I guess I'm pretty low-brow in comparison to others here, but these days I'm really enjoying Royal Frankincense by Yankee, Mexican Cocoa by Pacifica and Sexy Cinnamon by Trapp. (Unless I luck into an incredible buy on Rigauds or Diptyques -- and I do mean INCREDIBLE -- I simply refuse to pay more than $15.00 for a candle, especially in light of how many I burn. Rigaud's Chevrefeuille is a personal favorite, but I wait for my birthday to get that -- and then I sure as hell haven't paid for it myself.)
My favorite Trapp of all time is Rosemary Bouquet -- hands down, far and away. Orange Vanilla comes closer than any other, granted, but Rosemary Bouquet takes the cake every time.
Two other personal favorites that aren't too expensive are Havana and Plantation, both by Botanique.
Btw, tdi, I've burned many Tyler candles over the last few years. They're made not too far away (Texas) and are widely available here; their "throw" is phenomenal for soy-based candles; they're VERY reasonably priced; their scent selection is wide. Favorite Tylers include Diva, Hippie Chick, Goldleaves, Cinnabuns, Kathina and High Maintenance. Tyler's Orange Vanilla is disappointing for me, though, especially after my having been spoiled by Trapp's OV for so long now.
If you want a reasonably priced spice scent for the holidays, btw, I strongly recommend Yankee's Hanukkah fragrance, Festival of Lights.