New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Jardin D'Amalfi

post #1 of 62
Thread Starter 
So, I rarely hear people talk about this, but it is split pretty often around here. I know Jack Hunter is a fan, but what do others think of this one? I only really ask since there are only 5 reviews in the database, and it never seems to be mentioned outside of the split board. I may pick it up (via a split or something) with my new found Christmas cash, so I'd like to know the thoughts of those who have tried it or tested it. I'm a bit of a Creed fan and own five of their frags already and thought it may be a nice addition to my collection for summer/spring.

Thanks.
post #2 of 62
I like it, but my skin doesn't. I had to bail on the party for this one. It's too bad, because it's great on paper. But even my clothes seem to make it go bad. It's just one note that I really don't like. I'm not going to mention it, 'cause I don't want to ruin the show for anybody else.

On paper, it's beautiful. But I have so many Creeds that I love - especially Virgin Island Water and Aventus - there's no worries for me!
post #3 of 62
It's a fantastic scent, probably one of the best that Creed has. You most likely do not hear much about it, since until recently has only been available in the 250ml flacon @ $640.00. They now offer a 1-oz bottle at $205.00, which is quite steep seeing you can get in on a 50ml split for considerably less.

The price is most likely keeps the average person from really enjoying this fragrance.
post #4 of 62
Personally think it's a very nice scent.
post #5 of 62
This one is way too floral for me. It kind of reminds me of Light Blue from D&G.
post #6 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by hednic View Post

Personally think it's a very nice scent.

It is, but for the price Creed is charging it should be a bit more than just nice. Even the split price is ridiculous.
post #7 of 62
For now, a bit floral and the price is prohibitive. One can measure worth by the amount of enjoyment had from the experience. For me, I'm not there yet. It is a very well made beautiful fragrance, no denying that.
post #8 of 62
My top fragrance right now, I just can't get enough of it. Hopefully it won't be discontinued seeing how it's a royal exclusive.
post #9 of 62
to me this is a great scent that I would wear a lot of in the fall
post #10 of 62
I used to love this scent. However, I recently revisited a sample my brother had, and it seemed to have turned and had an off note to it - has anyone else experienced this?
post #11 of 62
Is there anyone doing a 50ml split on Jardin D'amalfi? I tried googling but the ones I found are allready closed...
post #12 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wassup100 View Post

Is there anyone doing a 50ml split on Jardin D'amalfi? I tried googling but the ones I found are allready closed...

PalmBeach is currently doing one:

http://www.basenotes.net/threads/309...reed-Nasomatto
post #13 of 62
Thanks very much for the quick response!
post #14 of 62
Thread Starter 
It's interesting re-reading this. I just picked up 30mL in a split today and wanted to see what everyone was saying. I'm really looking forward to it now!

Perhaps some people's minds have changed in the few months since this was new?
post #15 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by OctaVariuM View Post

It's interesting re-reading this. I just picked up 30mL in a split today and wanted to see what everyone was saying. I'm really looking forward to it now!

Perhaps some people's minds have changed in the few months since this was new?

It is excellent, IMO. I am no Creed fan but I certainly love this release from the house...
post #16 of 62
I now have to concur with jack hunter. It is the most beautiful scent I have ever smelled. Simply mind blowing!
post #17 of 62
It is a great scent. I was surprised by the longevity as well.
post #18 of 62
Not a fan of Creed, i admit It's a good acquisition for spring/summer, plus the longevity is great for a Creed scent.

Been enjoying it for the recent summer down here in Oz
post #19 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by hobbes22 View Post

I used to love this scent. However, I recently revisited a sample my brother had, and it seemed to have turned and had an off note to it - has anyone else experienced this?

I like it good but have experienced just a little bit synthetic and powdery note to it. Not sure if that's what you meant.
post #20 of 62
I was very excited for this one, but it turned out to be a complete let down. Longevity and projection were very poor and the scent itself was good yet not great. It seemed to have an off note, something artificial or shrill that made it sometimes unpleasant. Also, it seems a bit too floral overall.

The price is outrageous for what it is.
post #21 of 62
I really enjoy this scent, but on my wife. For me personally, it's a bit too feminine.
post #22 of 62
a nice but not outstanding fragrance ..
post #23 of 62
I never tried it, but I would love to.

I usually say to people that I have no creed, but when talking about perfumes I have to admit I have Bois du Portugal, Bois de Cedrat and Baie de Genievre. My only creeds.


Post Scriptum: Does anyone know where to buy creed samples?
post #24 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by DanielPlainview View Post

Post Scriptum: Does anyone know where to buy creed samples?

