rank these creeds from favorite to least favorite

Millesime Imperial
Jardin d Amalfi
Original Vetiver
Green Irish Tweed
Green Valley
Taberome
Boi Du Portugal
Aventus
Spice & Wood
Original Santal
Virgin Island Water
Silver Mountain Water
Erolfa

I'll only post the ones I've tried (I added Himalaya):

Aventus
Green Irish Tweed
Himalaya
MI
OV
SMW
VIW
OS

My preference at the moment:

Silver Mountain Water
Green Irish Tweed
Virgin Island Water
Millesime Imperial
Spice and Wood
Aventus
Original Vetiver
Bois du Portugal
Erolfa
Jardin d'Amalfi
Original Santal
Tabarome Millesime

My personal ranking below... the top three are interchangeable, and I also added Himalaya in the list:
--------------------------------------------------
Silver Mountain Water (own)
Aventus (own)
Green Irish Tweed (own)
Spice and Wood (sample)
Millesime Imperial (sample)
Erolfa (sample)
Himalaya (sprayed)
Original Santal (sprayed)
Virgin Island Water (sprayed)




2598

Creed - my favorite house...

This is how I see them. In order:

love:
aventus
spice and wood
jardin d'amalfi
green irish tweed
original vetiver
virgin island water
bois du portugal
original santal


Like:
erolfa
silver mountain water


Dislike:
millesime imperial
tabarome


Have not yet tried:
green valley

Aventus
GIT
BdP
OS
OV
Himalaya
MI
VIW
Tabarome

Have not tried any other.

millesime imperial (I get so much use out of this, it is perfect in the hot Miami weather)
green irish tweed (I wear this to the office a lot)
VIW (great for casual day time wear down here)
himalaya (i use this a lot as a casual and work scent, makes me feel so clean)

aventus ( i go through phases with aventus, over all i enjoy it but dont wear it a lot, i use it as a nighttime scent)

silver mountain water (i wear it to the office from time to time, i wouldnt rebuy it)
original santal ( i enjoy it but it gets cloying in the heat and it rarely gets cool enough to wear)

original vetiver (i use it as a room spray for my office and everyone loves it)

NOT A FAN OF

erolfa (piss poor longevity)
green valley ( i like GIT better as of now)
bois du portugal ( its ok, i like other woodsy scents more)

I wished I could spray creeds as room spray

Millesime Imperial
Jardin d'Amalfi
Green Irish Tweed
Aventus
(Himalaya)
Bois du Portugal
Original Vetiver
Silver Mountain Water
Erolfa
Original Santal
Virgin Island Water

i bought a decant blind and didnt like it enough to wear

erolfa
original santal
original vetiver
himalaya
Royal Oud
Virgin Island Water
Aventus
Green Irish Tweed
Jardin d'Amalfi
Millesime Imperial
Silver Mountain Water

I'll take it!!!!!

What, no Winsor or Pure White On the list?

bois du portugal
green irish tweed
aventus
original santal
millesime imperial
silver mountain water
original vetiver
himalaya
erolfa
virgin island water
green valley
tabarome
spice and wood
jardin d'amalfi

Aventus
Erolfa
MI
GIT
Green Valley
Spice & Wood
Jardin d'Amalfi
Bois du Portugal
Original Vetiver
Himalaya
Virgin Island Water
Silver Mountain Water
Original Santal
Tabarome

You left out 2 of my favorites, Windsor and Royal Oud.

GIT
Aventus
MI
SMW
Himalaya

Might change once I'm able to try MI in hot/humid weather.

Git
aventus
mi
ov
smw
sw
od
himalaya
tabarome
erolfa
bdp
jardin

Hmmm. [pause to think] Limited to the ones I own and have had the time to wear a bit.

erolfa
himalaya
silver mtn water
original vetiver
green irish tweed
tabarome (only own the new one)

That's half representative, because a couple pf those rate close to the same for me.

Aventus
Millesime Imperial
Green Irish Tweed
Virgin Island Water
Original Vetiver
Royal Oud

Of the ones I am familiar with...

Fan of:
Aventus
GIT
Bois du Portugal

Not so much:
SMW
MI
Himalaya
VIW
Original Santal
Original Vetiver
Erolfa

Green Valley
Original Vetiver
Spice and Wood
Virgin Island Water
Green Irish Tweed
Aventus
Original Santal
Himalaya
Millesime Imperial
Silver Mountain Water
Erolfa
Tabarome Millesime
Bois du Portugal

Millesime Imperial
Green Valley
GIT
Original Vetiver
Virgin Island Water
Tabarome
Silver Mountain Water
Erolfa
Himalaya
Jardin d'Amalfi
Aventus
BdP
Spice and Wood
Original Santal

Highest Rank

virgin island water
green irish tweed

Really Good

aventus
spice and wood
jardin d'amalfi
bois du portugal

Like

silver mountain water
original santal
tabarome

Don't Care

millesime imperial
original vetiver
himalaya
erolfa
green valley

Love:

Vintage Tabarome
Angelique Encens
Windsor

Like:

....
....
....


