I've tried all three.
Td'H Parfum -- thick and linear orange scent. I'm just not a fan of non-complex citrus scents, that have that lysol/bathroom cleaner vibe.
Opium PH EDP -- thick, smooth spice and vanilla scent. Similar to Egoiste, which I like more because it's lighter and more airy.
Vintage Dolce & Gabbana PH* -- my favorite right now; it's elegant and sexy; bright citrus opening, very well blended spices and tobacco heart notes, and semi-sweet vanilla dry down with citrus in the background throughout.
*I've also owned the first reformulated version of this (with the stamped bottle label) and its notes were sharp and all over the place.