I just got these yesterday. Did you get the Ciel as well?
I thought the Gold was terrible. Eh. To each his own. The Ciel was pretty interesting, very floral, almost too much. The Dia is a bit of a disappointment, after the hype in that one thread. Maybe it's just too 'sophisticated' for me. It's certainly not terrible, though. I'd wear it if I had to. The Silver, I just don't get.....I'm going to have to try it some more.
They also sent me women's frag samples, and I think I'm more impressed with those actually.