Don't Care:

All the rest

Like:

green irish tweed
millesime imperial
silver mountain water
virgin island water

Rest I don't care for.

OV
VIW
OS
Aventus
GIT
BDP
Himilaya
SMW

Love

green irish tweed

Like

millesime imperial
himalaya

Tolerable

virgin island water
aventus

Dislike

All the others about equally with Erolfa the worst of the lot

Millesime Imperial
Silver Mountain Water
Green Irish Tweed
Aventus
Himalaya
Virgin Island Water
Original Vetiver
Original Santal

Top Group:
Vintage Tabarome*
(missing here: bois de Santal, selection verte, bois de cedrat, angelique encens, ambre *canelle, baie de geniévre, chevrefeuille, feuille verte, windsor)

Middle Group:
citrus bigarrade
millesime imperial*
green valley
green irish tweed
bois du portugal
erolfa
jardin d'amalfi
tabarome Millesime*

Less excited about:
spice and wood
virgin island water
aventus
silver mountain water
original santalrefer santal imperial
original vetiverrefer vetiver 1948
himalaya

- - - Updated - - -

Top Group:
Vintage Tabarome*
(missing here: bois de Santal, selection verte, bois de cedrat, angelique encens, ambre *canelle, baie de geniévre, chevrefeuille, feuille verte, windsor)

Middle Group:
citrus bigarrade
millesime imperial*
green valley
green irish tweed
bois du portugal
erolfa
jardin d'amalfi
tabarome Millesime*

Less excited about:
spice and wood
virgin island water
aventus
silver mountain water
original santalrefer santal imperial
original vetiverrefer vetiver 1948
himalaya

- - - Updated - - -

Top Group:
Vintage Tabarome*
(missing here: bois de Santal, selection verte, bois de cedrat, angelique encens, ambre *canelle, baie de geniévre, chevrefeuille, feuille verte, windsor)

Middle Group:
citrus bigarrade
millesime imperial*
green valley
green irish tweed
bois du portugal
erolfa
jardin d'amalfi
tabarome Millesime*

Less excited about:
spice and wood
virgin island water
aventus
silver mountain water
original santalrefer santal imperial
original vetiverrefer vetiver 1948
himalaya

- - - Updated - - -

Top Group:
Vintage Tabarome*
(missing here: bois de Santal, selection verte, bois de cedrat, angelique encens, ambre *canelle, baie de geniévre, chevrefeuille, feuille verte, windsor)

Middle Group:
citrus bigarrade
millesime imperial*
green valley
green irish tweed
bois du portugal
erolfa
jardin d'amalfi
tabarome Millesime*

Less excited about:
spice and wood
virgin island water
aventus
silver mountain water
original santalrefer santal imperial
original vetiverrefer vetiver 1948
himalaya

- - - Updated - - -

Top Group:
Vintage Tabarome*
(missing here: bois de Santal, selection verte, bois de cedrat, angelique encens, ambre *canelle, baie de geniévre, chevrefeuille, feuille verte, windsor)

Middle Group:
citrus bigarrade
millesime imperial*
green valley
green irish tweed
bois du portugal
erolfa
jardin d'amalfi
tabarome Millesime*

Less excited about:
spice and wood
virgin island water
aventus
silver mountain water
original santalrefer santal imperial
original vetiverrefer vetiver 1948
himalaya

- - - Updated - - -

Apologies, the bn site went crazy!

OK, I'll play.

Green Valley
Bois du Portugal
Aventus
Green Irish Tweed
Virgin Island Water
Spice and Wood
Millesime Imperial
Silver Mountain Water
Erolfa (while it lasts)
Tabarome Millesime
Himalaya
Original Santal
Original Vetiver

Not tried Jardin d'Amalfi.

- - - Updated - - -

OK, I'll play.

Green Valley
Bois du Portugal
Aventus
Green Irish Tweed
Virgin Island Water
Spice and Wood
Millesime Imperial
Silver Mountain Water
Erolfa (while it lasts)
Tabarome Millesime
Himalaya
Original Santal
Original Vetiver

Not tried Jardin d'Amalfi.

Aventus
Spice and Wood
Green Irish Tweed
Virgin Island Water
Bois du Portugal
Himalaya
Erolfa
Millesime Imperial
Silver Mountain Water
Original Santal
Original Vetiver
Tabarome

Haven't tried:

Green Valley
Jardin d'Amalfi

On top:
jardin d'amalfi
spice and wood
Millesime Imperial
Silver Mountain Water

... and the real champion:
Windsor

Love:

VIW
MI
GIT

Like:

SMW
original vetiver
Himalaya

Neutral:

Erolfa
Spice and Wood

Don't like:
aventus
original santal
green valley
bois du portugal
tabarome

1. bois du portugal
2. tabarome
3. silver mountain water
4. green irish tweed
5. aventus

Windsor
Jardin D'Amalfi
Selection Verte
Royal Oud
MI
OV
GIT

Aventus
SMW
VIW
GIT
MI
Tabarome
OS

Aventus
Silver Mountain Water
GIT

The rest ... ehh...