Whichever is the cheapeast from the following sources: Basenotes Sale forum, eBay, Fragrancenet, surrendertochance.com, beautyencounter.com, and fragrancevials.com.
post #25 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by DanielPlainview View Post

I never tried it, but I would love to.

I usually say to people that I have no creed, but when talking about perfumes I have to admit I have Bois du Portugal, Bois de Cedrat and Baie de Genievre. My only creeds.

How is Bois de Cedrat these days? Any noticeable changes in the formula? It used to be a heat-appropriate, pretty nice, natural-smelling lemony scent (overpriced goes without saying).
post #26 of 62
This is one of the most magnificent fragrances I have ever smelled. Incredible summertime fragrance. However, I a careful where / when I wear it, since it does lean a little bit toward the feminine side. But, damn, that is some special stuff for sure. One of the reasons I am looking forward to warmer weather.

- - - Updated - - -

Quote:
Originally Posted by EndlesslySurprised View Post

How is Bois de Cedrat these days? Any noticeable changes in the formula? It used to be a heat-appropriate, pretty nice, natural-smelling lemony scent (overpriced goes without saying).

I just purchased a flacon about a month ago of Bois de Cedrat. It was love at first sniff, so I pulled the trigger - Wasn't that much more than a 4oz bottle, so I figured "what the hell". Unfortunately, I don't have any other formulations to compare it to. Just a sample from TPC, then a purchase from Neiman Marcus. I am not sure if it is any different from batches in the past, but I don't really ever hear of Creed reformulations. All I can say for sure is that the stuff currently available is pretty nice. Maybe not completely unique, but darn nice IMO.
post #27 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by EndlesslySurprised View Post

How is Bois de Cedrat these days? Any noticeable changes in the formula? It used to be a heat-appropriate, pretty nice, natural-smelling lemony scent (overpriced goes without saying).

My Bois de Cedrat is from 2008, so I don't know if they've changed it. Whenever a person sprays it, the picture of a real lemon appears in front of his/her eyes. It is a completely perfect illusion. It is almost real. Totally natural. But the longevity is so poor...
post #28 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by DanielPlainview View Post

My Bois de Cedrat is from 2008, so I don't know if they've changed it. Whenever a person sprays it, the picture of a real lemon appears in front of his/her eyes. It is a completely perfect illusion. It is almost real. Totally natural. But the longevity is so poor...

Yeah, I recently ordered a sample of BdC on ebay. Seeing as it's still available on Creed's website and it's one of the few Creeds I haven't tried yet, it piqued my interest. From what I've been reading, it's a really nice citrus lemon scent but with horrendous longevity, disappears after a few hours. Can't wait to sample it out for myself.
post #29 of 62
ebay seller is offering 5 ml for 25 bucks and another is offering 5 ml of windsor for 30 bucks. i am intrigued.
post #30 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by CapriDog View Post

I like it good but have experienced just a little bit synthetic and powdery note to it. Not sure if that's what you meant.

No, I don't think that's it. When I sprayed it at the store, I really enjoyed the scent and didn't find it powdery in the least.

However, I had them make me a small sample, and when I sprayed it a few months later, there was this sour, almost urine-like note in the opening and mid. Very pronounced. I think the juice had turned in the little sample atomizer. I had others smell it, and they all agreed it smelled sour and strange.

As much as I enjoy it, I won't be buying it for fear that it would go bad over time. Maybe I'll get another sample and see if it stays true this time. I'm curious if anyone else has experienced this sour note in Jardin d'Amalfi.
post #31 of 62
The first 1-2 hours are beautiful, by hour 4-5 it's gone.
post #32 of 62
I can see where some are getting that tinge of a dirty note but its not enough to distract me. I do agree that this is the most beautifully stunning opening I've ever smelled and to me, it is less fem than white cologne. However, Longevity on a test strip was stellar but on skin and clothes, not so much so. I will have to wear it again. If I can't get some mileage out of it, I'm not sure if its worth the green. I'd love to have it regardless but money doesn't grow on trees and I have to make sure this has more going on for it than sheer beauty.
post #33 of 62
One of my favourites. I dont know the notes im smelling, but I enjoy it. Perhaps a little feminine.
post #34 of 62
One of the best, one of my favs.
post #35 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by JiveHippo View Post

It is, but for the price Creed is charging it should be a bit more than just nice. Even the split price is ridiculous.

$141 for 50ml shipped doesnt sound too bad at all...
post #36 of 62
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by FISS80 View Post

$141 for 50ml shipped doesnt sound too bad at all...

