Unfortunately I am not quite familiar with any of those scents, except for Gautier. Nothing really points out to a specific Aqua Allegoria - so I will just give you my own recommendations:
Herba Fresca is my favourite one of all and the most original.
Gentiana is a nice and interesting floral.
Pampelune is fruity and mouthwatering pink grapefruit (unfortunately does not work on my skin though)
Lemon Fresca is really nice and fresh soapy clean citrusy.
Pivoine Magnifica and Foliflora are ok if you are into light florals, so is the Rosa Magnifica.
I think the Aroma Allegorias were discontinued though. My favouirte was the yellow one with the saffron in it. I can't remember the name as they were all quite similar (energizing, relaxing, refreshing or whatever, I can't tell the difference LOL!).