It is not very sweet at all and is a deffinately subdued with a smokey note to keep its feminine sweetness under control. I love this stuff and it is perfect for a romantic evening worn by either sex. I would never say overrated because I am one of the most crazy about this one. There is not much talk about this one at all so I don't see how many people are rating it too high. Furthermore, I have found that this one is liked by almost all people who I've been around while wearing it. I'm even wearing it now.
I would never say this is overrated because this is my love, and there is nothing to suggest it would be. You may not like it but that is your thing. Overrated... I think not... ;D