HI! ╩I can only comment on Etro's Messe de Minuit.... ╩I happen to love it. ╩It is a very emotional and personal type of perfume. ╩You will hear positive and negative things about it because you usually either love it or dislike it a lot. ╩It has been said that it reminds people of churches with insence...old books...antique shops...or attics and cellars...I wear it for my personal pleasure and a lot when I go to bed. ╩ ╩Very comforting to me.