I have everything I sought, so I therefore no longer have a wish list.
My adventure into the world of deep vintage wasn't worth it. Lots of rancid bottles out there.
My favorite discontinued fragrances are
Cartier L'Essence de Must Pour Homme
Cartier Must Pour Homme
Cartier Santos Concentree
Cartier Santos Eau de Sport
Gucci No. 3
Gucci Pour Homme 2003
Hermes Eau de Cologne
And while I have great sentimentality for Gucci Nobile, I think it's basically not all that great. Since the bottle and the juice are beautiful, I have them backlit in a display case in my bathroom. It is one of the most beautifully-packaged men's fragrances of all time. Every so often I convince myself that it's ok and I put some on. And I suppose it is ok, but nothing more. It just takes me back to another time in my life, so I'll always keep some around.