I agree with Palm Beach.
Many opinions on things like longevity, what it smells like, etc. etc. can
be very subjective. Some people say fragrances like Aventus, Jubilation XXV, and Straight to Heaven last for only 15 minutes (which at first I thought until I had worn them a few times), but have lasted me up to 24 hours, and still had people telling me I smelled good long after I was able to detect the fragrance myself.
Incognito's posts do not sound like the work of a company shill, and I perceived he just happened to find something that he considered unique, good smelling, and fairly priced for what he received.
Remember that another user also commented on the first page about its longevity:
Originally Posted by hawk
I had a sample of this a few years back, I remember it was very sweet but didn't smell cheap and more feminine than masculine. It has lots of vanilla and maybe sugar! I also remember it lasted too long and projected very well... Smelled like a "sweet vanilla bomb" but in a good way!
Considering Incognito just got a bottle of this, I wouldn't consider that there's been any change in it either, since the user Hawk tried it at least.
Let's not get squirrely and accusatory over a $20 fragrance, especially if the OP was just trying to let us in on a deal that he personally thought others would enjoy.