I don't have any comments on frags you haven't mentioned, Indie.
The two I like that I've tried are Versace L'Homme and Blue Jeans.
Blue Jeans reminds me a lot of D&G actually, with what I guess is the tobacco note.
Versace L'Homme is a more classic frag masculine frag with a bit of herbs in it. Definitely old-school. It reminds me of Givenchy Gentleman in the feel of the smell, but not the actual smell itself if that means anything to anybody. I think L'Homme is meant to be appreciated through its siliage. I like this one a lot... it seems to be pretty versatile and it has a lot of character as well.