I actually like Ciel and plan on buying a bottle...It works great down here in Florida and projects like a beast for a citrus-based fragrance...its light enough to wear as a daily scent but my wife smelled this one and Honour man and those were her two favorites out of ALL of them....She smelled Jubilation, Memoir man, Interlude Man, Epic and Reflection man and Ciel and Honour were her two favs....So, I'm going with what the wife likes on me and my skin....
What's weird about Amouage is the discrepancy between what people like and don't like....I guess why its cool to have different noses and scents that tantalize us...What smells to me like nail fungus is another person's signature scent...I think that's what's pretty cool about fragrance...