From what you describe, and looking at your tastes in your wardrobe, I highly recommend that you pick up a bottle of Odeur 53 immediately. No rubber or burnt tire smell at all. It is beautiful, evasive, abstract, and completely wearable. The fragrance is absolutely unique and yet somehow conventional at the same time. It is not a fragrance that shouts “I’m wearing cologne!”, but acts more on an unconscious level. I have been wearing it for the past year in all seasons, in many contexts, and it always seems appropriate.
Odeur 71 is sharper and more challenging, and I wear it less. I suppose if I wanted to make more of a statement I might reach for this, but it has never grabbed me the way 53 has. 71 is nice, but somehow flatter and more 2 dimensional. Odeur 53 has some weird magic to it that people really respond to.