Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › My Top 10 Picks For Winter 2012
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

My Top 10 Picks For Winter 2012

post #1 of 63
Thread Starter 
I'm going to list my top 10 winter picks for 2012. And hopefully some of you will list yours.

Fragrances that are very strong, which often project too much in the summer, do much better in the winter since the cold air limits the projection. That said, while many summer fragrances won't project well in the cold air, most of my fall picks (such as Rive Gauche) can. All scents here are graded by their projection and longevity, in addition to their overall quality.

11th: Kouros (Sorry, I like you, but too many of the people I'm around would consider you quite the stinker.)

10 - Angel Men
This made a splash in the 90's (a decade dominated by fresh sporty scents) by challenging the consumers with Mugler's male variation of Angel. Some may find the tar note harsh, but beneath that it smooths into a vanilla-chocolate sweet gourmand (with a quality patchouli note).

9 - Sycomore
What winter list would be complete without a vetiver-based scent? And a well-made one I'll add. The vetiver in this exclusive Chanel fragrance is set into a safe pleasing floral aroma. This is easily unisex and recommendable to those who like vetiver. For those who are on a budget, I would recommend Encre Noir by Lalique, which is very similar and good in it's own right.

8 - Le Male
Who can forget the naked sailor bottle design? Lavendar, mint, vanilla, tonka bean. A known compliment getter. Some will say it's cheap, synthetic and overly sweet. Others will love it. But this is largely likeable among non-basenoters.

7 - 1 Million
Cinnamon, leather, and blood orange. It's sweet, fruit, but with darker undercurrents. Many classify it is a club-scent, but myself? I can (and enjoy to) wear this practically anywhere. Of all of my fragrances, this is probably the one that gets me the most attention. It's high on my fall list as well, because I simply love this one.

6 - Aventus
Pineapple, bergamot, apple, birchwood, and a little bit of vanilla. It's gotten a lot of hype on here, but to me, it lives up to the high standards it is saddled by. It is probably my #1 overall favorite out of every one on the list, but this work well all-year round whereas my higher picks are mostly winter-only for me.

5 - Dior Homme
Uses the "make-up" note of iris to make a powdery scent (with a smooth gourmand background) that is masculine and unlike anything else in the designer market. I like the original a little more than the intense version, but both are great. While you don't necessarily need to own both since the differences are minimal, you can't go wrong with either.

4 - M7
Amber, oud, cherry syrup smell. It's love-hate, and most non-basenoters I know weren't big fans of this. This is harsh, pungent and noxious, in the most pleasing way possible, to people looking for something daringly unique. There is no fragrance on the market exactly like this. A true masterpeice. It's a shame they had to discontinue it.

3 - Egoiste
This powerhouse by Chanel has been overshadowed by many of the more modern releases, but still, it is an unforgettable leafy woody vanilla scent that will well suit those open to more traditional tastes.

2 - Pure Malt
A boozy beer scent with the signature patchouli, that dries down into a chocolate vanilla base, that is enjoyable all the way through.

1 - New Haarlem
Pancakes, french toast, butter, syrup, sugar, coffee, vanilla. The king of gourmands. Projects better than any other fragrance I know of and lasts upwards of 14 hours. Seeing as you only need one spray per wearing, the lasting value on this well justifies the price.
post #2 of 63
Like and have the first nine in your list. Dislike the last one listed.
post #3 of 63
What I'm looking forward to:

Special mention - Histoires de Parfums -Ambrarem


10 - Comme des Garcons - Ouarzazate
9 - Gucci - Envy
8 - Profumi del Forte - Ambra Mediterranea
7 - Slumberhouse - Sova
6 - Amouage - Jubilation XXV
5 - Hermes - Ambre Narguile
4 - Amouage - Tribute
3 - Amouage - Memoir Man
2 - Frederic Malle - Portrait of a Lady
1 - Guerlain - Spiritueuse Double Vanille
post #4 of 63
10. Amouage Jubilation XXV
9. MPG Ambre Precieux
8. Bvlgari Black.
7. PDN New York
6. Hermes Bel Ami
5. L'Artisan L'Eau du Navigateur
4. L'Occitane Eau Des Baux
3. Chanel Egoiste
2. Hermes Equipage
1. Chanel Coromandel
post #5 of 63
4 seasons, 10 favourites at one time, the ones in signature
post #6 of 63
1 and 2 are on a different level than the rest for me, but here we go (only picking stuff from my collection):
1.\tDior Homme Intense
2.\tTom Ford Private Blend: Tobacco Vanille
3.\tBond no 9 New Haarlem
4.\tJean Paul Gaultier Le Male
5.\tYves Saint Laurent La Nuit de LHomme
6.\tLInstant de Guerlain Pour Homme Eau Extreme
7.\tThierry Mugler Pure Havane
8.\tVan Cleef & Arpels Midnight in Paris
9.\tPaco Rabane 1 Million
10.\tThierry Mugler A*Men
post #7 of 63
In no order...
1) musc ravageur
2) reflection man
3) creed vetiver 48
4) muscs koublai khan
5) GIT
6) l'air du desert marocain
6) chanel egoiste
7) dyptique lOmbre dans l'eau
8) creed FDTRB
9) caron puh
10) cuir ottoman
post #8 of 63
Since I don't switch scents by season, my Top 10 for Winter is the same Top 10 in my signature below...
post #9 of 63
Quote:
Originally Posted by noirdrakkar View Post

