Interesting. I have never tried 3rd Man but I need to.
The only thing that I found it similar to other than the original is Ungaro II. I reckon they are both from Jacques Polge aren't they? Of course, the original doesn't have the vanilla and neither does Ungaro II but there is some similarity there. The "dirty" citrus with depth and sensuality is the deal with both.
Now you're makin' my trigger finger itch for a blind purchase of the Caron.....!