I have been itching to try Creed Windsor for 6 months now. I am a notorious Creed critic, I admit that I like Aventus and Love GIT, just HATE the Cheer-leading squad that accompanies them. ANYWAY I have been obsessing over Windsor for 6 months, and ALMOST blind bought a flacon, but luckily had the opportunity to try it first. I rarely give a fragrance a thumbs down, (ONLY 8% of all my 125 ratings were thumbs down) but this would rank a double thumbs down if I could...Lime cream, pine oil, eucalyptus cough drops, and a strange chemical undertone similar to what Creed Original Vetiver has. I know the Creed snobs would give a cup of muddy water a thumbs up if it came from Creed, but I judged it on its own merits, not its House. Top it off that people actually pay $600-$700 for this and it just makes it all the more tragic. If you must join the exclusive "Creed club" for heaven sake...buy Green Irish Tweed, or even Aventus...
post #1 of 51
1/16/13 at 11:44am