I'm going to list my top 10 winter picks for 2012. And hopefully some of you will list yours.

3 - Egoiste
This powerhouse by Chanel has been overshadowed by many of the more modern releases, but still, it is an unforgettable leafy woody vanilla scent that will well suit those open to more traditional tastes.

You are confusing with your threads sometimes.

In a previous thread you had started as,
Quote:
i don't care for the chanels - am i alone?

in which you list Egoiste as one of the Chanel's you do not care for.

And again I quote
Quote:
egoiste - i really like this one, but i don't find it wearable or versatile.

So may I ask how you list Egoiste as one of your Top 10 Winter Fragrances. You also list Sycamore, which again, you say you do not care for Chanel.

http://www.basenotes.net/threads/314...one?highlight=

I could understand if this was something over time that you learned to have a better appreciation for, but we are only talking about a couple of weeks.

- - - Updated - - -

Quote:
Originally Posted by drseid View Post

Since I don't switch scents by season, my Top 10 for Winter is the same Top 10 in my signature below...

Although we do not have a radical shift in weather by season down here, I am in complete agreement.

If that was the case, I would have to ditch literally half of my collection because it could be worn in the right temperature.
post #10 of 63
10-Creed OS
9-Amouage Memoir Woman \t\t
8-Davidoff Zino
7-Gucci pour Homme (2003)
6-Bond No. 9 New York Oud
5-Montale Black Aoud
4-Esencia Loewe
3-By Kilian Incense Oud
2-Guerlain SDV
1-CD Fahrenheit
post #11 of 63
The Afternoon of a Faun
Or Black
Sycomore
Barry Lyndon
L'Heure Defendue
Eau Sauvage Parfum
Heritage Eau de Parfum
Dioressence
JHL
Frapin 1697
post #12 of 63
not a bad list...my winter wouldn't be complete, however, without:

Burberry London
Gucci Pour Homme II
Tobacco Vanille
Rochas Man

& while I don't own them, yet, I think a "winter" list wouldn't be complete without mentioning LIDGE & YSL La Nuit
post #13 of 63
My top 10 winter list would look something like this:

1. Amouage Jubilation XXV
2. By Kilian Straight to Heaven
3. Terre d'Hermes
4. Frapin Caravelle Epicée
5. Maison Francis Kurkdjian Absolue pour le Soir
6. L'Occitane Eau des Baux
7. Le Labo Rose 31
8.Guerlain Jicky Parfum
9. Chanel Egoiste
10. Amouage Honour Man
post #14 of 63
In no particular order:
-------------------------------------

  • Egoiste by Chanel
  • Vintage M7 by Yves Saint Laurent
  • Eau des Baux by L'Occitane
  • Original A*Men, PH, and PM by Thierry Mugler
  • Envy for Men by Gucci
  • Vintage Michael for Men by Michael Kors
  • Givenchy Play Intense by Givenchy
  • L'Instant de Guerlain by Guerlain
  • Spicebomb by Viktor&Rolf
  • Tobacco Vanille by Tom Ford
  • Spiriteuese Double Vanille by Guerlain
post #15 of 63
i heard that bruce willis cologne smells pretty good....bwhahaha
post #16 of 63
1. Tobacco Vanille
2. Tuscan Leather
3. Musc Ravageur
4. Le Male
5. Dior Homme Intense
6. Rive Gauche
7. Back to Black
8. Gucci Pour Homme II
9. Pure Havane
10. L'Air Du Desert Marocain


Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk 2
post #17 of 63
I'm looking forward to breakin' out the winter frags. It's just startin' to get cold here so I can't really list a top10 yet as it would just be speculation. Fuck it. I'll speculate.