I got 30mL for $57 shipped.
post #37 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by OctaVariuM View Post

I got 30mL for $57 shipped.

So basically you got it for less than cost.
post #38 of 62
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by PalmBeach View Post

So basically you got it for less than cost.

I guess. There was a sale on flacons at fragrancenet, and with the 20% off it came to pretty cheap per ml for the split.
post #39 of 62
Congrats on reaching your 1000+ post.

Funny, I have never seen Creed Royal Exclusives on any site other than Creed, even Fragrancenet.
post #40 of 62
I received a sample from Surrendertochance.com. Man, this frag is one of the best I smelled from Creed since Aventus. The citrus and floral combo really does it for me. Could be considered unisex IMO. Seems like I detect some Neroli in there somewhere. Actually, it kind of reminded me of Neroli Portifino except not as sharp in the initial spray. Will have to get in on a split for this one.
post #41 of 62
One of the best summer fragrances of all time IMO
post #42 of 62
D'Amalfi is a wonderful distinct fragrance, however, for 95% of people, it's not worth the money and there are more affordable alternatives from the Creed house.
post #43 of 62
I found it really beautiful for a woman.
post #44 of 62
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sandy View Post

I found it really beautiful for a woman.

It is interesting how many people say this. I agree that it would be fine on a woman, but I see no issue with wearing it. It doesn't strike me as overtly feminine, the same way Neroli Portofino or Castile don't. To each their own.
post #45 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by OctaVariuM View Post

It is interesting how many people say this. I agree that it would be fine on a woman, but I see no issue with wearing it. It doesn't strike me as overtly feminine, the same way Neroli Portofino or Castile don't. To each their own.

Bud, there are times when we basenoters don't understand each other I've just seen that the 'best man scent ever' is Aventus. I can't see myself to list it within the best 200... it seems that not just the shape but the inside of our noses are so very different
post #46 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by Scentologist View Post

I now have to concur with jack hunter. It is the most beautiful scent I have ever smelled. Simply mind blowing!

Ditto
post #47 of 62
Creed has a winner with this one. I am looking forward to wearing this in the spring and summer months particularly. My first wear today at the office got a glowing compliment.
post #48 of 62

I smelled this fragrance a couple of months ago and really really liked it, was almost obsessed with it :-) maybe because of the price-tag (the exclusive thing about it, I don't know). Now that I was in the position to buy a 30 ml bottle I went to my local niche shop. I smelled it again (on paper) and thought that it smelled good, the salesperson also let me smell Original Cologne and Spice and Woods. Looking back I should have bought Original Cologne. It smells more natural then Jardin D'amalfi, and if you want to smell classy in the summer this is a very good pick imo. Spice and Woods smelled real good too, but I was looking for a summer fragrance, and Spice and Woods is more a fall fragrance.

 

Now I can immagine you guys know the feeling, you arrive there all hyped up like 'YES I'm finally going to have this brilliant fragrance', you smell others that smell better but since you allready wanted the one your obsessing over it seems like you can't help it, you need the item ticked off from your checklist. Well Jardin D'amalfi did just that to me. After I sprayed it on my neck (after I bought it of course ....) I smelled the off-note people are talking about, never smelled it before and don't think it's the juice going bad, it's just the scent. It smells like a cleaning product mixed with flowers :-( Now I own a 200 dollar bottle that I don't like and I keep wearing it daily in the hope that I will like it more, but a cologne you enjoy must smell at least good in the beginning. I don't see me being able to ignore the cleaning product/flower smell in the next coming months. To top it all of the bottlecap just smells bad (it's like the offnote concentrated *10, nothing gardeny to find there).

 

So for all of you that are wanting to buy this fragrance please sample first (I reached out to some people in the U.S who did splits but they didn't ship to Europe). It will save you alot of money in the end. If you want a safer but elegant fragrance for the summer try Original Cologne.

 

Ohh I really hope I will like it more as time goes by, will keep you guys posted!

post #49 of 62

try combining Aventus with Jardin d'Amalfi for a truly special blend.  (1:1)

post #50 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wassup100 View Post

I smelled this fragrance a couple of months ago and really really liked it, was almost obsessed with it :-) maybe because of the price-tag (the exclusive thing about it, I don't know). Now that I was in the position to buy a 30 ml bottle I went to my local niche shop. I smelled it again (on paper) and thought that it smelled good, the salesperson also let me smell Original Cologne and Spice and Woods. Looking back I should have bought Original Cologne. It smells more natural then Jardin D'amalfi, and if you want to smell classy in the summer this is a very good pick imo. Spice and Woods smelled real good too, but I was looking for a summer fragrance, and Spice and Woods is more a fall fragrance.

