, and you have presumably got a small collection of materials you have been playing with there. Have you been handling something stronger when previously using your alcohol vessel? Would cross contamination not be a strong possibility?
What have you been handling in the last week or so before this?
Sorry this sounds a bit like a tell off but it isn't meant that way...
You say you were dropping crystals? in an unscientific manner, and you have presumably got a small collection of materials you have been playing with there. Have you been handling something stronger when previously using your alcohol vessel? Would cross contamination not be a strong possibility?
What have you been handling in the last week or so before this?
Sorry this sounds a bit like a tell off but it isn't meant that way...
post #6 of 10
11/7/12 at 5:04am
Sensitization due to benzoin tincture is not unheard of. It is very important though to know which species you've got: Liquidambar Orientalis (Storax) or Styrax tonkinensis or Styrax benzoin.
Here's a paper on Liquidambar Orientalis (Storax):
http://ec.europa.eu/health/ph_risk/c...ccp_o_025a.pdf
A visit to your doctor is advisable. They can prescribe you some hydrocortisone ointment that should offer some relief.If this is due to sensitization, reaction might occur more often to other fragrance materials as well.
What you can do now: keep the spot cool.
Feel better soon!
Here's a paper on Liquidambar Orientalis (Storax):
http://ec.europa.eu/health/ph_risk/c...ccp_o_025a.pdf
A visit to your doctor is advisable. They can prescribe you some hydrocortisone ointment that should offer some relief.If this is due to sensitization, reaction might occur more often to other fragrance materials as well.
What you can do now: keep the spot cool.
Feel better soon!
post #7 of 10
11/7/12 at 6:19am
I've been handling just the other standard eo's that I have. No need to worry about it being a tell-off. That's why I posted here to get others perspectives on the situation. Clearly the ideal situation is that I am simply mistaken and it was something else. Indeed in the moment I thought it was all in my head. Seemed stupid at the time but the persistence of it lead me to believe maybe it wasn't all in my head. My thoughts were similar to Irina, rather than it being a full-on allergic reaction it could have been a simple matter of this being the first time I've had contact with it, and therefore was having an immune response to it. It is an exotic species (it doesn't grow here) and I've not had the benefit of breathing in it's pollen and developing an affinity with it.
Then again, like Aloe Vera, which is known for being healing I have horrible reactions to that substance. My skin literally pulls tight, bunches up like tissue paper then peels off if I use Aloe Vera. The whole thing feels like sunburn for days. Anyway as you say, I'll see a Dr and try and sort out what this and whether or not it's that material or unrelated.
- - - Updated - - -
I've been handling just the other standard eo's that I have. No need to worry about it being a tell-off. That's why I posted here to get others perspectives on the situation. Clearly the ideal situation is that I am simply mistaken and it was something else. Indeed in the moment I thought it was all in my head. Seemed stupid at the time but the persistence of it lead me to believe maybe it wasn't all in my head. My thoughts were similar to Irina, rather than it being a full-on allergic reaction it could have been a simple matter of this being the first time I've had contact with it, and therefore was having an immune response to it. It is an exotic species (it doesn't grow here) and I've not had the benefit of breathing in it's pollen and developing an affinity with it.
Then again, like Aloe Vera, which is known for being healing I have horrible reactions to that substance. My skin literally pulls tight, bunches up like tissue paper then peels off if I use Aloe Vera. The whole thing feels like sunburn for days. Anyway as you say, I'll see a Dr and try and sort out what this and whether or not it's that material or unrelated.
Then again, like Aloe Vera, which is known for being healing I have horrible reactions to that substance. My skin literally pulls tight, bunches up like tissue paper then peels off if I use Aloe Vera. The whole thing feels like sunburn for days. Anyway as you say, I'll see a Dr and try and sort out what this and whether or not it's that material or unrelated.
