My impartial judgement: 5/5 both. Personal preference: Sage (5) over Coeur (4, maybe 3-4). When they were both new, fellow BNs seemed to have a preference for Coeur. However, L'Homme Sage was nominated as 'best new' for the internal 6th ABFA award. http://www.basenotes.net/awards/2006/mnew.htmlOriginally Posted by LushLife