Now I can immagine you guys know the feeling, you arrive there all hyped up like 'YES I'm finally going to have this brilliant fragrance', you smell others that smell better but since you allready wanted the one your obsessing over it seems like you can't help it, you need the item ticked off from your checklist. Well Jardin D'amalfi did just that to me. After I sprayed it on my neck (after I bought it of course ....) I smelled the off-note people are talking about, never smelled it before and don't think it's the juice going bad, it's just the scent. It smells like a cleaning product mixed with flowers :-( Now I own a 200 dollar bottle that I don't like and I keep wearing it daily in the hope that I will like it more, but a cologne you enjoy must smell at least good in the beginning. I don't see me being able to ignore the cleaning product/flower smell in the next coming months. To top it all of the bottlecap just smells bad (it's like the offnote concentrated *10, nothing gardeny to find there).

So for all of you that are wanting to buy this fragrance please sample first (I reached out to some people in the U.S who did splits but they didn't ship to Europe). It will save you alot of money in the end. If you want a safer but elegant fragrance for the summer try Original Cologne.

Ohh I really hope I will like it more as time goes by, will keep you guys posted!

Sorry that your experience was less than you expected.
post #51 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wassup100 View Post

I smelled this fragrance a couple of months ago and really really liked it, was almost obsessed with it :-) maybe because of the price-tag (the exclusive thing about it, I don't know). Now that I was in the position to buy a 30 ml bottle I went to my local niche shop. I smelled it again (on paper) and thought that it smelled good, the salesperson also let me smell Original Cologne and Spice and Woods. Looking back I should have bought Original Cologne. It smells more natural then Jardin D'amalfi, and if you want to smell classy in the summer this is a very good pick imo. Spice and Woods smelled real good too, but I was looking for a summer fragrance, and Spice and Woods is more a fall fragrance.

Now I can immagine you guys know the feeling, you arrive there all hyped up like 'YES I'm finally going to have this brilliant fragrance', you smell others that smell better but since you allready wanted the one your obsessing over it seems like you can't help it, you need the item ticked off from your checklist. Well Jardin D'amalfi did just that to me. After I sprayed it on my neck (after I bought it of course ....) I smelled the off-note people are talking about, never smelled it before and don't think it's the juice going bad, it's just the scent. It smells like a cleaning product mixed with flowers :-( Now I own a 200 dollar bottle that I don't like and I keep wearing it daily in the hope that I will like it more, but a cologne you enjoy must smell at least good in the beginning. I don't see me being able to ignore the cleaning product/flower smell in the next coming months. To top it all of the bottlecap just smells bad (it's like the offnote concentrated *10, nothing gardeny to find there).

So for all of you that are wanting to buy this fragrance please sample first (I reached out to some people in the U.S who did splits but they didn't ship to Europe). It will save you alot of money in the end. If you want a safer but elegant fragrance for the summer try Original Cologne.

Ohh I really hope I will like it more as time goes by, will keep you guys posted!
I find it odd that you were able to purchase a 30ml bottle of something that is only sold in a 248ml flacon.
post #52 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by FISS80 View Post


I find it odd that you were able to purchase a 30ml bottle of something that is only sold in a 248ml flacon.

It is available in 30ml.  Check the creedboutique.com website.

post #53 of 62
---
Edited by JiveHippo - 5/27/13 at 7:42pm
post #54 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wassup100 View Post

I smelled this fragrance a couple of months ago and really really liked it, was almost obsessed with it :-) maybe because of the price-tag (the exclusive thing about it, I don't know). Now that I was in the position to buy a 30 ml bottle I went to my local niche shop. I smelled it again (on paper) and thought that it smelled good, the salesperson also let me smell Original Cologne and Spice and Woods. Looking back I should have bought Original Cologne. It smells more natural then Jardin D'amalfi, and if you want to smell classy in the summer this is a very good pick imo. Spice and Woods smelled real good too, but I was looking for a summer fragrance, and Spice and Woods is more a fall fragrance.