- - - Updated - - -
I've been handling just the other standard eo's that I have. No need to worry about it being a tell-off. That's why I posted here to get others perspectives on the situation. Clearly the ideal situation is that I am simply mistaken and it was something else. Indeed in the moment I thought it was all in my head. Seemed stupid at the time but the persistence of it lead me to believe maybe it wasn't all in my head. My thoughts were similar to Irina, rather than it being a full-on allergic reaction it could have been a simple matter of this being the first time I've had contact with it, and therefore was having an immune response to it. It is an exotic species (it doesn't grow here) and I've not had the benefit of breathing in it's pollen and developing an affinity with it.
Then again, like Aloe Vera, which is known for being healing I have horrible reactions to that substance. My skin literally pulls tight, bunches up like tissue paper then peels off if I use Aloe Vera. The whole thing feels like sunburn for days. Anyway as you say, I'll see a Dr and try and sort out what this and whether or not it's that material or unrelated.
post #9 of 10
11/7/12 at 1:01pm
- janmeut
- offline
- Gender:

- 218 Posts. Joined 8/2006
- Location: Kampen
- Select All Posts By This User
post #10 of 10
11/7/12 at 4:37pm
- Chris Bartlett
- offline
- Gender:

- Trader Feedback: 0
- Pell Wall Perfumer
-
- 1,929 Posts. Joined 7/2011
- Location: Shropshire
- Select All Posts By This User
That wouldn't be wise - since you clearly did not have a skin contact reaction at the contact site - putting it on a burner and filling the air around you with it might induce a much worse reaction. I would see your doctor before using it again in any capacity.
Also don't eliminate the possibility that it was something else altogether - getting no reaction at the site of contact and yet a sensitisation or allergic reaction elsewhere is very unusual - I suspect the two events may be unrelated and your reaction has another cause as yet unknown.
Return Home
Back to Forum: Fragrance DIY
- Contact reaction to benzoin tincture
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Fragrance DIY › Contact reaction to benzoin tincture
Currently, there are 592 Active Users
(49 Members and 543 Guests)
Recent Discussions
- › I made a blog to answer questions for the "just starting out"... 10 minutes ago
- › COTD—how are we caffeinating today? 11 minutes ago
- › Where and when will I be able to buy the Yohji Homme relaunch in... 14 minutes ago
- › Best Carnation 30 minutes ago
- › How many different ingredients are there in a typical fragrance? 31 minutes ago
- › 24 year old looking for a signature scent 35 minutes ago
- › Where is the list of my reviews? 35 minutes ago
- › Mitsouko EDT: looks old, but from what era? 39 minutes ago
- › What men shouldn't do 45 minutes ago
- › Bleu De Chanel: Summer or Fall or winter?? 48 minutes ago
View: New Posts | All Discussions
Recent Reviews
- › Acqua Colonia Mandarine & Cardamom by 4711, 2012 by Alexey
- › Harrods Oud Patchouli by Bond No. 9, 2012 by mlsweeney
- › Artek Standard by Comme des Garçons, 2009 by Bufshuf
- › Bois Du Portugal by Creed, 1987 by noirdrakkar
- › New Haarlem by Bond No. 9, 2003 by noirdrakkar
- › Eros by Versace, 2013 by noirdrakkar
- › Ma Liberté by Jean Patou, 1987 by Andr Moreau
- › Eddie Bauer Balance by Eddie Bauer, 1996 by Carol Ann Bianco
- › Esprit De Tigre / Spirit Of The Tiger by Heeley, 200 by Buysblind
- › Chevalier D'Orsay by D'Orsay, 1911 by rbaker
View: More Reviews
New Fragrance Wikis
- › UK FiFi Award winners 2013 by Grant
- › UK FiFi Awards tonight. by Grant
- › Groups Guidelines by Grant Osborne
- › Buy, Sell, Trade Rules by Grant Osborne
- › Following And Followers by Grant Osborne
- › Search And Advanced Search Tutorial by Grant Osborne
- › Tagging Tutorial by Grant Osborne
- › Add A New Item Tutorial by Grant Osborne
- › Image And Video Tutorial by Grant Osborne
- › Subscription Tutorial by Grant Osborne
Home | Fragrance Product Guide | Forums | Fragrance Wikis | My Profile
About Basenotes | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2013 Basenotes is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle
About Basenotes | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2013 Basenotes is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle





