LOL - there's no doubt. The lemmings are loose.
I haven't tried any Body Shop fragrances, and have barely heard of them. Woody Sandalwood sounds wonderful though, and since you're chemistry is somewhat close to mine, I'm going to have to sample it, I'm afraid... sigh. So strange it's not long lasting with that name.
How do you control the compulsion without bankrupting the pocketbook? Others are far more experienced than me at that trick, but I buy lots of samples, primarily off ebay, Lucky Scents, Beauty Habit, Luscious Cargo, Aedes De Venustas, Perfume Bay, etc So many fragrances are eliminated at that level it becomes more manageable. But my Christmas list is large, and I've had to wait a long time to fulfill some of my perfume desires. My Want-To-Sample list is absolutely huge!
It really helped when I discovered, like you, I adore chypres. That helped me to narrow in on ones that might actually work on my skin! But then, again... I notice I now have this huge list of chypre must-tries!