Try Rexona Essentials for Men Aftershave Balm and Nivea for Men ExtraSensitive (in the white bottle) aftershave balm. Both are fragrance neutral and do a great job for their modest price. The former leaves you with a slightly drier look than the latter.
I tried the hideously expensive Lab Series Razor Burn Relief+, while it worked well, it didn't work any better than the other two on my skin.
The other advantage of these ones is that you can spray two or three squirts of EDT into the balm before applying it, twirl it around to mix the EDT and the balm up, and you have your own matching aftershave balm.