Now I can immagine you guys know the feeling, you arrive there all hyped up like 'YES I'm finally going to have this brilliant fragrance', you smell others that smell better but since you allready wanted the one your obsessing over it seems like you can't help it, you need the item ticked off from your checklist. Well Jardin D'amalfi did just that to me. After I sprayed it on my neck (after I bought it of course ....) I smelled the off-note people are talking about, never smelled it before and don't think it's the juice going bad, it's just the scent. It smells like a cleaning product mixed with flowers :-( Now I own a 200 dollar bottle that I don't like and I keep wearing it daily in the hope that I will like it more, but a cologne you enjoy must smell at least good in the beginning. I don't see me being able to ignore the cleaning product/flower smell in the next coming months. To top it all of the bottlecap just smells bad (it's like the offnote concentrated *10, nothing gardeny to find there).

So for all of you that are wanting to buy this fragrance please sample first (I reached out to some people in the U.S who did splits but they didn't ship to Europe). It will save you alot of money in the end. If you want a safer but elegant fragrance for the summer try Original Cologne.

Yeah, I love Pure White Cologne (formerly known as Original Cologne). JdA was too feminine for me. Got my wife a split of it and she really likes it.

Quote:
Originally Posted by FISS80 View Post

I find it odd that you were able to purchase a 30ml bottle of something that is only sold in a 248ml flacon.

Creed sells 30ml bottles of the Royal Exclusives, including Jardin d'Amalfi.
post #55 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by FISS80 View Post


I find it odd that you were able to purchase a 30ml bottle of something that is only sold in a 248ml flacon.


it also comes in a 1 oz (30 mls)

 

http://www.creedboutique.com/156-jardin-d-amalfi.html

 

oops someone already responded. I love this scent. i cant wait for it to come in a 4oz bottle (hopefully) i cant get myself to spend that much money on a flacon. Hmm the layering with Aventus is intriguing. I currently layer Aventus with VIW, but i can see this working as well.

post #56 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by CaliDude View Post

Yeah, I love Pure White Cologne (formerly known as Original Cologne). JdA was too feminine for me. Got my wife a split of it and she really likes it.
Creed sells 30ml bottles of the Royal Exclusives, including Jardin d'Amalfi.
My apologies. Thanks for setting me straight.
post #57 of 62

I'm interested in trying this one. So far I have not cared for any of the Royal Exclusives except Spice and Wood.

post #58 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by papillo View Post

Hmm the layering with Aventus is intriguing. I currently layer Aventus with VIW, but i can see this working as well.

 

i found Aventus + Virgin Island Water to be a big fat fail.

 

however, both Jardin d'Amalfi and Pure White Cologne work BRILLIANTLY with Aventus because they both have exquisite and airy top notes that sit on the bed of Aventus's musk and woody basenotes.  it makes both JdA and PWC much more masculine (for those fretting JdA's feminine tilt).

 

i was wearing Aventus+Pure White Cologne last summer at an outdoor seating area of a restaurant, waiting for my group to arrive.  a table of 4 people were about 20 feet away.  as they left, one of the girls comes up to me and asks "what is that cologne you are wearing?  it is amazing.  everyone at my table wants to know!"

 

i'm usually not a big "blender" of frags.  but these are two exceptions i make regularly, because both are examples of where the end is better than the sum of its parts (and its parts are pretty damn good on their own!).

post #59 of 62
Quote:
Originally Posted by Casablancas View Post

 

i found Aventus + Virgin Island Water to be a big fat fail.

 

however, both Jardin d'Amalfi and Pure White Cologne work BRILLIANTLY with Aventus because they both have exquisite and airy top notes that sit on the bed of Aventus's musk and woody basenotes.  it makes both JdA and PWC much more masculine (for those fretting JdA's feminine tilt).

 

i was wearing Aventus+Pure White Cologne last summer at an outdoor seating area of a restaurant, waiting for my group to arrive.  a table of 4 people were about 20 feet away.  as they left, one of the girls comes up to me and asks "what is that cologne you are wearing?  it is amazing.  everyone at my table wants to know!"

 

i'm usually not a big "blender" of frags.  but these are two exceptions i make regularly, because both are examples of where the end is better than the sum of its parts (and its parts are pretty damn good on their own!).

 

Really? i have gotten very good reviews from people on the Aventus and VIW combo. I am not a huge fan of the Ashy drydown of aventus or the predominant lime note of VIW so i hardly wear them separately.  I believe i have a sample of Pure White cologne somewhere and i will def try this layer out. 

 

Really? i have gotten very good reviews from people on the Aventus and VIW combo. I am not a huge fan of the Ashy drydown of aventus or the predominant lime note of VIW so i hardly wear them separately.  I believe i have a sample of Pure White cologne somewhere and i will def try this layer out.

post #60 of 62
I frequently blend 1:1 Aventus and Windsor, it smells absolutely amazing.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Male Fragrance Discussion