My verdict: both excellent. I voted SV better for a simple reason. I bought EdlA as a present for someone (so I didn't pick it for myself) but bought SV for me. Therefore selfishness has decided which I like better.
Both are indeed great. I've heard fellow members say neither lasts well on them, but I get fair to very good duration from notes in my SV. It isn't a sillage monster and a lot of its field flower freshness does dissipate, but I have nice mint lasting for substantial duration.
My mom got my gift of EdlA. It certainly lasts well on her. Fantastic smell. L'Artisan does eclipse so many grassy citruses with this release--easily teaching so much of the market how this should be done.
Tough choice, Tuner.