I like many niche brands and love the fact that I am not at my job smelling like everyone else. I pay quite a bit more, however for these fragrances who claim they use nothing but the best, highest quality materials and ingredients, which is their way of justifying the prices they demand of us. While I go ahead and purchase the ones i have because I love the way they smell, I can't help but wonder if all of the "we only use the finest, highest quality ingredients" spill is just a bunch of BS. The houses I'm referring to are Amouage, Creed, Clive Christian, Xerjoff, etc...How can you really tell if there is something to what they propose or if we just buy into it?
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Fragrance Industry and General Fragrance Discussion › Are we all drinking the kool-aid and buying into hype?
Recent Reviews
-
In my opinion beyond love is related to carnal flower really closely but yet so different. As an example of what I'm trying to say is like Fracas had two daughters, the naughty crazy and loud...
-
Fresh, shampoo gel, aquatic, calone- style thing with a flinty drydown. Reminds me of Joop Splash a bit. It's pleasant, wearable and inoffensive and is obviously an attempt at a mainstream...
-
I find this to be so wonderfully complex. It evolves throughout the day like few other fragrances that I've tried. I have not tried the EDT, but I love the EDP so much I'm gonna stick with it....
-
This is one of those sweet fragrances that men in their late 40's are not supposed to like, but I'll wear what I darn well please! The fact that the sweetness is so beautifully balanced with...
-
I tried the "extreme" version before this one, and was neutral. Then I tried the EDT and wow! This has all of the smoothness of the extreme, but add a brightness that really sparkles (if you...
Are we all drinking the kool-aid and buying into hype?
post #2 of 27
3/5/13 at 10:45am
First off - How do you pronounce your username?
Second - Of course there's hype. We live in a world where value is judged by cost when they are two totally different things. That said, there is a distinct difference in quality between the brands you mentioned and say a Hugo Boss line but ultimately both will do their thing and both are aimed at different demographs.
Consider the main average client base to be like once in a while drug users and us high end junkies are like all day every day, give me that good ish straight in my veins kind of clientèle.
- - - Updated - - -
First off - How do you pronounce your username?
Second - Of course there's hype. We live in a world where value is judged by cost when they are two totally different things. That said, there is a distinct difference in quality between the brands you mentioned and say a Hugo Boss line but ultimately both will do their thing and both are aimed at different demographs.
Consider the main average client base to be like once in a while drug users and us high end junkies are like all day every day, give me that good ish straight in my veins kind of clientèle.
Second - Of course there's hype. We live in a world where value is judged by cost when they are two totally different things. That said, there is a distinct difference in quality between the brands you mentioned and say a Hugo Boss line but ultimately both will do their thing and both are aimed at different demographs.
Consider the main average client base to be like once in a while drug users and us high end junkies are like all day every day, give me that good ish straight in my veins kind of clientèle.
- - - Updated - - -
First off - How do you pronounce your username?
Second - Of course there's hype. We live in a world where value is judged by cost when they are two totally different things. That said, there is a distinct difference in quality between the brands you mentioned and say a Hugo Boss line but ultimately both will do their thing and both are aimed at different demographs.
Consider the main average client base to be like once in a while drug users and us high end junkies are like all day every day, give me that good ish straight in my veins kind of clientèle.
post #3 of 27
3/5/13 at 10:45am
- cacio
- offline
- Gender:

- 6,612 Posts. Joined 11/2010
- Location: Washington, DC
- Select All Posts By This User
I don't think ingredients are a big part of the story, most of the times. These brands do tend to use more naturals relative to many mainstream ones, which tend to smell very synthetic. But only up to a point. Besides, no matter how many natural materials they use, the cost of materials is just a small fraction of the price.
So my take is that one pays for the composition. Pretty much like for, say, certain luxury clothing brands. Materials are indeed better (leather, wools, etc), but that doesn't justify the difference in price. What one pays for is the design. Whether it's justified or not.
cacio
So my take is that one pays for the composition. Pretty much like for, say, certain luxury clothing brands. Materials are indeed better (leather, wools, etc), but that doesn't justify the difference in price. What one pays for is the design. Whether it's justified or not.
cacio
post #5 of 27
3/5/13 at 10:49am
Both are very good points. Thank you.
- - - Updated - - -
It's the name of an Egyptian Pharaoh and one of their deities...not that I in any way see myself as either. When asked for a username I thought it would be unique.
- - - Updated - - -
It's the name of an Egyptian Pharaoh and one of their deities...not that I in any way see myself as either. When asked for a username I thought it would be unique.
- - - Updated - - -
Nothing more than that
- - - Updated - - -
It's the name of an Egyptian Pharaoh and one of their deities...not that I in any way see myself as either. When asked for a username I thought it would be unique.
- - - Updated - - -
It's the name of an Egyptian Pharaoh and one of their deities...not that I in any way see myself as either. When asked for a username I thought it would be unique.
- - - Updated - - -
Nothing more than that
post #7 of 27
3/5/13 at 11:05am
- hednic
- offline
- Gender:

- 45,789 Posts. Joined 10/2007
- Location: United States
- Select All Posts By This User
post #9 of 27
3/5/13 at 11:22am
- L'Homme Blanc Individuel
- offline
- Gender:

- 2,120 Posts. Joined 7/2012
- Location: Portland, OR
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
In the end, it only matters if you decide it matters to YOU. For me, it doesn't matter at all. I only care about three things:
How does it smell? ...do I love it? Is it unique?
How does it wear? ...does it last on my skin? Projection/Sillage? Compliments?
How much does it cost? ...am I wiling to pay that much to own it?
People who collect perfumes will have different reasons for their purchases, but if you're like me, meaning the only reason you buy perfume is to wear it, you can ignore everything but how it smells, how it wears and how much it costs.
- - - Updated - - -
Quote:
Why think about it at all? Really, it doesn't matter. Their claims are just marketing - even when they're 100% the truth, it's just marketing. Sure, the info can be interesting or maybe even helpful, but in the end, no amount of words can make a perfume smell better if you don't enjoy it. Only your nose knows. Words have no smell, and since we're talking about perfume here, trust your nose. Hype only matters if you're one of those people for whom it's important to be part of the hype - in other words, a follower or a joiner. Be your own person. Trust your own nose.
Spray the perfume on you skin.
...how does it smell?
...how does it wear?
...how much does it cost?
- - - Updated - - -
Quote:
THIS. Hype has no smell, so no amount of hype can make a perfume better.
post #10 of 27
3/5/13 at 11:51am
- lpp
- offline
- Gender:

- 2,148 Posts. Joined 2/2010
- Location: U.K.
- Select All Posts By This User
post #11 of 27
3/5/13 at 12:27pm
- Kagey
- offline
- Gender:

- 1,463 Posts. Joined 1/2011
- Location: England
- Select All Posts By This User
I don't believe hype or claims of "high quality," "natural ingredients," etc. I've read plenty about the actual costs of creating most fragrances, and accept that marketing is largely BS. I go with what I like.
But the first thing you said is that you're glad not to smell like everyone else. That's a fair criterion for selecting a fragrance. But you should know that you don't have to pay loads of money for that privilege. There are loads of reasonably priced scents out there that you won't smell on everyone and his brother.
But the first thing you said is that you're glad not to smell like everyone else. That's a fair criterion for selecting a fragrance. But you should know that you don't have to pay loads of money for that privilege. There are loads of reasonably priced scents out there that you won't smell on everyone and his brother.
post #12 of 27
3/5/13 at 3:34pm
- forfreddie
- offline
- Gender:

- 1,725 Posts. Joined 8/2011
- Location: Birmingham
- Select All Posts By This User
post #13 of 27
3/5/13 at 3:35pm
- silentrich
- offline
- Gender:

- 3,308 Posts. Joined 5/2009
- Location: Fort Myers, FL
- Select All Posts By This User
post #14 of 27
3/5/13 at 4:26pm
- noirdrakkar
- offline
- Gender:

- 3,121 Posts. Joined 10/2011
- Select All Posts By This User
Hype does have an effect on what I sample. If it's popular, it must be for some reason. But not what I buy. I purchase bottles and decants of fragrances based on my tastes alone.
There is a reason why you guys are buying samples of Tom Ford and not DIY samples. To say you are 100% immune to hype (rather than 99%) is simply a fabrication. We, as humans, aren't perfect and there will always be time we give in to such things. I suspect those kinds of statements LBI and hednic are vanity-based. Not to say mine aren't as well.
There is a reason why you guys are buying samples of Tom Ford and not DIY samples. To say you are 100% immune to hype (rather than 99%) is simply a fabrication. We, as humans, aren't perfect and there will always be time we give in to such things. I suspect those kinds of statements LBI and hednic are vanity-based. Not to say mine aren't as well.
post #15 of 27
3/5/13 at 5:21pm
- L'Homme Blanc Individuel
- offline
- Gender:

- 2,120 Posts. Joined 7/2012
- Location: Portland, OR
- Select All Posts By This User
Quote:
Actually, the reason people aren't buying DIY samples is due to the lack of a well run marketplace. Using your example of Tom Ford: there are so many sites where one can easily find reviews, critiques, samples, etc. But there isn't a well designed and well run marketplace for DIY perfume, and that's a shame. A great way to build one would be to create a site that functions like a combination of Reddit, with its voting system and comments, and an online dating site, where people can search by criteria rather than by brand names. That sort of system would be brilliant.
Craigslist and ebay changed the world of online selling, but a different model is needed for DIY perfume. The idea of selling a DIY scent based on its name wouldn't work. It would have to be more like the app store, where descriptions and reviews are king, but it would have to be muuuuch more searchable in terms of seasons, uses, notes, etc. And honestly, I don't even know how local laws would come into play... but... that's a topic for another day.
post #16 of 27
3/5/13 at 7:15pm
- silentrich
- offline
- Gender:

- 3,308 Posts. Joined 5/2009
- Location: Fort Myers, FL
- Select All Posts By This User
post #17 of 27
3/5/13 at 8:00pm
- hedonist222
- offline
- Gender:

- 12,972 Posts. Joined 9/2010
- Location: Abu Dhabi! UAE
- Select All Posts By This User
post #18 of 27
3/6/13 at 12:09am
Quote:
Originally Posted by L'Homme Blanc Individuel 
Actually, the reason people aren't buying DIY samples is due to the lack of a well run marketplace. Using your example of Tom Ford: there are so many sites where one can easily find reviews, critiques, samples, etc. But there isn't a well designed and well run marketplace for DIY perfume, and that's a shame. A great way to build one would be to create a site that functions like a combination of Reddit, with its voting system and comments, and an online dating site, where people can search by criteria rather than by brand names. That sort of system would be brilliant.
Craigslist and ebay changed the world of online selling, but a different model is needed for DIY perfume. The idea of selling a DIY scent based on its name wouldn't work. It would have to be more like the app store, where descriptions and reviews are king, but it would have to be muuuuch more searchable in terms of seasons, uses, notes, etc. And honestly, I don't even know how local laws would come into play... but... that's a topic for another day.

Actually, the reason people aren't buying DIY samples is due to the lack of a well run marketplace. Using your example of Tom Ford: there are so many sites where one can easily find reviews, critiques, samples, etc. But there isn't a well designed and well run marketplace for DIY perfume, and that's a shame. A great way to build one would be to create a site that functions like a combination of Reddit, with its voting system and comments, and an online dating site, where people can search by criteria rather than by brand names. That sort of system would be brilliant.
Craigslist and ebay changed the world of online selling, but a different model is needed for DIY perfume. The idea of selling a DIY scent based on its name wouldn't work. It would have to be more like the app store, where descriptions and reviews are king, but it would have to be muuuuch more searchable in terms of seasons, uses, notes, etc. And honestly, I don't even know how local laws would come into play... but... that's a topic for another day.
This is a FANTASTIC idea LHBI!!!
post #19 of 27
3/6/13 at 12:35am
- Diamondflame
- offline
- Gender:

- Trader Feedback: +20
- Frag Bomb Squadron XVII
-
- 5,599 Posts. Joined 6/2009
- Location: Singapore
- Select All Posts By This User
I'm pretty certain at some point in the fragrance journey many of us have tasted the kool-aid but not necessarily to buy into the hype. Sampling allows us to evaluate a fragrance without buying a full bottle of it and decide if we like it well enough for a full purchase. You can dig up the popular well regarded or in your view 'hyped up' BN favorites, track down BNers who rate them positively, look up their wardrobe and see if they have them in their wardrobe.
Bottomline: BNers don't always buy what they like/admire.
Imo quality of ingredients is nowhere near as important as the quality of composition. In the hands of a novice the best most expensive fragrance ingredients can still smell like crap.
Bottomline: BNers don't always buy what they like/admire.
Imo quality of ingredients is nowhere near as important as the quality of composition. In the hands of a novice the best most expensive fragrance ingredients can still smell like crap.
post #20 of 27
3/6/13 at 2:21am
post #21 of 27
3/6/13 at 3:58am
- JDBIII
- offline
- Gender:

- 417 Posts. Joined 8/2005
- Location: Louisville, Kentucky
- Select All Posts By This User
post #22 of 27
3/6/13 at 12:33pm
- Russel
- offline
- Gender:

- 4,611 Posts. Joined 12/2010
- Location: London, UK
- Select All Posts By This User
post #23 of 27
3/6/13 at 1:03pm
- lilybelle
- offline
- Gender:

- 9,184 Posts. Joined 4/2008
- Location: Virginia
- Select All Posts By This User
post #24 of 27
3/6/13 at 2:01pm
- PalmBeach
- offline
- Gender:

- 1,654 Posts. Joined 4/2012
- Location: South Florida
- Select All Posts By This User
post #25 of 27
3/6/13 at 2:17pm
- Surfacing
- offline
- Gender:

- 4,072 Posts. Joined 4/2008
- Location: Canada
- Select All Posts By This User
post #26 of 27
3/6/13 at 3:31pm
- Zibeline
- offline
- Gender:

- 2,536 Posts. Joined 6/2006
- Select All Posts By This User
I think there is a lot of hype in fragrance, like anything else. Some fragrances live up to the hype, some are no better than the garden variety stuff you find at the department store. It is an individual's responsibility to make these decisions for himself. Some people do really value the name and the glory behind a fancy price tag, sometimes they trust the price more than their own taste or sense of smell.
Over the years I have caught myself drinking the kool aid, and coming perilously close to spending what a friend calls "stupid money" on fragrance. I spend enough without being swept away by the latest niche brand or designer.
I agree that it is up to your nose, but sometimes other factors weigh in.
Over the years I have caught myself drinking the kool aid, and coming perilously close to spending what a friend calls "stupid money" on fragrance. I spend enough without being swept away by the latest niche brand or designer.
I agree that it is up to your nose, but sometimes other factors weigh in.
post #27 of 27
3/6/13 at 6:53pm
- L'Homme Blanc Individuel
- offline
- Gender:

- 2,120 Posts. Joined 7/2012
- Location: Portland, OR
- Select All Posts By This User
One Billion Percent THIS.
I always laugh when I see a post with the words "is it worth it?" in the title. We each define value in our own ways, and only you can decide how much of your money a perfume is worth. For some people, it's important to be part of the herd... to be a "me too." They buy what the herd buys and they decide if a scent is worth the price based on how many of the other OMGkoolkidz want it or already own it. That's fine if it makes them happy, but it's not for me.
For me, it's all about how much I enjoy the smell and how it wears, with compliments being a huge bonus. Hype or lack of hype is irrelevant. Popularity or lack of popularity is irrelevant. It's all about the smell and the wear.
Then again, I've always been a guy who goes his own way. I don't mind if my favorite scents aren't popular or even particularly well respected here. Some are, and some really aren't. I still wear CURVE for cryinoutloud, and that thing gets slammed more often than a tennis ball... but it's easily one of my most complimented scents. I love L'Air du Desert Marocain, but I also love Corduroy by Zirh, both of which wear fantastically on me.
The trick is to remember what matters and what doesn't. Marketing is just a sales tactic, and hype is just other people's opinions (often based on other people's opinions). That's all fine and good, but for me, nothing matters more than the smell and how it wears.
To be fair, there's more than one kind of hype, and I tend to pay attention depending on where the hype is coming from. There's a huge difference between the undiscovered-gem hype and the lolz-pantydropperz hype. I love when people here hype the unknown gems - especially the affordable ones, or the best of up and coming perfumers.
Return Home
Back to Forum: Fragrance Industry and General Fragrance Discussion
- Are we all drinking the kool-aid and buying into hype?
Basenotes › Basenotes Forums › Fragrance Discussion › Fragrance Industry and General Fragrance Discussion › Are we all drinking the kool-aid and buying into hype?
Currently, there are 371 Active Users
(36 Members and 335 Guests)
Recent Discussions
- › I´ve finally tried Aventus. Here´s my verdict: 33 seconds ago
- › d_squared 1 minute ago
- › Album, EP or Song of the Day - June 2013 9 minutes ago
- › Fragrance for a first date, same-sex edition 12 minutes ago
- › SOTD: Thursday, Jume 20th, 2013 15 minutes ago
- › Parfums de Nicolai NY vs Terre d Hermes??? 16 minutes ago
- › Has anyone heard of Ron Marone? 17 minutes ago
- › something like polo blue 20 minutes ago
- › Best Vanilla Based Fragrance? 25 minutes ago
- › Bought a Creed Millesime Imperial tester, not sure if real? please... 29 minutes ago
View: New Posts | All Discussions
Recent Reviews
- › Beyond Love by By Kilian by ScentedLife
- › Amazingreen by Comme des Garçons, 2012 by Spoombung
- › Terre D'Hermès Parfum by Hermès, 2009 by Gary F
- › Rochas Man by Rochas, 1999 by Gary F
- › L'Instant De Guerlain Pour Homme by Guerlain, 2004 by Gary F
- › Horizon by Guy Laroche, 1993 by Gary F
- › Fahrenheit by Christian Dior, 1988 by Gary F
- › Égoïste / L'Égoïste by Chanel, 1990 by Gary F
- › Drakkar Noir by Guy Laroche, 1982 by Gary F
- › Déclaration by Cartier, 1998 by Gary F
View: More Reviews
New Fragrance Articles
- › Aoud by M.Micallef celebrates its Tenth... by Judith Brockless
- › Dueto Parfums release new fragrance, Citiver by Judith Brockless
- › Guerlain ‘Les Parisiennes’... by Judith Brockless
- › Iris Prima: ‘The Spirit of the Ballet. ... by Judith Brockless
- › Pell Wall Releases 1953 Pour Homme and Eau de... by Judith Brockless
- › Serge Lutens by Grant
- › An Interview with Christopher Sheldrake -... by Grant
- › Aedes de Venustas launch Iris Nazarena next... by Grant
- › UK FiFi Award winners 2013 by Grant
- › UK FiFi Awards tonight. by Grant
Home | Fragrance Product Guide | Forums | Fragrance Articles | My Profile
About Basenotes | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2013 Basenotes is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle
About Basenotes | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2013 Basenotes is powered by Huddler Fashion & Lifestyle










.