In no order:
Original Santal
Tobacco Vanille
Musc Ravageur
JXXV
DHI
Pure Malt
Ambre Narguile
New Haarlem
Pardon
LIDGE

wildcards:
La Nuit
Spicebomb
Black Afgano
Terre
Wonderwood
post #18 of 63
-



Songe d'un Bois d'Ete
Sycomore
Patou pour Homme
La Treizieme Heure
Timbuktu
Invasion Barbare

1740

Fat Electrician

Bois d'Ascese
Ormonde Man
Oud Shamash

post #19 of 63
I barely own 10 fragrances, but my favorites so far that I think will be good for winter are:

1. Tobacco Vanille
2. Pure Malt (I only have a sample)
3. Back to Black (see above^)
4. New Haarlem
5. Jubilation XXV
6. Memoir Man (sample)
7. Burberry London
8. Aventus (sort of)
post #20 of 63
For me, in no particular order:

Tobacco Vanille
Tuscan Leather
Amber Absolute
LDDM
SL Fille En Aiguilles
Byredo Accord Oud
Pure Malt
Nasomatto Pardon
Chanel Sycamore

Number 10 is to be determined, I am giving serious considering to purchasing Le Labo Vetiver 46, or Bois D'Orage. Any thoughts?
post #21 of 63
I'm not big on top ten lists since there are only 7 days in a week. It seems weird to have a winter favorite I couldn't even wear once a week. That being said... as the weather gets colder, these are a few of my current faves:

- Gucci Pour Homme 1
- Gucci Pour Homme II
- Bvlgari Black
- John Varvatos (original)
- Curve
- Fahrenheit

And a few samples I'm really enjoying. For reasons I cannot explain, I tend to usually wear samples on Mondays.

- Sombre Negra by Yosh. Really worth seeking out!!!
- Andy Warhol, by Bond. Excellent, though I wish it were less sweet.
- Molecule 01. Make sure you can smell it before you buy it.
post #22 of 63
great lists guys. I always learn new things form your posts, seeing new frags to go for
my list,
Rochas Man
Reflection Man
Burberry London
Spicebomb
Pure Malt
Pure Havane
Allure Homme Sport Eau Extreme
Le Male
DHI
Guccy Guilty
post #23 of 63
My Winter Fragrance List (In no particular Order):

Pure Malt
Le Male
Black XS L'Excess
L'Instant de Guerlain
Burberry London
Musc Ravageur
LInstant pour Homme Extreme
Chanel Egoiste
Spicebomb
1 Million
post #24 of 63
Like and have the first nine in your list. Dislike the last one listed.
post #25 of 63
Break out the orientals and the heavyweights!

1.Egoiste
2.Antaeus
3.R.E.L.
4.Dunhill '34
5.Habit Rouge
6. M.K.K.
7. L'Occitane Vetyver (for those cloudy, brooding evenings)
8. Hinoki (for those clear Zen days)
9. Himalaya (because it shines in winter)
10.Eau d'Hermès ( In case you need an excuse to howl at the moon)

Cheers,

Mario
post #26 of 63
Quote:
Originally Posted by mecindylewis View Post

Like and have the first nine in your list. Dislike the last one listed.

post #27 of 63
Quote:
Originally Posted by PalmBeach View Post

You are confusing with your threads sometimes.

In a previous thread you had started as, in which you list Egoiste as one of the Chanel's you do not care for.

And again I quote

So may I ask how you list Egoiste as one of your Top 10 Winter Fragrances. You also list Sycamore, which again, you say you do not care for Chanel.

http://www.basenotes.net/threads/314...one?highlight=

I could understand if this was something over time that you learned to have a better appreciation for, but we are only talking about a couple of weeks.

- - - Updated - - -



Although we do not have a radical shift in weather by season down here, I am in complete agreement.

If that was the case, I would have to ditch literally half of my collection because it could be worn in the right temperature.

No flaming allowed!!

- - - Updated - - -

Habit Rouge
Black Aoud
M7
PdN New York
MPG Ambre Precieux
Jubilation XXV
SpiceBomb
LIDGE
La Nuit de L'Homme
Givenchy Pi
post #28 of 63
For right now my top winter fragrances are:

Azemour
Holy Water
Liquid Night
Gaiac 10
Bois d Orage
Pure Oud
Harrod's Oud Ltd.
Silver Musk
CdG Tea
Marasciella
post #29 of 63
Check signature below vvvvvvvvvvvvvv
post #30 of 63
Vintage Tabarome
Bois D Encens
Jubilation XXV
Tribute Attar
Patou Pour Homme
Derby (reformulation)
L instant de Guerlain Pour Homme Extreme
Tonka Imperial layered with Double Vanille
Clive Christian No 1
Ambre Narguille
post #31 of 63
Quote:
Originally Posted by lanky View Post

i heard that bruce willis cologne smells pretty good....bwhahaha

He uses A*MEN Original
post #32 of 63
Preludio D'Oriente - Cale
L'Homme Sage - Divine
Costume National Pour Homme
Diptyque - Volutes EDP
Aoud Musk - Montale
LIDGE
Incense Series - CDG
Givenchy Gentleman
Santos Concentree - Cartier
Fille en Aiguilles - Serge Lutens
post #33 of 63
In no particular order:
Chergui
Versace L`Homme
Chanel Egoiste
Chanel Antaeus
YSL La Nuit De L`Homme Edp
Mugler Pure Havane
Dior Fahrenheit
Creed Green Irish Tweed
YSL M7
Dior Eau Sauvage Parfum
post #34 of 63
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by PalmBeach View Post

You are confusing with your threads sometimes.

In a previous thread you had started as, in which you list Egoiste as one of the Chanel's you do not care for.

And again I quote

So may I ask how you list Egoiste as one of your Top 10 Winter Fragrances. You also list Sycamore, which again, you say you do not care for Chanel.

http://www.basenotes.net/threads/314...one?highlight=

I could understand if this was something over time that you learned to have a better appreciation for, but we are only talking about a couple of weeks.

LOL. This post made me laugh.

I did say I liked Egoiste a lot. I do. The criticism of it was its lack of versatility and wearability. But it's much more wearable in the winter.

And I was talking about their designer line mainly - not their exclusive line.
post #35 of 63
I don't have that many winter scents...but the few I use do a great job, smell great, and always get compliments.
1. Givenchy Play Intense
2. Dior Homme
3. Diesel Fuel For Life
4. Fierce
5. Le Male
6. Prada Amber
post #36 of 63
Dhi, creed aventus, tf tobacco vanille
post #37 of 63
Puredistance M
Invasion Barbare
Bois d’Ascese
L'homme infini
Absolue pour le soir
Leather Oud
Boutonniere #7
Tribute
Egoiste Concentree
Musc Tonkin
post #38 of 63
In no particular order

1. Tobacco Vanille
2. Coromandel
3. Ambre Narguile
4. Tonka Imperiale
5. Tuscan Leather
6. Chergui
7. Portrait of a Lady
8. Pure Malt
9. Italian Cypress
10. La Nuit De L'Homme
post #39 of 63
Random order:
Tuscan Leather
New Haarlem
Pardon
LIDGE
M7
Royal Oud
Rose 31
Pure Malt
Tonka Imperiale
London
post #40 of 63
Vintage Tabarome
Chanel Egoiste
Creed Bois de Santal
Mugler Pure Havane
Bulgari Black
Tom Ford Amber Absolute
Gucci Pour Homme I
Caron Tabac Blond
Penhaligons Hammam Bouquet
Amouage Opus IV
In random order
post #41 of 63
Knize 10
NdN
IB
La Myrrhe
Santal Noble

excited to wear these in general at the moment!
post #42 of 63
10.Rochas Man
9. A* Men
8. Mandragore Pourpre
7. La Nuit Le Parfum
6. Esencia Loewe
5. Green Irish Tweed
4. Tobacco Vanille
3. EgoĂ¯ste
2. Fille en Aiguilles
1. New Haarlem
post #43 of 63
Blue Amber
Sweet Oriental Dream
Tobacco Vanilla
LIDGE
AMen
Jaipur EDP
Absolu pour le soir
Lonestar Memories
Ambra 114
1740
post #44 of 63
In no particular order,

Frapin 1697
Ambre Sultan
Aramis
Cacharel Pour Homme
Egoiste
Frapin 1270
Himalaya
Jubilation XXV
Silver Mountain Water
Tobacco Vanille
post #45 of 63
I wear all my fragrances all year round.
post #46 of 63
From my collection only
1.\tChergui
2.\tRive Gauche
3.\tL'Instant Extreme
4.\tA*Men Pure Malt
5.\tEgoiste
6.\tM7
7.\tSartorial
8.\tOrmonde Man
9.\tDior Homme
10.\tBurberry Brit

