From the thread title, I was all set to come and berate the OP
Good thing he's just messing with us.
I think it's a great fragrance, sure enough, but there's something about it that keeps me from thinking it's a masterpiece.
I think it's the sweet chocolatey-musk drydown that does it, but hey, there's not much else out out there that does the same thing (let alone nearly as well) and its longevity and effect on the fairer sex can't be faulted, so maybe it does
deserve its reputation.
Easily an 8.5/10 fragrance for me, and I'm a hard marker.