In the posting of Apr10/10 Neal lamented the rising cost of F. Malle perfumes, in particular the Vetiver Extraordinaire. The thread was resurrected yesterday, and I commented that 2010 was the good ole days, compared to the prices of Malle perfumes now. Fellow basenoter Trebor suggested that vetiver essential oil "is significantly cheaper, more potent and just as complex to wear".
I don't like to think of myself as one of "the deluded perfumistas or naive housemaids" referred to, so I set about to explore the subject of vetiver essential oil. Wickipedia, Ebay, and numerous perfume sites have yielded some information about this product (as well as a vastly divergent price range). In the perfume guide Turin states that vetiver is one of a very few scents that have never been satisfactorily synthesized.
Wikipedia indicates that the oil is distilled from the root, and that vetiver is cultivated on a large scale principally in India, Haiti, Java and Reunion. Oil from Haiti and Reunion is sweeter than the smokier oil from Java, while the wild varietal of India, known as Khus, produces a superior oil.
So to my question: does any of the Basenote community have any comments, opinions or experiences to share about Vetiver essential oil in general, or in the particular case of Vetiver Extraordinaire(F. Malle) versus vetiver essential oil? On a personal note, I think Vetiver Extraordinaire is worth every penny.
I don't like to think of myself as one of "the deluded perfumistas or naive housemaids" referred to, so I set about to explore the subject of vetiver essential oil. Wickipedia, Ebay, and numerous perfume sites have yielded some information about this product (as well as a vastly divergent price range). In the perfume guide Turin states that vetiver is one of a very few scents that have never been satisfactorily synthesized.
Wikipedia indicates that the oil is distilled from the root, and that vetiver is cultivated on a large scale principally in India, Haiti, Java and Reunion. Oil from Haiti and Reunion is sweeter than the smokier oil from Java, while the wild varietal of India, known as Khus, produces a superior oil.
So to my question: does any of the Basenote community have any comments, opinions or experiences to share about Vetiver essential oil in general, or in the particular case of Vetiver Extraordinaire(F. Malle) versus vetiver essential oil? On a personal note, I think Vetiver Extraordinaire is worth every penny.