Hon. mention:
Musc Ravageur
A*Men
Arabie
Bulgari Black
Tea for Two
post #47 of 63
YSL M7
A*Men Pure Malt
Tom Ford Tobacco Vanilla
Creed Royal Oud
Tom Ford Oud Wood
Tom Ford Extreme
Tom Ford Amber Absolute
Tom Ford Tuscan Leather
post #48 of 63
French Lover
Sycomore
Bois d'Incense
Jubilation XXV
Royal Oud
Sartorial
Windsor
And offcourse gourmand supertrio:
DHI
LIDGE
TV
post #49 of 63
Shalimar (vintage Parfum de Toilette and/or vintage Parfum) by Guerlain
Egoiste by Chanel
Fille en Aiguilles by Serge Lutens
Oud Luban by Aftelier
Habit Rouge l'Extrait by Guerlain
Anima Dulcis by Arquiste
Aedes de Venustas by L'Artisan Parfumeur
Tribute and/or Jubilation XXV by Amouage
Noel au Balcon by Etat Libre d'Orange
And last but not least, Opium (vintage Parfum) and Opium Pour Homme (Edp) by Yves St. Laurent
post #50 of 63
Quote:
Originally Posted by QWERTYOP View Post

I wear all my fragrances all year round.

+1 On some cold rainy winter days I like to wear something bright to balance out the overall mood. That being said, I am much more inclined to wear "summer" scents in the winter than "winter" ones in summer.
post #51 of 63
Some of my favorite winter scents:

Richard James Saville Row
Knize Ten
Aramis Havana
Vintage Tabarome
Antaeus
Van Cleef & Arpels PH
PdNY
Varvatos
F Pour Homme Black
Gucci PH
post #52 of 63
Quote:
Originally Posted by thebeck View Post

Puredistance M
Invasion Barbare
Bois d’Ascese
L'homme infini
Absolue pour le soir
Leather Oud
Boutonniere #7
Tribute
Egoiste Concentree
Musc Tonkin

A lot of relatively new releases here. Which are your favorites out of Bois d'Ascese, L'Homme Infini, Boutonniere 7, and Musc Tonkin? I'm curious about each of these.
post #53 of 63
In no particular order

1. New Haarlem
2. Tobacco Vanille
3. Coromandel
4. Bulgari Black
5. Burberry London
6. New York Oud
7. Tonka Imperiale
8. Ambre Narguile
9. Pure Malt
10. Jeux De Peau
post #54 of 63
Here's mine

La Nuit
B*Men
Pure Havane
Antidote
Bulgari Blv
Bulgari Blv Notte
Michael Kors
New haarlem
Ferragamo Black
Boss XY ( love this one when it's rainy out)
post #55 of 63
Ambre Narguile
Musc Ravageur
Pure Havane
Opium EDP
LIDGE
New Harlem
Jil Sander Absolute
Fiori d'Ambra
DHI
Egoist
post #56 of 63
Quote:
Originally Posted by del View Post

In no particular order:
-------------------------------------

  • Egoiste by Chanel
  • Vintage M7 by Yves Saint Laurent
  • Eau des Baux by L'Occitane
  • Original A*Men, PH, and PM by Thierry Mugler
  • Envy for Men by Gucci
  • Vintage Michael for Men by Michael Kors
  • Givenchy Play Intense by Givenchy
  • L'Instant de Guerlain by Guerlain
  • Spicebomb by Viktor&Rolf
  • Tobacco Vanille by Tom Ford
  • Spiriteuese Double Vanille by Guerlain

I'd like to add L'Instant de Guerlain Pour Homme EXTREME in my list, and bump Givenchy Play Intense and Spicebomb down to 11a and 11b.
post #57 of 63
From my collection:

Vintage M7
Knize Ten EDT
Norne
Kyoto
Black Tourmaline
L'Egoiste
Vikt
Bois d'Encens
Baladin
Petroleum by HdP.
post #58 of 63
YSL - Body Kouros
YSL - M7 (vintage)
YSL - Opium pour Homme EDP
Chanel Antaeus
PdN New York
Serge Lutens-Chergui
TM Pure Malt
AdP- Colonia Essenza
HdP - Ambre Precieux
Guerlain - L'Instant pour homme Eau Extreme
post #59 of 63
dior homme intense vintage
L'Instant pour homme Eau Extreme
aventus
abercrombie fierce
acqua di gio essenza
ysl la nuit
tom ford noir
eros versace
1 million
play intense
post #60 of 63
No particular order:

  • Fille en Aiguilles
  • L'Homme Sage
  • Sycomore
  • Jubilation XXV
  • Black Tourmaline
  • Tanoke
  • CdG Original
  • Angel Men
  • Straight to Heaven
  • Orange Star
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Male Fragrance Discussion
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Male Fragrance Discussion › My Top 10 Picks For Winter 2012