I have Marc Jacobs Men and I like it quite a bit. It is a tad close to feminine, but I don't get alot of florals when I wear it. I really like the watery accord. Sure its totally synthetic, but it smells really abstract. I like the way the water runs off the musk and fig notes. Nice and milky scent. I can't take the womens version with all of the florals, but the mens is really nice. It almost has an edible chewy quality to it. imagine a coconut flavored Starburst candy chew- thats what Marc Jacobs for Men smells like to me. I should wear this one more.
I remember when it came out. Former Basenoter and full time Carolina Herrera slave Jeffery P (see, I even spell his name right!) was anxious to try this scent. He did everything he could to get a sample as soon as he could on the date it was released...And he hated it. HATED IT! He talked so much trash on this scent, saying it smelled like old ladies (can kind of see it). He'd write stuff like, "Oh, I'll be over for bridge club in the old Buick after I put on some Marc Jacobs for men". It just slayed me. I wonder if he still hates it. He used to hate Michael for Men, and then did a 180...Who knows?